Best prf weapon overall? *NEW POLLS WOO*

[Batter the Beast]

We certainly need a poll for best prfs. They have the edge in availability and such compared to the legendary weapons.

Because someone suggested it in the "Best Lord's person weapon" thread and I don't see it anywhere. No real rating criteria just pick which one you like the best or which you think is objectively the best. I'll probably do another poll in like a week or something using this poll's results for best overall prf weapon. To prevent any arguments, a prf weapon is defined as a weapon that can only be used by a certain group of units or one unit as per the FE wiki's definition

Shout-outs to FE5 and FE10 for having way too many prf weapons like holy crap

Also Misstletainn isn't included cause I hit the option cap for swords but who likes this weapon besides Owain am I right (please don't actually like this weapon)

EDIT: New polls have been added! Here are the results of the previous poll:

Swords:

Tyrfing: 19/73 (26.03%)

Binding Blade: 10/73 (13.70%)

Balmung: 9/73 (12.33%)

Ragnell: 8/73 (10.96%)

Mystletainn: 6/73 (8.22%)

Amiti: 5/73 (6.85%)

Rapier/Noble Rapier: 3/73 (4.11%)

Light Sword: 3/73 (4.11%)

Earth Sword: 3/73 (4.11%)

Falchion/Exalted Falchion: 2/73 (2.74%)

Mareeta's Sword 1/73 (1.37%)

Durandal: 1/73 (1.37%)

Sol Katti: 1/73 (1.37%)

Sieglinde: 1/73 (1.37%)

Regal Sword: 1/73 (1.37%)

Holy Sword: 0/73 (0.00%)

Beo Sword: 0/73 (0.00%)

Blaggi Sword: 0/73 (0.00%)

Caladbolg: 0/73 (0.00%)

Florette: 0/73 (0.00%)

Axes

Pugi: 39/73 (53.42%)

Wolf Beil: 15/73 (20.55%)

Armads: 13/73 (17.81%)

Tarvos: 3/73 (4.11%)

Wolf Berg: 3/73 (4.11%)

Lances

Wing Spear: 35/73 (47.95%)

Brave Lance: 12/73 (16.44%)

Reginleif 11/73 (15.07%)

Gáe Bolg: 8/73 (10.96%)

Siegmund: 6/73 (8.22%)

Dragon Lance: 1/73 (1.37%)

Bow

Yewfelle: 56/73 (76.71%)

Lughnasadh: 14/73 (19.18%)

Rolf's Bow: 3/73 (4.11%)

Magic

Forseti 38/73 (52.05%)

Book of Naga: 11/73 (15.07%)

Grafcalibur: 7/73 (9.59%)

Thani: 6/73 (8.22%)

Excalibur: 4/73 (5.48%)

Forblaze: 4/73 (5.48%)

Aura: 1/73 (1.37%)

Dime Thunder: 1/73 (1.37%)

Cymbeline: 1/73 (1.37%)

Edited February 4, 2015 by The Batter

[Klokinator]

Earth Sword (It fucking DRAINS HP MOTHER FUCKERS)

Armads because dat twirl critical

Brave Lance from FE5 because you can rape half the game with it

Idk about bows I just picked Yewfelle because it's FE4 and prolly OP

FORSETI IS CLEARLY THE GREATEST MAGIC

[eclipse]

Sword - Say what you will, a forged Rapier rocks.

Axe - Tarvos makes Nolan awesome.

Lance - WIN SPEAR

Bow - I chose Yewfelle 'cause the other options were terrible.

Tome - Forseti blows the everliving crap out of everything else.

[Jiac]

Sword - Binding Blade

I would've said Mani Katti, Durandal or Sieglinde but I really love the Binding Blade since fire.

Axe - Wolf Beil

I would've said Armads but you had to be conservative with it in FE 6 and you only got to use it in the last chapter of FE 7. Wolf Beil being Hector's favorite axe and it's usefulness for me is why I chose and remember it.

Lance - Siegmund

Could've done Reginleif because name, but I remember how much an impact the Siegmund did in terms of damage for Ephraim when I played FE 8.

Tome - Forblaze

Athos' mighty tome, Lilina + Athos' tome GG. Also GBA bias C:

[Topazd]

Amiti because Elincia bias. Pugi, Wing Spear and Forseti were easy choices.

Lughnasadh is a pretty decent weapon by itself, but is forever condemned to be used only by Leonardo, and therefore somewhat undermined. Thus I'll have to pick Yewfelle.

Edited January 25, 2015 by Topazd255

[bookofholsety]

FORSETI IS CLEARLY THE GREATEST MAGIC

^

(my other votes were the binding blade, pugi, gáe bolg and yewfelle but who cares about those forseti is the important part)

[RJWalker]

Sword: Tyrfing because the poll grouped Marth's Falchion and Crumb's Failchion into the same option.

Axe: Pugi. Not even close.

Lance: Dragon Lance

Bow: Yewfelle

Magic: Forseti because Forseti.

[DragonLord]

Sword: Tyrfing

Axe: Pugi

Lance: Gae Bolg

Bow: Yewfelle

Magic: Forseti

[Ownagepuffs]

I wouldn't really count legendary weapons as prf weapons. With that in mind.

Mareeta's Sword for Swords. Awareness, 20% crit, Brave Effect.

Pugi for axes.

Finn's Brave Lance for Lances

Lughsjdhehh for bows I can never spell that shit.

Grafcalibur for tomes. A killing edge that hits res? Yes.

It is no coincidence that almost every weapon is from Thracia 776

[Emeraldfox]

Ragnell - I named an Arcanine Ragnell, she got work done. Like the sword

Gae Bolg - Is great, and I like defense bonuses

Armads - Has a cool name

Lughnasadh - A legendary bow used by a legendary Archer(more like Sniper by the time he gets it hehe)

Thani - Micaiah uses it

[riariadne]

Gaiden also has a Regal Sword and it is extremely good (though nothing like the FE9 one), not that anyone other than me would vote it.

[BBM]

I don't think it's correct to group all Rapiers, all Falchions, etc together? I mean, even Elincia's Amiti varies from meh to amazing from FE9 to FE10; there's much more variance for the first two.

[Irysa]

Binding Blade because FIRE and 1-2 18 mt effective weapon is funny as shit. Pugi because 30 crit accurate 1-2. Wing Spear because it wins the game. Yewfelle beacuse fuck Leonardo and fuck Rolf, even if I haven't played FE4. Excalibur because Merric is the best wingman.

[CT075]

tyrfing, pugi, wing spear

i don't think anything can come even close to the majesty of forseti

[dondon151]

i see your forseti and raise you a graphcalibur

[Klokinator]

Forseti was badass in two games. Graphcalibur was really good in one.

I think we all know the winner here.

[dondon151]

graphcalibur is about as strong as the wing spear

[BrightBow]

I'm not too much of a fan of Grafcalibur. I mean, it's badass but it would be a lot more useful if Asvell could take two hits of a Master Lance to his face.

[dondon151]

yeah but he can just dodge one of the hits

master weapons have pretty poor hit and asvel has some good avo

[Batter the Beast]

I don't think it's correct to group all Rapiers, all Falchions, etc together? I mean, even Elincia's Amiti varies from meh to amazing from FE9 to FE10; there's much more variance for the first two.

Yeah but the poll for swords hit the cap with what I had there and the question cap was just enough to fit all weapon types. Otherwise yeah I would have done the weapons by game since I know that, for example, the rapier is far more useful in FE11 than FE6. Anywho since I forgot to share my opinion when I voted

Sword - Mystletainn: It's been a while since I've played FE4 but you get this weapon for 4 and a half chapters on a mounted unit for free and its an offensive juggernaut of a weapon with 20 skl + crit and 30 might

Axe - Pugi: It was between this and Tarvos but Orsin gets to wreck several indoor chapters with this thing while Nolan doesn't really wreck anything in DB chapters though he does the best out of the non-promoted DB units except maybe boosted Jill

Lance - Wing Spear: Thank god this thing exists to make FE11 H5 that much less difficult

Bow - Yewfelle: All the options suck but Briggid/Faval are more usable than Rolf and Leonard

Magic - Grafcalibur: The bane of FE5 bosses pre chapter 24 where Forseti bumps it out. Still, being extremely useful for almost the entire game is a huge plus

[Xator Nova]

Ragnell, Pugi, Wing Spear, Graphcalibur

[Ownagepuffs]

Oh wait. Maybe I should change my lance vote to Wing Spear since it really does snap FE11 in half.

[JSND Alter Dragon Boner]

Sword - Rapier(FE1). 15 MT weapon that can be bought everywhere. I honestly think this one's the best simply because other prf sword isn't around for that long, or just not as efffective.

Semi Honorable mention for Sigurd Silver Sword, which would otherwise own this poll if Alviss did not forget to label the sword with "for Sigurd only"

Axe: Pugi

Lance: W1N 5P34R

Bow: Yewfelle

Magic: Grafcalibur

Edited January 25, 2015 by JSND

[Quintessence]

Sword: Tyrfing

Axe: Wolf Beil, mostly because haven't played Thracia, and I find it to be more useful than the others.

Lance: Wing Spear

Bow: Ichival, because it is far more useful than lolRolf Bow and Lughnasadh

Tomes: Book of Naga, becuase I'm a scrub that didn't got Forseti on my first playthrough on FE4 8X and haven't played Thracia so yeah.

[Ϲharlie]

Sword: Mystletainn

Axe: Pugi

Lance: Wing Spear

Bow: Yewfelle

Magic: Graphcalibur

There is no option for prf staves, but I would vote for the thief staff if there was.