Athena_57

Could you explain what you mean with this?

Wdym he's likely to resolve himself?

Well, it was mostly because I could see his scumteam being like "Let's use him as a way to add heat to town wagons and see how long he makes it" so they just told him to vote town!Corrobin and gave him a few reasons, after which he did, but said "from my conversations" and got himself killed. If it's distancing, what's the plan? To get Tuvy deep? To get scum!Corrobin deep? If I'm scum with them I don't see them making endgame so I wouldn't bother with getting them deep but would try to use their votes to strongarm a mislynch.. Maybe we're dealing with an almost full newbscum team or maybe they just didn't think it through, but that's why at the time I felt the distancing scenario wasn't that likely. And then his latest pop-in happened and now I'm scumreading Corrobin anyways so...

Yeah, I can get that, I just felt it was kind of weird you left it at this generalization and didn't really go into the specific people (the dead town, the guy who caught tuvy's slip and bart). I think you missed my question, could you tell me where you stand on Bart? On that note, could you talk about who your top scumreads are in general because I have no clue what your gamestance is atm.

This read is probably my biggest disagreement with you, so I'll try to explain where I'm coming from. I had a pretty solid townread on him because of the KTS mess, since the conviction/anger about nobody sheeping him is pretty much what I've gotten used to (lol) seeing from him around his mislynches. There's also the minor mindmeld regarding FJP where I was getting ready to respond to FJP's wall but saw Bart's response and was like "Yeah, pretty much that". The 'lack of independent thought', which I can half-agree with is there is something he has as town as well and therefore not something I scumread him for. Finally, I'll doublecheck this, but what I remember from the game I played with scum!him (TPP), when he was discussing his scumreads he was talking about them, rather than to them. I (town) was one of his scumreads in that game and he kept repeating "Athena is playing to his scum meta" but didn't really question me/talk to me. In contrast, in training mafia where he was town he got into a 1v1 with his top scumread (who was scum) and his replies/pressuring there look a lot more like what I'm seeing from him against KTS at first and FJP now. I actually agree with almost all of your other reads, for example Alette which you worded pretty well imo. Maybe I disagree with you on yolo/snike, but I'll read that over again and get to it if/when I post a readslist. I don't really agree with your ordering though (even ignoring Bart), mostly because I'm not really sold on lynching RAD for gamestate reasons when there's actual scummy people around. So I'm in this weird spot where I agree with you on almost everything but don't really like where you end up, kinda similar to how I felt your posts made sense D1 but when I went back I didn't really like where your priorities were across the day.

Not so much that Refa's read is sheepable, but moreso that the Refa kill looks bad on you. Speaking of which: Going back to this defense of yours, this entire thing is silly. Omega had requested a sub before day end, so namekilling him is lol. Via had been inactive up till then. If Refa is a considerable namekill for you, if a step below Via, shouldn't him scumreading you push him over Via, like you're pretty much saying yourself here?

Not sure whether on purpose or not, but you're pulling my statement out of context. You were saying: "Why the fuck do I act the way I did WRT the Tuvy lynch at EoD as scum?" and using it as an argument you should be townread. I'm saying you'd totally do it as scum as well.

bark turn around ==> krab Should be c, not k Louis C.K. Louis "Louis Ferrante (born May 13, 1969) is a former Gambino family mobster" Gottem

Reason to move Shinori from null into scumleans. What do you think of Corrobin? Scum starting to crack or am I just bullying a townie?

I think it's a point in your favour, not a 100% lock-clear. How is that in any way an example of good logic? It's just a loud "I'm not scum" with some fancy words at the end imo.

Annoying is my middle name! Which posts did you agree with?

It may not matter to you, but it does matter to us who want to know whether you're town or scum and therefore need to know what you're thinking. Why do you trust Shinori now?

That doesn't mean you're voting at random. What made you go Shinori over others?

I think he's voting you for it atm actually

Why did you pick Shinori when others were talking nonsense / posting random images as well? What makes him trustable now?

Okay. Which post was it you misread?

@Corrobin You still haven't answered what the original reason you voted Shinori was and what you misread.

I hope you're all happy I'm not quotewalling by the way lmao

If you're scumreading him for his jokeposts or his aggressive tone, he does it as both town/scum.

Bottom quote was you in IDNSFMM5 right before the Junko lynch. (For context, both Junko/Shinori were scum) I'm not giving you any townpoints for what you did around EoD.

Not responding to FJP's wall because Bart pretty much covered it already and I agree with most of the points he (Bart) is making on it.

Why wouldn't he mention it if he's scum? If you're town and he's scum, why wouldn't he try to get you lynched over something like this?

Could you do me a favour and quote/bold the specific point you're answering here? You're quoting this massive FJP wall and answering with a single line so I'm a little lost as to what you're responding to.

Well, Refa's dead so.... Regarding me leaving the wagon, I was actually only gone for 30 minutes so I could see what people thought of my FJP case before I brought up the slip. This leaves Bart out of the three, can you talk to me more about how you feel on him? Idt you've really mentioned him before? Was your statement regarding scum in the middle voters meant because you were suspecting the three of us, or were you suspecting us for being the middle voters? (Lmk if you don't understand that I mean)

##Vote: Fairyjigglypuff