Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Zkirsche

  1. There's an FE10 randomizer if you want to mix things up a bit: https://www.reddit.com/r/fireemblem/comments/ggiurk/fe10_fire_emblem_radiant_dawn_randomizer/ Obviously need an ISO of RD.
  2. I feel like we need to split up Byleth F/M. Byleth F being in top 2 is undoubtable (maybe Edelgard is better). I feel like Felix is better than Byleth M though. Felix is ORKOing enemies right off the bat, Byleth is not. If Felix is a tier worse than Ingrid for having better stats and later flying then surely Claude< Edelgard for worse stats and later flying. Edelgard gets smite faster vs pass. I don't think investment matters in this game: everyone can become pegasus by 10 and everyone can become wyvern by 20. If pass on an archer is that strong Bernie should be up a tier too, her str isn't even that much worse than Claude's lmao. I also feel like Raphael/Caspar should be near Dedue, they can go mounted but mount utility is worthless when you're that low down (they're what, the 15th best mounted units?) and Dedue's early game is better. Btw "all talk/boss interactions LTC" would be cool to see optimised.
  3. Kill the madman for winning in what I thought was a near impossible situation after the Shinori flip and our association. I was panicking hardcore LD2 because I did not expect those swaps at all. Especially the amnesiac claim working as well as it did. Apologies especially to my scumteam for losing my cool I just couldn't handle the pressure this game.
  4. Thank fucking god Refa. Also people were complaining about me tunneling since way back so I think Sully's interpretation of my actions are just wrong there.
  5. I object to my nightmare read being insubstantial? For a D1 case it's not terrible, Nightmare's reads post were bad in teh same waffly sense as Junko's except worse than Junko he didn't have a strong read. Then mackc makes a weird post ignroing JUnko because apparently he hadnt read JUnko and I call him out for it. I don't think I made these votes stating they were the strongest things ever so it's misleading to criticise them for being weak when I never presented them as such! I always wanted to lynch Junko, I even said so. @Refa
  6. Is that Sully case really what has driven this turbo? Yes my Shinori and Mackc votes were weaker than my Junko vote of course that is the case. But I could hardly push Junko any fuirther with him subbing out and I wanted to check my other suspicions at the time. Shinori's post wasn't random I asked him to make it so my vote is a follow up of that. I fundamentally disagree about my points pushing JUnko out of proportion but w/e. I think that case is mostly fueled by paranoia from my P5 game tbh. I think Paranoia is getting the better of you again Refa. Can't believe you're pulling thsi shit after antihero.
  7. He could easily be lying it was less than like 4-5 hours into phase when I left and he hadn't claimed. Even if it gets him lynched later down the line it makes sense to make a claim that noone likes lynching. Look at how successful it has been!
  8. Also felt like they weren't going to be shot at or targetted by Athena
  9. Fable because they are a solid townread who I thought would benefit greatly from a calmer one v one situation. Felt like they were getting too frustrated at the stuff in thread.
  10. God Amnesiac is the classic scum fakeclaim wtf is this why is everyone buying it.
  11. god I leave to focus on my work thinking I didn't need to worry about this game and I'm getting turbo'd. Refa wtf are you doing man what inconsistencies are there in my posts? I'm the other co-networker btw.
  12. Wow there are a lot of votes on Junko, more than I thought. Forgot this in the post above but I never really knew why Shinori was scumreading me (I thought it was solely on the fact that I commented on his post count) so that was where my problems with it started.
  13. Happy that Mack made the 180 but then he scumreads the hydra because Junko townread them and Refa scumreads them for tunneling me. I don't think Snike has really tunnelled me, nor do I think that has any relation to Refa's scumread on Snike. (Which is mainly about Snike tunnelling Athena). @Mackc2 What do you think of Athena, eclipse and Omega whose slots were all targetted by Junko at one point or another. What about the other people Junko townread? Really lazy play here but I suppose it could come from either alignment. @Fable should ask him this stuff in the QT if he doesn't in thread. Eclipse's word walls about me vs Junko feel really contrived to leave with essentially no strong opinons on either of us. Basically sheeping BBM here. To clarify some things because you seemed to have missed it but my bit about BBM is found in the spoilers here. Junko ignored this this and continued to spout that there was no way for me to interpret BBM's actions the way I did even into D2 and it was more than a little frustrating. I don't like how you ignored this too. Were you saying that Junko's actions could be explained by Apathy or your actions could be explained by Apathy? My biggest grievance with this suspicion is that I don't see why you would go through all these hoops to keep Junko null but then vote him anyway? @BBM thoughts? @Omega. what parts of eclipse's tone do you find towny? Can you give a quote for anything in particular? I thought her interactions with Zeus were some of the worst at the time you posted(and that was the only bit of paranoia I had about the slot D1, otherwise I thought she was town). I felt like Fable had genuine frustration with the slot but eclipse was sort of going through the motions of scolding him and kind of egged on other players. @Snike which of Shinori's opinions do you like and why? @Refa Does Snike's content this game not remind you of Antihero? There he tunnelled me really hard in what was a really nitpicky OMGUS but he was just angry town. Here he reads the same kind of anger at getting cased with while tunnelling Athena the same way he kind of tunnelled me. How do you think his behaviour here is different, if at all? @SullyMcGully Junko had plenty of time to defend himself before, in fact part of my grievance with him this phase was his defence of his actions D1. What do you think about my content itself? The analysis I make, the arguments that I made, the questions that I ask? Everyone suspecting someone doesn't necessarily indicate that they're scum (although tbh I don't feel very suspected right now. I think the only people with suspicions on me are Shinori, BBM and now you). @Makaze What are you thoughts on eclipse's summaries here? She does have a couple of town reads albeit not explained in great detail. ##Unvote ##Vote: Junko Should've done this yesterday.
  14. Omega I think I was one of the first to scumread nightmare after that listpost and it might've been me you were thinking of before you scumread Shinori for it. It was just a bad post at the time that wasn't paid much attention to made worse by the fact that he ended up voting me. At the time I was facing a fair amount of criticism so it felt a bit like he was piggybacking off of that. I don't think Shinori's big response to Refa really changes much it's mostly self-defence. Is there anything of Refa's not about yourself that you agree/disagree with? Why? I think my vote is better spent here for now though: ##Unvote ##Vote: Mackc2 @Mackc2 Thoughts on Junko? Is there a reason you're not engaging with Fable? @Snike I just feel like it's nitpicky I'm afraid. Why is Athena being coached now but not before when his content was bad? Can you give a general thoughts post on other people with reasoning? @BBM I expected more from you because it's a 22p game so PoEing someone down D2 is kinda ridiculous. But then you come in with a bunch of well thought out cases on eclipse and wepaons which is definitely more of what I expected. Still glossing over JB's content but he voted Mack for not commenting on Junko when he has openly admitted to not really reading me vs Junko. While I appreciate the Mackc vote @Jaybee Can you read Refa's case (page 51), my post here D1 and my post here coming into D2. The Junko posts these were scrutinising were one and two. I need to go back and re-evaluate what made me townread weapons and eclipse D1 because agreeable cases against them are building fast and furiously but I recall thinking eclipse was surefire to be town D1 and weapons to be likely town. A problem I have with eclipse is that her quote walls are huge and that is a big turn off for me.
  15. Oof I missed that post Shinori above me but I explained that it was the reads post that spurred my vote. I'll do a better read through later.
  16. @Snike What do you think of Omega and his bold entrance in large red text? I don't necessarily disagree/agree on it but it's just weird ITP spec that just isn't necessary? ITP spec in general is bad because it's hard to determine the subtlety of SK vs town play (I do think there is a difference though) and it just ends up being used to throw paranoia on an otherwise universal townread (e.g. Refa). Then to claim it is just gut is annoying. I understand the frustration at how I've handwaved them because that is what I feel about my Junko case but I can't change my opinion of it. I'm just missing the crazy scumreads on the slots. The picky stuff in particular that stood out to me is stuff like Satsuma's early suspicion over "well here's your chance for redemption" by Athena, silly stuff like that. More recently there was you harping on Athena for picking Refa when Refa is really not a bad pick (at least not in my opinion) and not that unnatural for Athena given Athena's post? You kinda just listed everyone that Athena townread and presented it as a better option than Refa. About JB, I don't really know much about the slot, but there was a post by BBM where he was just "JB's posts just aren't very good." and that shuts my brain off a bit to the case. Think I'm gonna stop talking about roles/rolespec tbh I've made my stances clear and it's gonna derail discussion too much unless I claim. W.r.t. Shinori's post, that was a post that he made after I prompted him to make it so it wasn't really a random post. I didn't like his reads list and the fact that he didn't comment on Junko at all as I've been trying to think about who Junko's scumbuddies are likely to be and stuff like that is what you have to look out for. Apparently the lack of Junko pressure is just gut which is obviously dubious. The expansive reads are a little on the basic side for my liking, stuff like people voting Bibbon (which is really just bad play rather than scummy play), Athena sheeping (sheeping isn't scummy guys), and I definitely feel like there should be more than "gut" determining your Junko read as well given everything. Has anything changed here with Refa's mega post @Shinori? I felt like he did a good job putting everything together in a bitesize piece. Would like to know what @Kaoz thinks too. As for consolidating I had to leave and the votes were pretty spread out at the time so I wanted to put it on arreal wagon and I though Bart's was better at the time. I dislike BBM's attitude towards me recently (I'm on his lynch priority just through PoE which is really bad for BBM), but his actions overall have been pretty townie. His reconsideration and self-awareness in regards to his Bibbon read early on, the fact that he was able to realise it was more frustration at playstyle looks quite good and I wish more people had that awareness. He also came into D2 kinda lost for reads and that naturally sparked him into a bunch of rereads and I feel like scum!BBM wouldn't come into the phase weak like that. Maybe I'm just overestimating him though. Not willing to lynch here for a while, just keep an eye on the slot. I thought Zeus was town right from the getgo and didn't think his actions would come from scum. I felt like the people who were casing him (e.g. Fable) were more just mad at being snarked at (there was a post from Fable that really made that clear imo) @Mackc2 Is Junko scum? I know you think I am tunneling but what do you think of my case's logic at least, ignoring that Junko didn't post much. I have to go now, will try and re-evaluate people later tonight. I still think Junko is the best lynch.
  17. Junko is scum not because of how long he voted me, or that he was suspicious of me, but the justification he uses to vote me.
  18. I've got more on the way but weapons I'm not angry at Junko for voteparking I'm angry at him for basically ignoring my comments on his attack and his weak LD1 reads. I even said in my last post that people should consider that town can votepark too before voting me on it.
  19. My motivation for this game is just gone at this point. Everyone I was looking forward to seeing responses from: Marth, Nightmare, and now Junko have all subbed out. Nightmare's claim is w/e because there might be something on top of the martyr to make it worthwhile for him to target town (assuming Refa town). @Fable what is Mackc like in the quicktopic? I don't think it's fair to say I haven't followed up because I did where I could aside from commenting on the nightmare claim. I am really really torn on Athena because rolespec implies he is scum but there are some points of contention for that. His voting behaviour LD1 is townie, none of his posts read very scummy (like, the cases against him are good but kind of nitpicky?) and he doesn't really make sense as a buddy for Junko/Nightmare given the cases they made against each other (Junko against Athena, Athena against Nightmare). @Refa @Snike who do you think Athena's buddies are and what are they doing right now? I don't know anything about Junko's meta tbh I can't really remember, I just know he was kinda flaky. I don't really want to consider 2 year old meta though, nor do I want to read up his past games. The problem with sitting on the same read is that it's really easy to make a bunch of reads ED1 but hard to maintain them or show that they evolve as scum. So if that's all someone has then it's likely it comes from scum. It also lets scum have a lot of reads which appears better than not having many. I'm kinda annoyed we didn't yesterday now. People casing me for "tunneling" should really take a step back and think to themselves what they'd do in my shoes coming into the day phase with Junko ignoring your case and mislabelling it as a misrep. I don't think it was a misplay on my part to keep pushing there. ##Unvote ##Vote: Shinori Shinori's read post here is mediocre imo. He never explained why Walrein was rubbing him the wrong way, Refa is third on gut (???). His bit about BBM is just discrediting Bibbon's townread on BBM and he is really disliking me over the day phase but of course never explains why. Would like some expansion here. I don't think JB is unmemorable now either so would like to see what he thinks of JB's new content. Mackc's push on me isn't really scummy but again he should think more about things from my perspective. Null on the slot post-nightmare but still happy with lynching it. Feeling the same way about JB as I do Athena in a way, just don't see his content as super bad but can't argue against the cases against him. Will try to read him in more detail but it's hard. Top three lynch dandidates fo me are Junko/Mackc/Shinori. Junko's read LD1 were very outdated and he accused me of misrepping him when I pointed that out. Mackc's predecessor Nightmare was scummy because of a strange LD1 vote switch and his attitude to scumhunting in general D1 and my Shinori read is explained above.
  20. Quote walls aren't the same as Eury walls. Shinori am I scummy for simply not liking the amount you've posted nor the way you've posted it?
  21. Shoutouts to Antihero LUL. I'm not gonna claim what I did. Sully wants me to claim but is voting Bibbon for claiming randomly, which is a really weird disconnect to me. Sully what happens if I was jailer and do what you say? I either claim outright or make it apparent I am a strong PR that won't ever claim. What is Bibbon trying to do as scum by claiming jailer in your opinion? Confusing slot. Weapons there's much more to my Junko case than just sheeping what Marth said. One point of contention especially was how outdated Junko's reads were (not so much now), which is scummy because it isn't actually hunting for scum to just attack people for their ED1 stuff, just pushing for a lynch. Feels like you're really misrepresenting my D1 reads there, especially since I explained in great detail what the scum intent in BBM's ED1 actions were. Who is scum btw? Top three scumreads? I don't think Weapons claiming he tracked me is over the top @Vi-astra considering that is what Sully was kind of implying. I think he did it to end confusion ("people are bad at reading between the lines" - Refa) from people like Shinori. It doesn't matter how many times you post or say these things, it's all about the time spent sitting on them. It shouldn't take you all phase to come up with 4 reads where 3 of them are based on ED1 content and the fourth is someone voting you. Making three posts doesn't excuse the posts being bad in quality and your reads staying the same in them. Those three posts were made over the course of the day so if there's no change or boost in opinions it's a big tell. ##Vote: Junko I don't care if you explained it doesn't make sense I explained why it made sense so address that please instead of substituting your own reality and version of events. Bolded shows complete lack of an attempt to think things through from my perspective. It's not about scum benefitting but I thought it was scum panicking by trying to find a counterwagon that sticks. In hindsight I guess Bart was just being earnest and had very little self-preservation but in the heat of the moment I messed up my read of his actions. I also didn't notice Snike's response to anything so if you could point me in that direction. Refa said he would sheep my logic on Junko late D1 to the point where we almost lynch him, lays into Junko hard for Junko's read on him, but then 180s because Junko has conviction? Did I miss something, why was Junko town enough to defend him before that post out of interest Refa? I thought Junko's point against Athena was good but then Athena just comes in and seemingly destroys it instantly so ??? on this slot still. More happy to lynch here than yesterday though. Need to wait to see more from Mack. @Shinori have you finished rereading yet? Thoughts on players? Can you make like a listpost or some shit I hate your quotewalls. Still need to go over everything Jb and Eury related.
  • Create New...