Well, if you're redoing the ROM and looking for comment, I guess now is a good time to post my Musain playthrough.
Progress before the route split
[spoiler=Chapter 7A]
[Chapter 7A: For the Fallen]
Turns: 20
Loot: Speedwings, stolen potion, short spear, blue gem
Purchases: Iron lance, Heal staff, Rapier
Funds: 420g (sold Talisman)
Apparently, I can check the contents of shops on the map preview screen. Who knew?
Turn 1, I buy some stuff, sell the talisman from chapter 6 to rustle up funds for that sexy rapier, and Lia and Astra chat. Then the team cuts their way to the chest room, where Gabriel uses a chest key to loot the speedwings. Meanwhile, Astra, Juan, Crowe, and Lia hold off the stream of cavalier reinforcements. Everyone else continues up the hallway, where they invade the other treasure room. Then they push over to the boss, where Gabriel and Ilanice are super useful against the mages. Kolbane and Furet weaken the boss, and Lumi murders his face.
Furet gains S bows. Wowza. Ilanice advances to B lances. Felix gets B dark magic. Lia gains B staves.
Lumi/Kolbane and Renair/Furet reach B support. Lia/Astra initiate C support.
Stats:
Name Lvl HP Str Skl Spd Lck Def Res Wep Rank Support
Renair 13.25 27 13 11 15 10 6 4 Swd A Furet B
Kolbane 13.22 33 14 13 18 11 8 3 Swd A Lumi B
Furetchen 2.73 37 17 10 10 6 10 4 Ax C Bow S Renair B
Ilanice 9.91 25 9 11 15 11 6 7 Swd E Lnc B Juan C
Amelia 14.48 25 16 14 11 7 7 13 Anima B -
Chester 5.19 21 6 11 14 10 5 4 Swd D -
Crowe 11.2 28 16 11 13 3 6 1 Bow B -
Lia 13.40 22 13 11 11 12 4 10 Staff B Astra C
Lumi 12.37 29 11 14 16 5 11 3 Swd B Kolbane B
Gabriel 10.31 27 14 9 11 9 7 13 Dark B -
Juan 9.43 29 12 8 10 6 12 3 Lnc C Ilanice C
Astra 11.47 33 13 9 9 6 15 3 Ax B Lia C
Hmm... who to give that speedwing to? Looks like Amelia, Gabriel, Juan, or Astra.
Juan, I am disappointed at your fail level there, bro.
Crowe has monster strength. He matches Amelia's but is 3 levels lower. Whoa.
[spoiler= Chapter 8A]
[Chapter 8A: Salvation]
Turns: 14
Loot: None
Purchases: Iron lance
Funds: 60g
Renair's diary: Today I almost died, got felt up by a creepy enemy commander, and then was rescued by a Nephenee lookalike. All this for Astra's sake. That fucker owes me like ten bottles of scotch.
Wait, where was I? Oh right. The map.
It seems I have two choices: head up through sparsely-defended territory and over a snag to reach Cullahan easily, or head left and face piles of enemies and the boss.
... Left it is!
Renair, her rescuer, and her two loyal chumps mow their way to the boss, engaging him on turn 8. Juan uses Seren's killer lance to impale Groper McGroperface with two most excellent crits. After that, the team mops up various enemies and makes for the north. Juan buys an extra iron lance and polishes off the three remaining enemies on the island while Renair talks to Cullahan, ending the chapter.
Bugs: The boss will speak at the end of turn 10, even though I murdered him previously.
Stats:
Name Lvl HP Str Skl Spd Lck Def Res Wep Rank Support
Renair 13.98 27 13 11 15 10 6 4 Swd A Furet B
Juan 12.13 32 14 10 12 8 14 3 Lnc B Ilanice C
Lia 15.34 23 14 12 12 13 5 11 Staff B Astra C
Seren 9.41 28 10 11 12 9 9 5 Lnc C -
Juan was clearly the MVP of this chapter. He gained three levels, three HP, two points in every stat except resistance, topped everyone but Astra in defense, and tore the boss a new one. Mega respect.
Seren is unimpressive. She's like Ilanice, but without flying, swords, or quite as much speed. She'll likely get left behind if she can't grow well.
[spoiler= Chapter 9A]
[Chapter 9A: Convergence]
Turns: 10
Loot: Veritas
Purchases: N/A
Funds: 60g
This is a really fun chapter. Due to the music, my rejoining allies, a sweet sword, a new bard character, AND a mobile boss, it numbers among my favorites.
Renair, Juan, Lia, and Seren stay together most of the time, clearing out the starting area. They're joined by Ilanice and Amelia, who I decide to keep out of the eastern dragon territory (attempting such became the cause of a few resets.) Lumi and Gabriel do just fine cutting down the enemies near them. Chester and Crowe have a funny little dialogue and are able to handle the axe bandits with a little fort dancing. Then Furet and Kolbane appear, and visit the houses to recruit Adrian and grab the Veritas. After some more slaughter, the boss shows up, and I pull back and then engage him on the following turn. Amelia softens him and Juan critkills for the win.
Also, Amelia gains A anima rank and Juan gains A lances.
Stats:
Name Lvl HP Str Skl Spd Lck Def Res Wep Rank Support
Renair 14.36 27 13 11 16 11 6 4 Swd A Furet B
Kolbane 13.43 33 14 13 18 11 8 3 Swd A Lumi B
Furetchen 2.94 37 17 10 10 6 10 4 Ax C Bow S Renair B
Ilanice 10.27 26 10 12 15 11 6 8 Swd E Lnc B Juan C
Amelia 14.99 25 16 14 11 7 7 13 Anima A -
Chester 5.41 21 6 11 14 10 5 4 Swd D -
Crowe 11.54 28 16 11 13 3 6 1 Bow B -
Lia 16.60 23 15 13 13 14 5 11 Staff B Astra C
Lumi 13.13 30 12 15 16 6 11 4 Swd A Kolbane B
Gabriel 11.36 28 15 10 12 9 7 13 Dark B -
Juan 14.26 34 15 11 13 9 16 3 Lnc A Ilanice C
Seren 10.38 29 11 12 13 9 10 5 Lnc C -
Adrian 1.30 17 1 2 11 12 3 3 - -
Kolbane, Juan, and Amelia are great as always. Lumi and Gabriel proved this chapter that I really don't need to worry about them too much anymore - they can hold their own. I wonder if they can support, since they showed up together in this chapter. Crowe and Ilanice need a little love from me, since they're lower than the other folks, but definitely worth training. Lia now has the highest level in the group. She is a lifesaver. Chester is really only there for unlocking stuff, but he's managed to stay out of trouble despite his low level. I still haven't decided what to do about Seren. She had a good level-up, at least. Also, I need to work on supports.
[spoiler=Chapter 10A]
[Chapter 10A: Liberty]
Turns: 16
Loot: 6000g, Heavy Spear, stolen lockpick
Purchases: Heal staff, Restore staff, Potion x 3, Fire Tome, Iron sword x 3, Steel sword x 3, Iron lance x2, Iron bow, Hand axe
Funds: 6671g
Prep: Hurray, more trade functions have been unlocked! I sell Chester and Adrian's blue gems for 10k gold. Astra uses the speedwings, boosting his 9 speed to 11. Finally, I choose to bench Furet, and as much as it pains me, Amelia.
Map: WTF SHOPS IN RANGE OF SIEGE TOME? RAAEEGG
*reset*
Right, so. Everyone advances while Lia buys herself some staves and Renair grabs some swords. The rest of the purchases go to the convoy. At the stairs, Astra, Felix, Seren, and Adrian go left, while the others head to the right. Here's where things get stupid. At the time, I figured keeping the NPCs alive would garner a reward, so I did not free the captive men, and I rescued Vallans and Merriway. Fighting my way up the map without their help probably cost me a number of turns. I also forgot to buy a door key to let Enjo out, which means Chester had to loot the chests and then hoof it over to Enjo's door before the reinforcements came out. I didn't know Astra could talk to Enjo to get the latter his PRF tome, either. Oops! I'll have to replay this chapter sometime now that I know better.
Gabriel and some other folks soften the boss, and Ilanice takes the kill. The end.
Other notes:
LumixKolbane A support. :3 So cute.
CrowexKolbane C.
Lia reaches A staves.
Seren B lances.
Bugs: Again, Ducann is back, even though Juan murdulated him back in Chapter 8A.
Stats:
Name Lvl HP Str Skl Spd Lck Def Res Wep Rank Support
Renair 14.45 27 13 11 16 11 6 4 Swd A Furet B
Kolbane 14.06 34 15 13 19 11 9 3 Swd A Lumi A, Crowe C
Furetchen 2.94 37 17 10 10 6 10 4 Ax C Bow S Renair B
Ilanice 12.91 26 10 12 17 11 6 9 Swd E Lnc B Juan C
Amelia 14.99 25 16 14 11 7 7 13 Anima A -
Chester 5.51 21 6 11 14 10 5 4 Swd D -
Crowe 12.67 28 16 11 14 3 7 1 Bow B Kolbane C
Lia 19.55 25 16 14 15 14 5 11 Staff A Astra C
Lumi 13.73 30 12 15 16 6 11 4 Swd B Kolbane A
Gabriel 12.63 28 16 10 13 10 7 14 Dark B -
Juan 15.48 35 16 12 13 9 17 3 Lnc A Ilanice C
Seren 12.63 30 12 12 14 9 11 5 Lnc B -
Adrian 2.93 18 1 2 12 12 3 4 - -
Karina 10 30 2 6 6 10 6 2 - -
Seren's doing okay, so I'll keep growing her. Lia is almost ready to promote - I hope she gets a promotion item in the upcoming patch.