Jump to content

MCProductions

Member
  • Posts

    2,381
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by MCProductions

  1. 5 minutes ago, Captain Karnage said:

    Love the "BWAAAMP" in the opening of the trailer.

    Looks cool, but wasn't this a free game in Japan?

    Yes, Kaga himself pointed this out on his blog, but the costs of translation made it impossible for him to distribute the English version for free. Basically, if you buy the English version, you are not supporting Kaga himself, rather Dangen Entertainment's localization team.

  2. Praise you for this, now FE11 can actually be played like an actual Fire Emblem game for completionists and I have no need to ever play FE12, a game I hate, ever again

    Edit: Does this include the mod that adds the Online Shop items to normal gameplay?

  3. 29 minutes ago, Hero of the Fire Emblems said:

    I do think you should probably wait until the patch is released; as it turns out, the older translation inadvertently amped up the Gary Stuness of the avatar by a great deal in the prologue alone, before we’ve even gotten into the rest of the game. I’d probably wait to analyze Kris’s role compared to Marth again once we can put this out, because even at the bare minimum the more correct “one of my royal guards” is already a hell of a lot less Stuish than “my one and only Royal Guard who is the awesome one and only” that the older translation somehow (and inconsistently) got

     

    FE12 is really, really focused on Marth; Kris is pretty largely someone who Marth is propped up on (with Kris being among Lucina in the list of Marth fanclub presidents), but the older translation seems to unintentionally make this seem the other way around 90% of the time. Even in the prologue alone, 2 very important conversations concerning Marth had to be redone or completely retranslated from scratch because of how off the mark they were tonally speaking.

    Having played the game in Japanese, I legitimately can't disagree more. FE12 is Kris' game start to finish, Kris is the protagonist of 12, Marth is an important character but still plays second fiddle to the Avatar Kris, to the point where Marth is NOT EVEN PRESENT in plot crucial scenes in the remake where he was in the original, such as when the characters learn the truth of Archenea's history. There's many reasons I consider Kris the biggest sin FE has ever done, and the butchering of Marth's character and FE3's themes are big reasons why.

  4. 8 minutes ago, TriforceP said:

    The thing is, as much respect as most of us - myself included - have for Kaga and what he created, he hasn't worked on the Fire Emblem series for over 15 years. For most of us, that's longer than we've even known what Fire Emblem was. The series has moved on beyond him and his thoughts. While an interesting insight into how these games came to be, his words should no longer be taken as gospel. He left the series and moved on to do other things. I don't see why people have a hard time letting Fire Emblem doing the same to him. 

    There's a reason I don't mind Robin or even Corrin as much as I do Kris, despite them being worse implemented as self inserts than Kris, FE13 and  14 are *not remakes* and as such, they can move past the original creator's philosophies especially given the time gap. FE12, being a remake of 3, does not have that luxury, as anything it does the creators of the original would not have done, there's a difference between would not and could not, is something *also* should not do, unless you have no respect whatsoever fro the author of what your remaking and are willing to spite their efforts for the sake of the feature they have stated to be a bad idea, which if you are willing to do that, fine, but don't get shocked when people like me take offense to the remake's actions and consider it the worst version of the product due entirely to what comes to across  as malicious intent. 12 as a remake does exactly this with Kris, and say what you will about the rest of the game, I still don't like it, I can not view how Kris was implemented, regardless of anything else, as not highly offensive, and the only way to fix this is to remove him entirely. or not make 12 a remake in the first place. I would be singing a very different tune about Kris if 12 was not a remake of a Kaga game, but 12 is exactly that, and instead of doing a remake's job, it adds things the original knew were bad ideas, and just comes across as hostile to people who actually respect the original team's writing style/intentions.

  5. The Avatar in FE12, a remake of FE3, a game directed by Kaga, a man who has openly stated in an interview that self inserts in his games will never happen, so haphazardly throwing one into 12 is always going to be offensive, always. This is an objective fact. It'd be like making Metal Gear Solid a generic 3rd person shooter with little stealth and zombies, oh wait. At the end of the day, it doesn't matter *how much* you rewrite FE12, unless you completely remove Kris, like entirely remove him from existence, this game's writing will continue to be the most offensive thing from a writing standpoint the series has ever done. I appreciate the attempt to make that scene work, the problem is, if you respect Shouzou Kaga at all, this scene, or any other with Kris fundamentally cannot work by the nature of Kris being a self insert avatar in the *remake* of a game created by Kaga.  

  6. 46 minutes ago, Hekselka said:

     On the cover picture of the game you can see an obvious lord character and a noble looking girl with a staff which makes me wonder, is this a game with 2 protagonists (as in either dies it's game over) and if yes I really wonder how Kaga handles an important female character.

    Opinions on female protagonists in the FE series has been mixed after all.

    Vestaria technically has 4 protags. Zeid, Sihulatin, and their love interests. Like Tearring Saga the game follows both character's separate armies

  7. 13 minutes ago, VincentASM said:

    What am I translating? XD

    I have nothing to do with the official VS translation BTW. Although I would love to be involved, but I don't even know who's doing it...

    Not even I know, and people have actually accused me of being American Kaga I know his blog and notes so well.

    Btw Vincent, I'll need to track down the Twitter post later, but one of his Twitter posts a while back now stated the Zeid Gaiden was actually around 25 chapters long now, not the 10-15 mentioned in your news post.

  8. 53 minutes ago, VincentASM said:

    By the way, I don't think the two Gaiden games are scheduled for Summer. It's possible that the Lucca Gaiden will release in Summer, but Zeid's Gaiden probably won't be ready until next year.

    Also, there are some really cool features/additions in Zeid's Gaiden, which I'd love to talk about when I have more time...

    Thanks for the clarification, my Japanese isn't the best, so I mistook it for saying all three were releasing this summer. Rereading it now, it's clear it's more just the localized game while the Gaidens will be ready to enter the testing phase. Also Kaga apparently hired 50 playtesters. Where can I sign up for that job

    I'll update the OP to reflect this

  9. From Kaga's twitter itself, the English version of  Vestaria Saga 1 should be completed/released if nothing goes wrong this summer. Get hype people

    Edit: In addition, the Vestaria Gaiden games are near completion and will be entering the testing phase soon. The Lucca Gaiden, thanks to it being shorter, may also release this summer, while the Zeid Gaiden seems to be releasing sometime around Holiday this year or early next year if nothing goes wrong. 
     

    Does this mean the mainsite can actually have a Vestaria section now?

×
×
  • Create New...