If you could make a random character with any kind of Holy Weapon, except for Narga and Loputousu, from FE 4 what would be the top three?
I think that my number one choice in Holy Weapons is the Mistolteen because that Weapon can give a ridiculous amount of critical, which by the way it helps give you a lot. What I mean is that the critical percentage in FE 4 are calculated by skill + weapons kill bonus. The Mistolteen gives a +20 boost in skill, so not only does it give the skill it increases the percentage by 20.
The next Holy Weapon I'd choose would probably be the Falaflame. That weapon is the ultimate tanking weapon, not the Swanchika. The first reason why is because it weighs less than the Swanchika (the Swanchika has a weight of 20, the Falaflame has a weight of 15,) so it doesn't reduce A.S. as much as the Swanchika. The next reason why is because it gives a +10 boost in Magic, Defense, and Resistance, all of the perfect stats to boost in for a magic user, so it helps with any magic user having low defense, it makes that magic user even more resistant to other magic users, AND gives it an offensive bonus, something the Swanchika doesn't do.
The next weapon would be the Balmunk. It was a close tie between Balmunk and Holsety, which there is only one difference, which is that the Balmunk has a weight of 3 while the Holsety has a weight of 5. Other than that they are the same in terms of base accuracy, might, and stat boosts.
Edit: I think this should move to NES and SNES Era's board.