So I'm trying to ISO people in this hell of Too Many Posts, and I have low motivation to do it, but I'm trying anyway. I started with Rapier I guess. I've gotten to after the whole scumslip thing, and the only thing I really don't like is that he fails to come up with a scumread despite all the reactions to his wagon he should have, which from my perspective is strange since I can usually pick out a couple people I think have scummy votes on me even in hard defense. I don't really like how he completely lets ecplipse go after all that either
He's even surprised but he doesn't analyze it nor does he seem to have a read on eclipse. When he finally does read Eclipse, he sides with Eclipse esp between me and her, which I guess to me doesn't make sense to me since it felt like he didn't really read my case but I dunno. Despite that he doesn't really find me scummy either, which I guess just confuses me more since every post on me has a different read (this is more noticable then the other reads he has) but never seems to lean too far in any direction with it. Anyway yeah finishing that I don't really know how to read him. He has a few oddities with his posts but nothing explicitly scummy enough to throw a case at. I don't even see the tone thing I mentioned before (albeit that doesn't mean much).
The only problem is that he doesn't really have a lot of concrete scumreads on people it seems like, even though he really should, and he kind of just focuses on Elie eventually like everyone else does and jumps to that. He notes lots of problems with Refa tunneling him but fails to do much about it. I guess maybe he could be scum because of this? It would be worth a vote at least.