Jump to content


New Member
  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by XnadrojX

  1. Actually this is just Kaif townmeta from what little I know, and RAD is confident so imma sheep him there.


    ##Vote: @Jester's Gestures


    Brief overview of why I didn't like him, I felt that his "conclusions" just didn't sound right? Like the one post I quoted where, "he was shooting down a possible TR on me", I didn't like because of the way that happened. It was like "RAD Why are you TRing Jordan here? FoS on you" which is pretty ???, given how he was like, TRing him a couple of pages before. I'll actually quote stuff tomorrow but I'm just going to go off what I remember of my case from the top of my head

  2. OK look, sometimes I'm just retarded, you're reading too deeply into me being dumb.

    weiner being scum makes me feel a bit better on jester, but not by that much. I still don't know who jester is, but there are people (looking at you fen) who will shade/bus teammates for weird reasons. Also the "agenda-driven" was me saying I didn't like how the post flowed, didn't feel like a conclusion and felt more of an objective to achieve.


    ##Vote: @Kaif


    it's between this and jester at this point, and jester sure as hell ain't getting any traction.


    I'm going to take my time, it's like 8v1 rn, there isn't much reason to hurry 



  3. 1 hour ago, RADicate said:

    1) the dumbtell in and of itself was a null for me (i have caught him as scum in turbos on this, but also xnad’s the type to ACTUALLY do it too sooooo)

    2) i have input on this but i want xnad’s response before i drop my own

    3) Meh.

    Walk me through your read (dumbtell notwithstandig)

    I made a response you square

  4. 1 hour ago, RADicate said:

    @XnadrojXdrop me a lynch order with reasons of your preferred lynches when you see this


    unrelated but nier automata is a wierd af game



    weinerboy > Jester's Gestures > Shinori = Bart > Kaif > RAD =  Sully > Baldrick


    weinerboy is obvious.

    I scumread Jester's Gestures from yesterday, posts felt very agenda-driven, I don't feel like their progressions are natural and make me feel like they're trying to engineer something.

    Shinori and Bart because I have no clue on them and wouldn't mind them dying.

    Kaif might go above Shinori/Bart soon but for now they're riding off the Amy D1 towniness.

    RAD because they're playing into what I imagine town RAD to be doing. Will elaborate on this if needed.

    Sully is hard, I don't really want to have them as locktown but their content is strong and I see no reason for them to die.

    Baldrick because I'm trusting everyone's read on via and assuming he's town

  5. 1 minute ago, Baldrick said:

    1. I shouldn’t have to explain that I think you were pretending to be ignorant.

    2. Unless you know fenrir does that as a mod, you shouldn’t expect it.

    3. No comment.

    Not buying it, if anyone else is respond to me.

    I think it's very fair to expect it when literally every other site I've played on does it, or at least pings you.

  6. 1 minute ago, Baldrick said:

    If you don’t want to be lynched, start by explaining why you post before checking who died overnight.

    1. Being dumb doesn't make me scum, I shouldn't need to have to explain this.

    2. I would expect to receive a "You have died" DM when I die.

    3. I forgot Mafia get nightkills

  7. In fact, many players in the game so far seems disconnected to what's really happening. It seems to just be people making their own bubbles of space and poking other people with their big cases. There's so little direct interaction, it makes me paranoid that there's a deep scum hiding somewhere engineering this "content" to be so interaction-less and mechanical. IDK if it's just me though, because it seems like RAD and maybe the weinerboy are actually trying to make real interaction and throw out gamestate ideas rather than case specific people/defend specific points.

  8. 2 hours ago, Kaif said:

    I don't know what the fuck is actually happening rn, can someone give me a quick run down to what has happened smfh.

    I would normally scumread this post, but this seems totally like something you'd do from what I've seen of you playing tbh.


    I recommend skimming through the whole game, although starting from EoD1 is ok if you really are lazy. It's only like, 20 pages of like 15 posts each? It's not that long.

  9. 9 hours ago, Jester's Gestures said:

    I'll be clear that I don't scumread Xbad, but you're telling me that you tr him 9/10 because he didn't know who died? It's not out of the realm of possibility to fake, so could you elaborate on that read? FoS RAD. 

    Via and Dunn interactions don't read as scum buddies to me, especially EOD. Care to explain how via could've possibly bussed? 

    The confidence behind this is a little off putting at first, but I can't say you haven't convinced me. 


    6 hours ago, Jester's Gestures said:

    Your unvote was formatted wrong so the script didn't catch it. My bad though because I also missed that, but it doesn't change the fact that there was no vote activity from you until page 16, even though you were quite active in the thread.
    How does me making the point make it any less of a point?

    Your reluctance to vote seems like it comes from the perspective of not wanting to draw attention.
    How convinient of you to handwave the two largest wagons. Iirc you specifically put both of them as null in a readlist.


    6 hours ago, SullyMcGully said:

    Honestly with regard to Claire I feel like I'm running up against a brick wall, so let me just say what I don't like about Claire in this game:

    It feels like she ignores/brushes off as much content directed at her as possible, especially my content. Yeah maybe that's because my content sucks, but it annoys me nonetheless. I've never understood the town intent in ignoring even posts you think are stupid, because I don't think my posts are stupid. And this has happened to me in previous games as well, it's almost always scum doing it. 

    I also feel like we aren't seeing the kind of progression I expect from Claire. What I expect from town is that at gamestart reads are weak like Marth's early reads were, but they get better as time goes on and more information is obtained. Claire's reads stood out early game as being decent, but her scope really narrowed as D1 went on and I don't feel like I've seen anything from her this phase that matches up to the promise of her early cases.

    This isn't much of a case, but I hope this explains why I feel suspicious of Claire and feel like she isn't doing the best she could be doing as town.



    ##Vote: @Jester's Gestures


    This feels soooooo agenda-driven. In fact, I think their Day 2 has been reeking of nothing but agenda so far. 


    I'm inclined to TR Sully here, they don't seem to gain anything from what they're doing rn if they're scum at all, same reasoning goes to RAD. Which puts Claire and Shinori quite far down my list, I wouldn't mind a wagon forming on one of them. 

    I'm like, quite iffy on weinerboy because his recent posts just have a feel to them that makes me not want to believe he's scum, plus I agree with quite a bit of what they said, but they still have their Day 1 bringing down their look.

    There isn't enough content for associatives since Day 1 had so many people ignore each other so much, especially re: Dunn and the people they incriminated seems to be in their own bubble, their lack of spew is probably engineered as well which is :c

  10. On 1/1/2019 at 9:44 AM, Jester's Gestures said:

    I'd prefer CFD to Athena because I feel like most of their posts have been asking questions rather than contributing themselves and I don't have any strong scumreads other than Ichigo. What's your thought process behind a supa lynch?

    This post feels pretty off to me now.

  11. >Kaif subbed in for Amy

    Did not see that coming.


    Marth is absolutely never scum here, they never needed to push Dunn at that point.

    weinerboy's most recent post ticks me off for some reason, and yeah their voting patterns are a bit sus. I'll look at that later.

  12. 5 minutes ago, Jester's Gestures said:

    I don't know you, but I've heard your name before. I'd be extremely surprised if you knew me. I'm not proud to say it, but I'm from that one chatroom on a Japanese competetive monster fighting simulator website. Yes, I do happen to go by another username.


    Your content is exactly what I would expect from a town!xbad. Iirc, you were the first person to state a non-scumread on Bart after his early antics, and that's the kind of perspective I'd expect to see. I also find that I tend to agree with you more when you are town, which I think holds true this game. Plus, you haven't done anything crazy yet. As for my identity, well, that's classified, although I wouldn't be surprised if you guessed.

    I'm not really feeling this Marth lynch. Looking at wagon build up, weinerboy was parked on Marth for a while, RAD came in with a flimsy gut-read that even he seemed unsure about. Via lynching for mostly "low effort" I think? And unless I am missing something, Ichigo straight up OMGUS votes. It doesn't come off as extremely town motivated to me.
    ##VOTE @Ichigo

    I'll be on and off (probably lurking) until deadline.

    Ew now I'm mentally checking off a list of everyone who calls me XBad.


    Also happy new years for everyone in my timezone A.K.A No One

  13. 14 hours ago, Shinori said:

    I liked a lot of marth's posts on page 7 but I don't know if Marth responded to this and I missed it or if he just ignored it.  Either way it doesn't matter too much for the most part his posts on Page 7 made me feel overall better about him.

    I most likely missed it in one of your other posts so I apologize ahead of time but; Why do you feel Claire is a better vote here over Marth?  Unless I'm misunderstanding you seem to imply you don't like what Marth is doing and in my opinion it sounds like he should be slightly worse in your eyes for this.

    I explained in some post somewhere that I had to go to lunch for like 2 hours, was a aimless retard, plonked my vote somewhere and planned to move it when I came back from lunch.

    As for why it was on Claire, they were one of the 2 major talking points at the time and I already announced that I didn't want to lynch Bart so uh, they were the first name that came to mine.

    16 hours ago, RADicate said:

    Alright xnad, lets get this out of the way just like every other game. If you are scum you should know better than to pick a fight with me :D

    That being said what about amy's read do you agree with? To me amy's comments wrt me weren't much of a read at all and more of a "get your act together and start being productive"?  

    So i'm confused as to what you see here?

    The former part makes no sense coming from a town POV, if i were to be scum, and if you were to be town, logically I would know you are town and could very easily fabricate a townread on you, why is my read on you at all AI in this scenario?

    Also if you could, walk me through your overall thoughts on amy and what about them pings you as town? 


    One day, many years from now, I'll come back and triumph over your sorry ass!

    It's not "agree" per se, more like, "whatever you said sounds good and I'm going to sheep what you're doing".


    Amy: Opened in trying to ease the game out of RVS, without really unnaturally trying to rush it like I've seen scum try to do. How do I explain, it was like they were trying to egg on something worth talking about, rather than reaching to make something look like it's worth talking about. Their follow-ups throughout the day has also been pretty good IMO, their logic always check out, which isn't really a townpoint but it makes them a lot more readable, and I feel like their posts try to gamesolve rather than push agenda. I can quote stuff if you want but I assume this is enough for you.

    16 hours ago, RADicate said:

    yeah and where you stand on marth too @XnadrojX 

    my d1 reads are lame as a general rule but ur xnad soooooooo

    My marth read is kinda like ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh, I don't really know where to stand regarding that, I can see why he's scumread because his logic does give me a few question marks, but at the same time I think most of his recent posts are like, ranging between decent to good, so I'd like, put him as Town-ish pending further re-reading.



  • Create New...