I'd hand it to Dawn. It's not as easy to jump back into for replays, but it's a more satisfying overall experience.
Path is a smooth and consistent playthrough, rarely demanding much of the player, while Dawn is a more ambitious, bumpier ride, so to speak. I love 'em both and they have their ups and downs, but Dawn's peaks make it the better game in my mind, consistency and balance be damned. It requires a lot of the player, but that just makes it more rewarding.