Jump to content

MaryQueen99

Member
  • Posts

    11
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by MaryQueen99

  1. Well, Edelgard is one of the main characters, she is clearly in love with Byleth in every route, Edge of Dawn is sung from her POV (and especially the last versione is very romantic). In her route her love for Byleth is even clearer and she is the first bisexual lord of the series (and gay girls have "only" 5 options, and she is one of the best choice). Other than that, there is the fact that she is either hated or loved, it's hard that people don't have a strong opinion about her. So being Byleth the avatar of the player, everyone that loves her will S support her. Anyway, I think Dimitri x Byleth and Silvayn X Felix are more popular (and ok, I expected Dimitri, but I don't understand why Sylvain x Felix is so popular. I understand why people see them as a romantic couple, I don't understand why they are so popular).

  2. I have a question on new game plus. 

    I started a new game, and wanted to unlock the supports with Shamir and Catherine, but they're not avaible. Have I to wait until they appear in game to buy their supports with renown? 

    Another question, I ended the game 2 times, once with BE and once with BL. Still, the option to S Support Sothis is never avaible. I'm pretty sure I selected the answers that give point with her, but she is not available. What have I to do? 

  3. I just thought another question, about the Byleth in the Crimson Flower ending

    Spoiler

    Why does Byleth survive? If I understand correctly, Byleth was dead at birth and if he is alives now it's just thanks to the crest. But in the ending the crest disappear and Byleth heart start beating for the first time. 

    I mean, I'm happy it ended that way but I don't understand why. 

  4. I don't know Japanese, but in general I found the english version good, and they paid attention to keep it coherent (Edelgard always say reach for my hand like the song, and other things). The only thing that I found strange and that made me worry, was in the s support with Edelgard

    Spoiler

    When she calls Byleth "My friend". From what I get, in the Japanese version she says Anata, that could be translated as "My dear/darling". I feared that they censored the support or it was platonic like that of the 2 gay male options. Then I read and it was clearly romantic, but that "My friend" part felt really strange. 

     

  5. 2 hours ago, Sid Starkiller said:

    Well of course they COULD find a justification, they wrote the damn story. But there's a limit to how much they should change background details (one of the many things Rev did wrong). Hell, they wouldn't even let Byleth go back a second time to try and save Jeralt! If they won't even let him go back a few seconds twice for the same reason, they're not gonna let him go back the entire story.

    I mean, technically Byleth can rewind times multiple time, and when that scene happened I thought "Go back again!", but I think the point was that it was one of these situations where you can't save that person no matter waht. Like when your unit is in a bad place and even if you rewind you can't save them, unless you restart the battle. If course if they did a dlc with Byleth rewinding everything then yeah, they should pay attention to not change things, not too much anyway.

  6. 42 minutes ago, Sid Starkiller said:

    Byleth's ability to rewind time is very limited, though. He's never shown using it in cutscenes more than a few seconds at a time. And even if you rewind an entire battle, just because the battle took you an hour up to that point doesn't mean it took that long from the character's perspective. For example in D&D (at least in 5th edition) one round of combat, meaning every player's turn and every monster's turn, takes 6 seconds of "actual" time. If we apply that rule to this game, even a 99 turn battle (the maximum allowed before automatic game over) would only last just under 10 minutes. There's no reason to think Byleth could go back 6 YEARS (remember that the school part takes place over 1 year) and start the whole plot again.

    Yeah, I know that Byleth rewind ability is limited, but if they wanted to do it they could find a justification easily. I just thought it was a cool idea, I think the base for it it's in the game, but it's their choices, and more than justifying byleth ability in an eventual 5th route I would be worried that they do the story justice. It's something that could come out really good or really bad. 

  7. Honestly... Yes. I only played the BE route, I will play the others soon, but... I could only think "Things could have gone better". I know, the game want you to think no route is the canon one, and even if I liked the BE route very much, knowing what we as players know about the story, I just wish for a route where all the 3 lords collaborate. It's something impossible normally, but from when I knew Byleth can rewind time, I could only think that if byleth got one more shot to make it right, if he maintained the memory of all the routes, an ending where the 3 lord don't fight (not until death) could be possible. But I guess it's been condirmed we won't get the 5th route right? Well, I just hope then for a Dlc for the BE route, I liked the story but the second part was shorter and with just one cutsscenes, I hope in that at least. 

  8. First of all, I would advise the author of the petition of sharing it in others forum and in some Fire Emblem group on Facebook.

    Second, I find the male gay option insulting. I mean, 3 options (2 of them being old man and 1 is married) was already bad, but when you know that the older options

    Spoiler

    Are literally Queerbait, and a S Support has always meant marriage or a romantic confession. What would you feel if you S Supported Edelgard but you don't get togheter and you marry a generic man? Tell me you would be fine with it

    It is insulting. I mean, I'm a woman so it doesn't directly affect me, but I think everyone can admit that they had chosen the worst options. Making Claude or Dimitri bisexual, or another students would have been a better option. 

    And let's not start talking about realism because it's not realistic that all the cast can potentially marry Byleth. 

  9. Hello there! My first Fire Emblem game was Awakening. I remember trying the demo and I immediately loved the concept that losing your units in battle meant losing them forever. It is a concept really different from others strategic game where units are cannon folders, literally. Even if I didn't like Fates as much as Awakening I have good hope about Three houses. I'm just waiting my chance of buying the switch, soon hopefully XD

×
×
  • Create New...