Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Peter The Cool

Nabarl vs Karel

Nabarl vs Karel  

27 members have voted

  1. 1. Nabarl vs Karel

    • Nabarl
      14
    • Karel
      13


Recommended Posts

-Both have to be Level 20 Swordmaster (caps same as game)

-FE 6 Karel vs FE 12 Nabarl (They are stronger.) Well FE 7 Karel 2 more Spd, but over all FE 6 Karel is better

-Karel uses Wo dao

-Nabarl uses Killing Edge

Things that don't count:

-Awakening

-Stat boosters

-Any Items

-Supports

-Any thing outside out the battle.

Edited by London Hargrove

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Who would win and why?

Calculations of course

Prime FE12 Navarre wins on each itteration of karel

Im using for my calculations 20/20 FE6 karel ane 20/20 fe7 karel via averages rounded down or up traditionaly and FE12 20/20 navvaru

This uses Binding Blade+30 Innate Crit on Swordmasters and FE6 Weaponry

[email protected] 20/20:

HP:46 Str:21 Skl:29 Spd:24 Luck:19 Def:16 Res:14

[email protected] 20/20:

HP:39 Str:20 Skl:29 Spd:26 Luck:19 Def:14 Res:14

[email protected] 20/20 SM:

HP:57 Str:24 Skl:29 Spd:30 Luck:29 Def:16 Res:5

If you really want a battle we have Wo Dao Karel VS Killing Edge Nabarl

Binding blade calcs:

Nabarls Battle Stats:

Atk:33 Hit:143 Crit:74 Avoid:109 Critical Evade:29

[email protected] Battle Stats:

Atk:29 Hit:138 Crit:84 Avoid:87 Critical Evade:19

[email protected] Battle Stats:

Atk:28 Hit:138 Crit:84 Avoid:91 Critical Evade:19

Edit:Calcs

[email protected]/FE7 Displayed Hit on Nabarl:

138-109=29 Displayed Hit

Nabarls Displayed Hit on [email protected]/FE6:

143-91=52 Displayed hit on FE7 Karel

143-87=56 Displayed hit on FE6 Karel

Nabarls Displayed Crit on the Karel duo:

74-19=55

Karels FE6/FE7 Displayed Crit on Nabarl:

84-29=55

Nabarl True Hit:

61.72% On FE6 Karel

54.40% On FE7 Karel

Karels True Hit:

17.11% On Nabarl

Everyones True Crit:

59.95% True Crit

The damage Nabarl takes from the Karels critical and non critical:

28-16=12

29-16=13

12x3=36 2HKO on critical

13x3=39 2HKO on critical

The damage Nabarl inflicts on Karel critical and non critical:

33-16=17 damage

33-14=19 damage

17x3=51 OHKO

19x3=57 OHKO

P.S:This doesnt use crits=100% Accuracy

The Battle Nabarl VS FE6 Karel:

Nabarl Hits Critical on Karel

Karel is dead

(btw FE6 karel is doubled by navarre Lol same as FE7 Karel)

The Battle Nabarl VS FE7 Karel:

Nabarl Hits Criticals Karel on 2nd attack or 1st attack OHKO

Karel is dead

Nabarl is the winner

Edited by TTPK_Tal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

FE6 Karel? FE7 Karel? (Same caps but Durandal v no Durandal access is a thing to consider, as well as Supports)

FE1/3/11/12 Nabarl?

IMO FE6 Karel because:

[email protected] 20/20 after unlimited boosters purchase

HP:60 Str:24 Skl:29 Spd:30 Luck:30 Def:22 Res:23 Mov:15 Con:25

Durandal gives 17+5 Atk and is effective against reclassed flier!Nabarl

Supports for Crit and CEV in FE11/12 are negligible at best, where Karel is saying fuck you to any crit that Nabarl might have even with forges.

*Edit*

Can you forge the Glass Sword in FE12?

Idk maybe with a bunch of boosters like Rainbow Pot and Cancer etc in FE12, his stats might exceed Karel's, but with supports, Karel's still looking at a boatload of Hit/AVO/Crt/CEV where in FE12, forging only offsets Hit and Crt and supports are unimpressive since he needs all 3 of his supports present.

Open ended question is open ended

Edited by Sara.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

FE6 Karel? FE7 Karel? (Same caps but Durandal v no Durandal access is a thing to consider, as well as Supports)

FE1/3/11/12 Nabarl?

IMO FE6 Karel because:

[email protected] 20/20 after unlimited boosters purchase

HP:60 Str:24 Skl:29 Spd:30 Luck:30 Def:22 Res:23 Mov:15 Con:25

Durandal gives 17+5 Atk and is effective against reclassed flier!Nabarl

Supports for Crit and CEV in FE11/12 are negligible at best, where Karel is saying fuck you to any crit that Nabarl might have even with forges.

*Edit*

Can you forge the Glass Sword in FE12?

Idk maybe with a bunch of boosters like Rainbow Pot and Cancer etc in FE12, his stats might exceed Karel's, but with supports, Karel's still looking at a boatload of Hit/AVO/Crt/CEV where in FE12, forging only offsets Hit and Crt and supports are unimpressive since he needs all 3 of his supports present.

Open ended question is open ended

I made a calc of them using there Iconic weaponry and average stats and Nabarl doubles that durandal Karel anyway if karel gets durandal nabarl gets hero sword and then its ulti rape

FE1/FE3 nabarl is a merc so that swordmaster battle isnt really valid as swordmasters were added in FE4

so its or FE11 nabarl or FE12 nabarl

Karel wont fight with other people this is 1v1

the battle cant happen with supports because then we have

Nabarl is supported by this following units in fe12:

Marth

The Avatar

Ogma

Karel will likely be:

B Fir

B Bartre

The fight is even going to turn out rather the same as in my calcs anyway

Rainbow potion 20/20 Nabarl with all stat boosters ingame is stronger then karel so yea the most hypothetical fight would be average stats and iconic weaponry

Edited by TTPK_Tal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think that "unlimited boosters purchase" counts. And as for which Karel/Navarre, I would think it would be FE 6 vs FE 12, because that's the where they are strongest.(for the most part)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If no boosters, then no supports?

Rainbow potion/Constellations allowed for 12?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No Rainbow potion/Constellations allowed for 12 too. Plus if we want to add items Navarre would win because Navarre is in Awakening... I still dont know why Awakening has super high caps.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No Rainbow potion/Constellations allowed for 12 too. Plus if we want to add items Navarre would win because Navarre is in Awakening... I still dont know why Awakening has super high caps.

Karel is in Awakening as well..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Edit your Opening Post so that we have a concise list of what's not inclusive in this comparison. Otherwise it's like comparing two different kinds of fruits

Edited by Sara.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Karel doesn't matter, still voted for him.

or let's say, Karel doesn't matter, he still is better, heh

Edited by Gradivus.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oguma/Dieck/Raven are better than both

*shots fired*

Swordmaster is my favorite class, but I wonder why you picked these two in particular. Especially since Karel is always pre-promote and Guy/Rutger are a thing, hell, even Joshua.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...