Jump to content

ZoesMad

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    118

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Posts posted by ZoesMad

    Dot.hack//The World:R1 Mafia(Game thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    Ditto what GP said to via.

    GP, I understand where you're coming from on Rapier. Being reminded by a scumbuddy still seems incredibly unlikely. It was a timeframe of literally two minutes before he changed his mind. My read on you is more null atm, now that I see your legitimate questioning.

    Also regarding Ciraxis, his post was very surface level, and he also kept an RVS vote for no reason at all. Not exactly screaming town.

    Dot.hack//The World:R1 Mafia(Game thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    Alrighty, answering Terrador's question, and I've read my ISOs and have some things to say about who some ideas that could be important.

    @Terrador: This is my first time playing mafia. My only other mafia experience has been on Showdown which is a radically different game. (All in irc, role lists shown, etc.) I'm trying pretty hard fwiw ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    Man, I don't see how Marth's one liner is telling at all. Is that something that he'd only say as scum? If so, why? It's pretty funny that I don't agree with anyone's cases so far. Please understand, dude, mafia sucks.


    This is some of your only content about Marth. You make a decently large post after that regarding Poly, Blitz, SB, etc. but Marth is left completely out of it, and still gets the vote? Seems like you're running on your own agenda. Warrants explanation especially since you haven't posted much content since then.

    Cut: Looked at Proto's above post. Marth, while I think people shouldn't be seeing scum out of your posts, why the vanilla claim?

    I'm fine with leaving my vote on Weapons for now.


    Why? Besides that its obviously idiotic to vote based off a joke alone, you should have a read on someone at least.

    hmm, LOC is rather complicated..

    RE: Rapier vote on Marth

    This is scummy because it's an attempt to remedy the initial scummy play (refusing to vote) with conciliatory, textbook townie play (actually voting).

    RE: Terra v Kirsche

    Terrador needs to stop tunneling kirsche, and vice-versa. I think all of the possible arguments and counterarguments for the issue they are contending have been exhausted, and they both need to start scumhunting elsewhere.

    Opening of your post makes it seem to me like a psychological way of giving you room for error in your reads. A safety net of sorts.

    Why is it inherently scummy to not vote? Rapier waiting for something that gave him a harder read seems fine to me.

    Regarding Kirsche v Terrador, we still haven't gotten any masons confirming to anyone yet. It still remains an issue, and its been a good amount of time since Kirsche claimed Mason Leader/Recruiter/hes being vague on purpose.

    Not exactly digging your post tbh.

    Dot.hack//The World:R1 Mafia(Game thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    Ok here are some other things I have to say.

    @Green Poet: Gaius too kawaii indeed. On a serious note, why do you feel the need for Hugh's RVS vote to be questioned? It seems like he was just following what Blitz told him to do, which was vote someone randomly. Blitz actually had a response for Via's vote, and that started the whole Blitz being defensive v. scummy argument.

    @Weapons: I'm inclined to believe most of Ciraxis' post. I've already stated I think Rapier being attacked was blown out of proportion and I don't think his intent was scum then. I agree with his statement on the Kirsche situation. Weapons, I did miss why he voted you in the first place. Clarification on that would be nice.

    @Everyone: How much has flavor from role PM played into the actual setup/outcome of a game? This is more of general question so I can understand SF Mafia better.

    Dot.hack//The World:R1 Mafia(Game thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    Hi I exist. Here goes my first post. I just read 10 straight pages so I apologize if my logic is flawed, reasoning unclear etc. Ask to clarify if needed.

    Anyway here are my opinions on various issues:

    Kirsche: Definitely not agreeing with your opinion on being town leader D1. Terrador really voiced my complaints with what you've said. I'm fine with your Mayor claim, it's easily confirmable, but it does not guarantee town alignment in any way. Mason Leader/Recruiter/whatever claim is where I started to feel overwhelmed. You're throwing information at us, but what does it really prove? You seem desperate to create organization, but putting information in the wrong hands is worse than not being organized. I don't care that you can easily be proved. You still aren't proved as of now. Not worth putting this into your hands.

    Rapier: His vote on BlueDoom seems completely legitimate as a reaction test. The shift from joke to serious is worthy of being tested imo.

    ##Vote: Kirsche

    This is preliminary, I need to reread some things, but I really feel bad about trying to get town leader when completely unclaimed.

×
×
  • Create New...