The Serenes Warriors Experiment (First Set of Votes tallied)

[Sire]

Shadow Dragon - Linde (There were so many candidates: Caeda, Julian, Lena, Bantu, Minerva, Gotoh, even Jake [Jake x Anna!]. However, I ended up with Linde due to her design.)
New Mystery - Feena (I haven't played New Mystery, but tried to find a character that wasn't in Shadow Dragon. Feena seems unique enough. I could have picked Katrina, but I think fans probably want a more classic character than a newer one.)

Gaiden - Mycen (Based off of Awakening artwork, I haven't played Gaiden)

Genealogy - Alvis (Based off of what little I know, he seems interesting. I haven't played Genealogy.)
Thracia - Ishtar (Based off artwork and small tidbits. I haven't played Thracia.)

Binding Blade - Fir (Personal bias and she is a Myrmidon. I haven't played through Binding Blade, but should get around to it eventually...)
Blazing Sword - Sain (I could go Canas, Jaffar, or even Fargus, but  don't have a Cavalier on this list. Besides, Sain's personality could fit well for this type of game considering who all he will be around.)

Sacred Stones - Joshua (Tossed a coin between Seth and Joshua, Joshua won. I love practically everyone in the Sacred Stones, but I'll settle on Joshua due to his personality.)

Path of Radiance - Nephenee (A lance user and personal favorite, although I prefer her artwork from Radiant Dawn. There are also plenty of awesome choices here: Jill, Astrid, Haar, Bastian, Tibarn, Volke, and Oliver, but I'll settle on Nephenee.)
Radiant Dawn - Nolan (A member of the Dawn Brigade and an axe user. Other candidates were Volug, Nailah, and Heather.)

Awakening -       (I mean, who wouldn't want a Knight around to defend them? My other picks were Walhart, Olivia, and Owain.)

Fates: Conquest - Leo or Arthur (Leo if he doesn't count as a Lord, Arthur otherwise. Leo is a magic user on horseback while Arthur has his amazing sense of JUSTICE!)
Fates: Birthright - Takumi or Oboro (Takumi since he is a bow user and fairly popular character, Oboro since she has some character depth and wields Nagitanas.)

[Master Thunderblade]

I voted as well...
There were some pretty though decisions...

Edited January 19, 2017 by Masterthunderblade

[Jedi]

1 minute ago, Masterthunderblade said:

I voted as well...

There were some pretty though decisions...

Sorry its a quirk of mine to like making people think  

Keep the results coming in! Its really cool to see all the differences and then some huge similarities.

[Master Thunderblade]

Just now, Jedi said:

Sorry its a quirk of mine to like making people think  

Keep the results coming in! Its really cool to see all the differences and then some huge similarities.

It's a really nice initiative! 

Although the fact that every field is required may limit the amount of responses you will get, I never finished the jugdral games myself so I only really knew the characters from the first few chapters.

[Jedi]

1 minute ago, Masterthunderblade said:

It's a really nice initiative! 

Although the fact that every field is required may limit the amount of responses you will get, I never finished the jugdral games myself so I only really knew the characters from the first few chapters.

Yeah I felt that might limit some responses haha ^^; I took the risk anyways.

[Thany]

10 hours ago, Sire said:

Awakening -       (I mean, who wouldn't want a Knight around to defend them? My other picks were Walhart, Olivia, and Owain.)

HA.

I still hope for ether Walhart or Donnel. could use his pothead as a projectile boomerang XD

[Jeheza]

FE1     - Linde (I always liked her in shadow dragon.)

FE2     - Sevr (Have not played Gaiden but with the remake being a thing, I’d think he’d be cool)

FE3     - Hardin

FE4     - Arvis (Not played the game)

FE5     - Ishtar(Not played the game)

FE6     - Lilina

FE7     - Louise

FE8     - Lyon

FE9     - Tibarn

FE10   - Black Knight(Meg could be a good joke character, tho.)

FE13   - Kellam ( considered Vaike)

FE14   - Kagero (As birthright candidate) Felicia (As conquest candidate)

 

[Bandit]

My picks:

Spoiler

Shadow Dragon: Minerva

I've only played the game once, but she stuck out as being rather cool. She had a nice design and having a Wyvern Rider would be cool for Warriors, probably working like Link's Horse weapon only flying.

New Mystery: Caeda

Haven't actually played NM, but Caeda was also pretty cool in SD, that counts as a good enough reason right? Attacks could be inspired by her TMS specials, other than that it'd be nice to have a Peg Knight.

Gaiden: Alm

He has a cool design, and it would work well as a tie in to encourage people to buy Shadows of Valentia.

Genealogy: Arvis

Other than the main lord he's the only other character I know from the game. Poor reason I know.

Thracia: Finn

See above reasoning

Binding Blade: Wolt

I really like his design, and archers would be a really interesting Warrior type. Maybe he could play like Linkle?

Blazing Sword: Rebecca

Another candidate for the archer role, really doubt she'll get in but one can dream.

Sacred Stones: Ephraim

I like Erikia, but Eph is basically the only non-sword lord helping him stand out a bit more. What would be really cool is if he and Erikia could be a paired Warrior with Erikia providing back-up support for some special moves like Chrom in Smash.

Path of Radiance: Black Knight

Strong, slow, powerhouse character. While I've never played PofR I understand the Black Knight was pretty big in that game, so seeing him included would be nice.

Radiant Dawn: Sothe

I have played RD however, while I don't use Sothe much I feel he'd be great as a speedy combo character.

Awakening: Tiki

Playble Manakete would be so awesome, I'd be fine with her younger desgin but we just had that in TMS it'd be nice to see the more mature side of Tiki's personality and heightened power

Birthright: Scarlet

Same reasoning as Minerva, cool design and poorly used in Fates, plays a role in all 3 paths so she stands out more than the rest of the BR cast in that regard

Conquest: Keaton

Transforming Warrior, Wolfskins were really fun to use in Conquest and I can see him being a powerhouse in Warriors.

 

[Emeraldfox]

SD: Draug

Gaiden: Alm(I forgot he was a Lord, please pretend this is Silque)

NM: Sheena

GoHW: Arden

776: Machuya

BiB: Gwendolyn

BlB: Oswin

SS: Kyle

PoR: Gatrie

RD: Danved

A: Miriel

F: B: Mitama

F: C: Velouria

[BANRYU]

Aight, here's what I got: 

1. Tiki
2. Palla
3. Xane
4. Ayra
5. Nanna
6. Sophia
7. Hector
8. Lyon
9. Soren
10. Nephenee
11. Tharja
12. Takumi
13. Camilla

I tried to pick a relatively diverse cast of classes that would be interesting to play as, but my bias for magic and dragons might be showing a bit. I kind of feel like my results for FE2 and 5 should be invalidated since I know next to nothing about them ahaha... ;; oh well

[eclipse]

Will you ever publish the results of this experiment?

[Jedi]

1 minute ago, eclipse said:

Will you ever publish the results of this experiment?

I will be yes. I just wanted a good bit of data first, like with my "Fates character placements" deal.

[Thor Odinson]

FE1/11 - Caeda
FE2 - N/A, don't know them enough to say
FE3/12 - Minerva
FE4 - Ayra
FE5 - Finn
FE6 - Niime
FE7 - Pent
FE8 - Seth
FE9 - Titania
FE10 - Soren
FE13 - Flavia
FE14B - Ryoma
FE14C - Xander

My picks tend to be characters whom I both like and think to have at least some degree of relevance. I did prioritize a few mages over characters I like more though, because I heavily bias physical.

[Ebony]

Honestly I forgot to reply to this, so some of the characters I chose slipped my mind. However I do remember these:

FE4 - Ced

FE5 - Finn

FE6 - Klein

FE7 - Nino/Karel

FE8 - Eirika/L'Arachel

FE9 - Tibarn

FE10 - Micaiah

FE13 - Henry because I couldn't think of anyone better tbh

FE14BR - Oboro

FE14CQ - Keaton

 

If I don't get Tibarn or a Laguz, the only ones I'd be fine with are Keaton or Kaden. Keep the Taguel away pls.

[Brand_Of_The_Exalt]

Oops, voted for Lords the first time, so don't take it into consideration. It is similar to my second one:

FE1 - Caeda

FE2 - Est (did not play, liked her in SD/MOTE)

FE3 - Camus

FE4 - Finn

FE5 - Karin (did not play this one, looks good)

FE6 - Barthe :)

FE7 - Pent

FE8 - Joshua

FE9 - Marcia (same, love her in RD)

FE10 - Nephenee

FE13 - Severa

FE14BR - Taco meat

FE14CQ - Peri

Edited January 21, 2017 by Brand_Of_The_Exalt

[Night Zap]

FE1: Barst. Found him cool when I played Shadow Dragon

Gaiden: Kamui. Main reason his name stuck with me is that I love Kill la Kill.

Mystery: Sirius. He's cool.

Genealogy: Ced. Was cool in the FE4 LP I read

Thracia: Mareeta. Ditto, but with an FE5 LP, of course. Also, Swordmaster-Bias

Binding Blade: Gonzales SMASH!

Blazing Blade: Jaffar. Mostly because the dual Knifes of GBA Assassins would make for a cool, distinct fighting style (though I also like him as a character)

Sacred Stones: Joshua. Swordmaster-Bias strikes again!

Path of Radiance: Jill. How could I forget one of my favourite characters in the entire series? I hope Dragon Knights will be in the game.

Radiant Dawn: Mia. Swordmaster-Bias Part 3: The Biasing

Awakening: Henry. Pretty cool guy.

Conquest: Niles. Because I liked his supports.

Birthright: Oboro. I like her. Partly because her class is basically a Swordmaster with lances. She's also all around awesome.

[Jedi]

When I have my 3 day weekend, i'll post the current results. 

Thanks for your votes and patience.

[Light Strategist]

FE11/Book 1 Character

Camus

FE2 Character

Don't remember, I think it was Mycen (I literally did this minutes ago, my memory is awful.)

FE12/Book 2 Character

Tiki

FE4 Character

Ayra

FE5 Character

Raydrik

FE6 Character

Zephiel

FE7 Character

Lyn

FE8 Character

Ephraim

FE9 Character

Lethe

FE10 Character

Soren

FE13 Character

Lucina

FE14 Birthright Character

Shiro

FE14 Conquest Character

Siegbert

 

For most of the Japanese only games, I tried to use characters that I thought looked pretty cool or suiting for the gameplay type.

I haven't played much of Shadow Dragon or New Mystery but I remember seeing Sirius and basically studying him on the wiki, thus Char- I mean Camus is there. I chose Tiki more for the aspect of her being one of the few characters I remember being in FE12 since I haven't properly jumped into it yet.

I chose Zephiel for FE6 because it's the only Japanese only entry I've played sufficiently enough and Zephiel's on the cooler side of Villains IMO.

Lyn, Lucina and Siegbert are pretty much bias because I really like their character and designs.

Shiro I've chosen because there's always at least one brash and arrogant character and he's pretty capable as far as Fates units go.

Soren and Lethe are both taken from what I've seen in Path of Radiance but I elected to put Soren in the Radiant Dawn spot because I've heard he's pretty decent in it whereas I have nothing to base Lethe on but PoR.

Ephraim I chose because he seems pretty chill and confident but without much arrogance.

The rest are purely because of Awakening giving me visual aids to form an opinion of the character that way.

[Kirie]

This was really fun to think up! Some of my picks are ones that I think would be cool and probably have a decent shot of getting in (Caeda, Emperor Harden, Elincia, Robin). Others... probably unlikely (Ethlyn, Florina, Mathilda, Soren, Azama). One that's highly unlikely but I really wish would actually happen is L'Arachel. I could totally see her slamming through hordes of undead with Light magic while shouting out about punishing evildoers and yelling at Rennac for not helping.

Edited January 30, 2017 by Kirie

[Jedi]

Just now, Kirie said:

This was really fun to think up! Some of my picks are ones that I think would be cool and probably have a decent shot of getting in (Caeda, Emperor Harden, Elincia, Robin). Others... probably unlikely (Ethlyn, Florina, Mathilda, Soren, Azama). One that's highly unlikely but I really wish would actually happen is L'Arachel. I could totally see her slamming through hordes of undead with Light magic while shouting out about punishing evildoers and yelling at Rennac for not helping.

L'Arachel would be an amazing pick I think as well, she could go preaching about JUSTICE yeah, also these votes should be tallied soon, I got distracted today by Trails of Cold Steels ending lol.

[Kirie]

Eh, no rush. I'm glad you were running a bit late since it gave me enough time to sneak a vote in. :P

[Jedi]

And the first set of results are pretty much fully tallied, I may have missed a few because so many lines... 

 

Merged votes will show for characters who show up in multiple games

FE1/11 - All Marth votes discounted as he is the only Lord in the game

Caeda/Sheeda/Shiida: 32 
Tiki: 11
Merric: 6
Linde: 6
Ogma: 5
Camus: 4
Minerva: 4
Navarre: 4 
Doga/Draug: 4 
Jeigan: 4 
Wolf: 3
Abel: 2 
Catria: 2 
Wrys: 2
Xane: 2
Anna: 1 
Bantu: 1
Barst: 1 
Boah: 1
Castor: 1 
Gordin: 1 
Hardin: 1
Jeorge: 1 
Julian: 1  
Lorenz: 1 
Maria: 1
Palla: 1 

FE2 - Alm & Celica votes count because they are both MC's thus have actual competition 

Celica: 23
Alm: 11
Mycen: 6
Luka: 5
Zeke: 5
Mathilda: 4 
Atlas: 4
Saber: 3
Palla: 3
Robin: 2 
Doma: 2
Est: 2 
Kamui: 2
Sonya: 2
Valbar: 1
Python: 1
Booey: 1 
Catria: 1
Dyute: 1 
Grey: 1
Nomah: 1 
Silk: 1

FE3/12 - Marth Votes discounted 

Sirius: 12
Katarina: 12
Minerva: 8
Tiki: 7
Dark/Evil/Emperor Hardin: 7
Catria: 6
Caeda/Wing Spear: 5
Merric: 4
Xane: 3
Feena: 3 
Bantu: 2
Luke: 2 
Ellerean: 2
Ogma: 2
Sheema: 2 
Etzel: 1 
Abel: 1 
Athena: 1 
Cain: 1 
Castor: 1 
Cecil: 1 
Doga: 1 
Elise: 1 
Gharnef: 1 
Legion: 1 
Lorenz: 1 
Linde: 1 
Malice: 1 
Michalis: 1 
Navarre: 1 
Ryan: 1
Roshea: 1 
Wolf: 1 

FE4 - Sigurd & Celice may be voted for 

Ayra: 14
Levin/Lewyn: 12
Alvis/Arvis: 8
Ced/Sety: 7
Celice/Seilph: 6
Sigurd: 5 
Briggid: 3
Ardan: 3 
Deidre/Diedre: 3
Ethlin: 3
Cuan/Quan: 3
Leaf/Leif: 2
Altena: 2 
Dew: 2
Finn: 2
Shanan: 2 
Midir: 2
Tiltyu/Tailto: 2
Anna: 1 
Azel: 1
Hannibal: 1 
Holyn: 1 
Jamka: 1 
Julia: 1 
Julius: 1 
Larcei: 1 
Lex: 1
Lachesis: 1
Honorable Mention: ZIGLUDO-CHAN-SAN-SAMA-SENPAI-SAN-SAMA-SAN-SENPAI-CHAN's horse 

FE5 - Leif votes aren't counted 

Finn: 30
Orsin/Othin: 6
Ced/Sety: 5
Mareeta: 5
Nanna: 4
Karin: 3
Evyel: 3
Shiva: 2 
Linoan: 2
Ishtar: 2
Homeros: 2
Salem: 2 
Travant: 2 
Shanam: 1
Raydrik: 1 
Reinhard: 1 
Misha: 1 
Altena: 1 
Anna 1
Asvel: 1 
Dean: 1 
Machua: 1
Marty: 1 

FE6 - Roy votes aren't counted

Lilina: 20
Rutger: 7
Zephiel: 6
Percival: 5
Bartre: 5 
Sophia: 4
Fir: 4 
Gonzales: 4 
Ray/Raigh: 3
Merlinus: 3
Dieck: 3 
Wolt: 2
Sue: 2
Bors: 2 
Cecilia: 2
Miledy: 2 
Niime: 2
Thany/Shanna: 1 
Noah: 1
Murdock: 1
Marcus: 1
Lugh: 1
Hugh: 1 
Idoun: 1 
Igrene: 1
Klein: 1
Wendy/Gwendolyn: 1 
Saul: 1 
Fae: 1
Elphin: 1 
Echidna: 1 
Dayan: 1  
Chad: 1 
Anna: 1 

FE7 - the Lords can be voted for 

Hector: 12
Jaffar: 11
Lyn: 9
Pent: 6
Rath: 6
Canas: 5
Nino: 5
Matthew: 4
Louise: 4 
Karel: 3
Sain: 3
Oswin: 2 
Marcus: 2
Eliwood: 2 
Athos: 2
Florina: 2 
Heath: 2
Nils: 2
Raven: 2
Rebecca: 2
Wil: 2
Zephiel: 1
Ursula: 1 
Vaida: 1 
Renault: 1
Priscilla: 1
Nergal: 1 
Ninian: 1
Merlinus: 1
Lloyd: 1 
Isadora: 1
Hawkeye: 1 
Fiora: 1 
Dorcas: 1 
Bartre: 1
Erk: 1 
Anna: 1 

FE8 - Lords can be voted for 

Joshua: 16
Lyon: 13
Innes: 9
Seth: 8
Ephraim: 8
Lute: 8
L'Arachel: 7
Eirika: 6
Duessel: 5
Knoll: 4
Gerik: 3
Amelia: 3
Dozla: 2 
Kyle: 2
Moulder: 2
Saleh: 2
Tana: 2 
Tethys: 1
Selena: 1 
Natasha: 1 
Neimi: 1 
Rennac: 1
Marisa: 1 
Gilliam: 1 

FE9 - All Ike Votes are discounted 

Soren: 18
Nephenee: 9
Titania: 8
Elincia: 7
Tibarn: 6
Mia: 6
Mist: 5
Black Knight: 6
Lethe: 5
Marcia: 4
Ranulf: 3
Haar: 3 
Jill: 3
Shinon: 2
Oliver: 2
Oscar: 2
Gatrie: 2
Zihark: 2
Stefan: 1 
Tauroneo: 1
Rolf: 1
Mordecai: 1
Malakov: 1 
Largo: 1
Kieran: 1
Ilyana: 1 
Astrid: 1
Sigrun: 1
Brom: 1
Anna: 1

FE10 

Micaiah: 11
Sothe: 9
Elincia: 7 
Pelleas:  6 
Black Knight: 8
Nephenee: 5
Nolan: 5
Soren: 4
Ranulf: 3
Oliver: 3
Nailah: 3
Mist: 3
Jill: 3
Leonardo: 3
Mia: 3
Titania: 2
Tibarn: 2
Sanaki: 2
Edward: 2
Caineghis: 2
Anna: 2
Volug: 1
Tormod: 1
Volke: 1 
Stefan: 1
Sephiran: 1 
Sigrun: 1 
Skrimir: 1
Mordecai: 1
Heather: 1
Haar: 1
Geoffrey: 1
Fiona: 1
Danved: 1 
Boyd: 1 
Aran: 1
3-13 Archer: 1 

FE13 

Owain: 7
Tharja: 7
Walhart: 7
Robin: 6
Lucina: 6
Gregor: 6
Anna: 6
Lon Qu: 6
Severa: 5
Lissa: 4
Henry: 4
Fredrick: 4
Tiki: 3
Vaike: 3
Maribelle: 3
Cordelia: 3
Flavia: 3
Priam: 3
Noire: 2
Say'ri: 2
Emmeryn: 2
Cervantes: 2
Cherche: 2
Kellam: 2
Donnel: 2
Sumia: 1
Ricken: 1
Nowi: 1 
Morgan: 1 
Miriel: 1
Inigo: 1
Gaius: 1 
Gangrel: 1 
Gerome: 1 
Brady: 1

FE14 - Birthright 

Takumi: 22
Oboro: 20
Ryoma: 7
Saizo: 7
Kaze: 7
Rinkah: 5
Hinoka: 4 
Sakura: 3
Scarlet: 3
Kagero: 3
Hayato: 3
Yukimura: 2
Subaki: 2
Setsuna: 2
Shiro: 2
Mitama: 2
Azura: 2 
Azama: 2
Reina: 2
Shura: 1 
Orochi: 1
Kaden: 1
Izana: 1
Hana: 1
Anna: 1

FE14 - Conquest 

Leo: 16
Camilla: 12
Charlotte: 9
Arthur: 9
Xander: 7
Niles: 6
Beruka: 4
Gunther: 4
Keaton: 4
Laslow: 4
Odin: 3
Azura: 3
Peri: 2
Ophelia: 2
Elise: 2
Benny: 2
Kaze: 2
Selena: 1
Siegbert: 1
Silas: 1
Soleil: 1
Velouria: 1
Percy: 1
Nyx: 1
Nina: 1
Mozu: 1
Izana: 1 
Jakob: 1
Felicia: 1 
Flora: 1
Effie: 1
Anna: 1

Characters who show up in multiple games total votes, If they got more than 1

Caeda: 37
Finn: 32
Soren: 22
Camus/Zeke/Sirius: 21
Tiki: 21
Anna: 16
Nephenee: 14
Elincia: 14
Black Knight: 14
Ced/Sety: 12
Minerva: 12
Owain/Odin: 10
Titania: 10
Merric: 10
Mia: 9
Catria: 9
Sothe: 9
Kaze: 9
Mist: 8
Tibarn: 8
Hardin: 7
Linde: 7
Ogma: 7  
Zephiel: 7
Severa/Selena: 6
Jill: 6
Bartre: 6
Briggid/Eyvel: 6
Ranulf: 6
Lethe: 5
Navarre: 5 
Doga: 5
Xane: 5
Oliver: 5
Inigo/Laslow: 5
Haar: 4
Marcia: 4
Merlinus: 4
Palla: 4
Wolf: 4
Karel: 3
Marcus: 3
Abel: 3
Bantu: 3
Izana: 2
Est: 2
Shinon: 2 
Castor: 2 
Gatrie: 2 
Zihark: 2
Mordicai: 2 
Sigrun: 2 

Edited January 30, 2017 by Jedi

[eclipse]

Props to whoever voted for Sigurd's horse and the 3-13 Archer.

Also, who was the other person that voted for Yukimura?!

[Anacybele]

Elincia beat Mia, awesome!

[Jedi]

2 hours ago, eclipse said:

Props to whoever voted for Sigurd's horse and the 3-13 Archer.

Also, who was the other person that voted for Yukimura?!

I think @Euklyd is who voted for the former haha.

Edited January 31, 2017 by Jedi