Jump to content

Phoenix01

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    30

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Posts posted by Phoenix01

    hobbies

    in General

    Posted

    I love playing chess. Other than that, listening to music/playing my viola and sometimes piano (though I suck at piano). I also enjoy playing street hockey even though I rarely get the opportunity, unfortunately. There's also the obvious video games.

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    I have a reply post incoming, but there's something that's really been bothering me.

    Why is Phoenix's claim so townie as to not to lynch him? 1x Omniguard could benefit scum just as much as it could benefit town, and additionally it's just too weak to constitute a role in and of itself. I'll bet anything that Phoenix is a Scum!JoaT and is just claiming the towniest part of his role.

    Like seriously. Just because it can be a doc doesn't mean it will.

    Doc isn't the only thing. It could also prevent hookers blocking, janitors, etc. Also you'll bet anything? Hmmm.

    I don't see a newb!scum player forgetting to mention that his role is only one-shot (for the reason I already gave).

    I will switch to FFM if necessary but preferably not Iris. Are you guys sure you don't want to lynch Poly?

    To elaborate, the PM said "once during the night". Originally I thought it meant "once during each night" but that seemed rather OP, and the role was "one-use omniguard" after all.

    I wouldn't mind seeing a claim from Iris. The reason I haven't responded to your questions is because my role PM is honestly quite odd, it says "you're the town miller governor, except you're none of these things anymore". I wasn't sure how to answer without saying what appeared to be random.

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    ##unvote

    Iris, in the same post you express your doubts about Shinori, you say that you think FFM and/or I might be town, and then you say "there's a ton of gambits they could pull". That sounds like you think we aren't innocent because the "pulling gambits" part doesn't really sound like something a townie would do, plus you say there might be a vet on their team. Mafia is the only faction that knows their members. Sounds pretty contradictory, care to explain?

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    I doubt FFM will be able to claim because she (?) said she was going to bed about three-four hours ago, and I doubt she'll be up before day ends.

    My role can cancel all actions aimed at a user during the night phase. I guess that means I can act as a psuedo-Doctor, because mafia won't be able to kill them. Make of that what you will.

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    Will attempt to explain my best claw vote later; can't be on much right now.

    Here now, so time for this. Also *bearclaw, stupid autocorrect.

    I meant it a lot more of a prod vote than a lynch vote. I asked him about FFM (whether he thought she was suspicious because of her logic) a while ago and he hasn't responded to that. I assumed because of that he was trying to dodge the question, which made me suspicious. There's also a possibility that they're both scum and bearclaw is avoiding saying anything really conclusive around her (even though FFM's vote on him kills that possibility). He also hasn't really said much about FFM in general. So basically my vote tried to get him to answer that question, even if it kinda failed. The only reason I can think of now is that he simply didn't see it, which shouldn't happen if you're reading everything.

    Also there are about 4 hours left if my subtraction is correct.

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    okay I feel as if phoenix01's reads reek of scum. He says that FFM's vote on Elieson is suspicous just because Elieson has been active? Not saying that elieson is scum bit yeah..

    Curious to see why you think darros sounds townish? You do not really give any examples whatsoever. I would assume you have a nullread instead.

    Feels like he is giving reads because he would get attention if he did not.You seem to have more beef with FFM then bearclaw based on your reads. Also cannot see how refa has been "iffy". Cannot really understand why you think refa would be iffy based on a joke post. You think he is leaning scum,null,or town? Also states how he believes GP's claim but then said in an earlier post let us investigate GP tonight. Also feels like that everyone who is voting for FFM gets a free pass. Poly"nothing much to say", Dallas "seems townish".

    ## vote phoenix01

    The biggest problem with your list is that it feels way to vague and it feels you are doing it out of obligation

    About FFM I understand your reasoning for FFM being scum but just how obvious he is making it feels just ridiculous. Like really obvious. It just feels way to easy to tear through. I will keep on eye him though, see if his posting style changes later.

    FFM's vote on Elie included "until he participates further". I took this to mean that FFM thought Elie was inactive, which I disagreed with because he was participating.

    That's an interesting idea you have on Poly and Darros, but they're essentially null suspicions. I can see why you'd think that, but it's just a coincidence. Darros I think has been contributing and I'm not really suspicious of him other than the fact that he posts some stuff that isn't related to the game (#243,244, and parts of his content posts).

    On Refa, "iffy" means "null but more likely scum but town".Don't really think joke posts are necessary and I still have beef with his Poly suspicions.

    Regarding GP, emphasis on "earlier post", opinions change. Willing to give him the benefit of the doubt, for now.

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    Reads:

    Poly- not really suspicious, I guess null is the proper terminology here (?)

    Darros- I dislike his avatar therefore lynch but he seems pretty townish I guess? Some of his content isn't related to the game, however and

    Iris- Some suspicion based on that omgus but otherwise not much. I'm not sure why you'd withhold reads, unless I'm missing something obvious.

    Refa- A bit iffy, not really sure what the point of #256 was. I looked at his read of Darros and I feel like the only really worthwhile support of his vote comes from bullet #2 and I don't think that's enough to warrant him being "more suspicious than eliescum".

    Green Poet- I believe his claim, nothing else really stands out.

    Me- hello

    Elieson- I have a minor red flag over him trying to pass GP's role off as sort of "better dead than alive" because of that "no nightkills for no information" even though he clearly stated all townies wouldn't be able to act. Also don't really understand his Euklyd vote without responding to the (actual content) post he made before.

    Junko- nothing much, really

    FFM- Yesterday I thought he was the most scummy here, then he got better, and now I think he's going back. His choice in voting is pretty suspicious. His vote on elieson was strange because, at least imo, elie's been contributing and active. You also asked Iris to expound on her vote for Elie when you didn't. And then he changed his vote to kopf, whattt. A pressure vote isn't going to do much at this stage. Nothing really to say about his bearclaw vote.

    Eclipse- Not much to say.

    Shinori- One of the other most pro-townies, he's done nothing to make me suspicious.

    Eurykins- Not much to say. Do hope you get better though!

    Bearclaw- I don't get his vote on Poly, and I'm still suspicious of what he's done before.

    Kopf- could stand to post more. Have fun at that wedding though.

    Euklyd- Not much to say. Seems rather townish aside from that.

    @Green Poet (#264): I voted him because at least they (Iris and Elieson) are contributing and I have issues with his as well.

    @Euklyd (#234): It felt like he was sort of trying to cover himself, imo.

    @Junko(#246): Why did he vote Euklyd instead of the other three you listed? If we're all acting the same then does it matter which one he picks?

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    re: ffm

    actually i'm feeling pretty good about ffm/shinori atm. pretty good meaning, not scummy. well probably more null in ffm's case, since apparently he's new. anyways, wrt shinori, i think it's a pretty good sign he's trying so hard (iirc he didn't do that as scum, but idr). poly also sorta jumped on this, but not sure how to feel about that.

    re: refa

    i mentioned that because i wanted refa to respond to it, pretty simple. and he did. my only reasoning is meta (and i don't know half the kids int his game/have played in a while) so that's why there were a lot of idks. either that, or that's how i type now.

    re: elieson

    this sounds really bad but i'm going to omgus elieson. actually it's not an omgus so let me explain. we started mafia around the same time, so i found it out of place that his tone is lecturing/condescending. also i think it's mostly because this is bullshit reasoning/a bit of a scumtell because scum's reads are generally CONTRIVED and that's the gut feel i'm getting from elieson atm.

    ##unvote

    ##elieson

    re: everyone else

    i'm going to iso later when i get back, but i can only remember like 5 people (out of 15) actually playing in this game which is bad/when i typed up this post everything above is all i remembered. not sure if everyone is trying to lay low or what.

    I don't get this reasoning. I mean like sure you started around the same time but that doesn't mean you're going to always be at the same level, different people pick things up faster than others and they're not always going to be at the same level. Also iso'd Elieson and, even though I have my doubts on him too, I don't really see an instance of him being really being condescending. I understand your views on his reads but imo the other things outweigh it, including the fact that this is omgus. Even though you're admitting it it doesn't make it more acceptable, imo.

    Also ##vote bearclaw

    Hasn't responded to my question from yesterday and could stand to be more active. (Yeah I know I could too)

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    Because everyone wants to see me cry. ;-;

    lolmeta

    What has Shinori done that makes him obvtown up to now? I mean, I'm not seeing him as scummy, but I'd like to know why this is the case.

    Yeah, but... it's still not that great of a role. Still, I don't see GP making that claim as scum, so... uh.

    Still not liking Frosty. Will re-read Iris to see if I find any content or if Elie's right on his read of her.

    idk why you're discarding metagaming so readily. Sure, it isn't facts and sure isn't the most reliable thing around, but people have habits and it can also be used to help narrow down a field/make more informed guesses.

    Also is it just me or is it strange that Junko's posts never seem to finish.

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    @Iris: I'm trying, haven't had time for much more than skims and replying to stuff said to me as of yet, I have one or two townreads from that but I'd rather not out them in case I change my mind when I do stuff tonight.

    umm yeah.

    So you don't find her suspicious because of that?

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    That post is so off I don't even think it's scummy.

    Read back to what happened overnight and I just don't get this post. If it's off, that should tip you off that that person's pretty scummy and is worth more looking in to. It sounds pretty hypocritical to me by that logic.

    also regarding Frosty and his post about "everyone's voting with flimsy reasoning so I might as well". That's only going to get you lynched faster, putting votes on people without reasoning is pretty scummy. Doing something "because other people did it" is a pretty terrible excuse.

    @Darros: I think that's kinda my personality, because I'm usually a pretty cautious/conservative guy and that translates into the game as well. Also tbh I'm not sure why people are jumping so much about my suggestion, it was only that.

    I Can't Believe It's not SFMM4! - Game Over

    in Mafia

    Posted

    Meh I would wait till phoenix01 or whatever posts some more. Seems to be his first game so this may explain why he wanted an investigation so early. Also has posted once or twice and one post I think was not even a content post. He is new (I think) so I can feel better as well.

    GP's claim seems legitimate to me. If she wasn't miller that would be quite an interesting thing to claim right away. No counterclaims yet either. I also hope kop is not vigilante again. I dislike RVS a lot as there is not much I can pull out except for the obvious.

    There is one problem with Eliesons vote I have though. It feels like he is trying to justify his vote on FFM just because. It might have been trying to contribute to RVS but that just seems like a silly reason right there as it was obvious it was a joke. But that is just nitpicking at this point. I hate RVS. I will try to wait for more content for the time being.

    I said "if nothing new comes up". If someone else claims something, obviously we'll have to debate who to investigate. Or we could wifom so evils don't know what's happening.

    Right now I'm not sure about FFM. When I come home from school, I'll post something.

×
×
  • Create New...