Jester's Gestures

Am slow reader. I'll get to it don't worry.

Your unvote was formatted wrong so the script didn't catch it. My bad though because I also missed that, but it doesn't change the fact that there was no vote activity from you until page 16, even though you were quite active in the thread. How does me making the point make it any less of a point? Your reluctance to vote seems like it comes from the perspective of not wanting to draw attention. How convinient of you to handwave the two largest wagons. Iirc you specifically put both of them as null in a readlist.

I'll be clear that I don't scumread Xbad, but you're telling me that you tr him 9/10 because he didn't know who died? It's not out of the realm of possibility to fake, so could you elaborate on that read? FoS RAD. Via and Dunn interactions don't read as scum buddies to me, especially EOD. Care to explain how via could've possibly bussed? The confidence behind this is a little off putting at first, but I can't say you haven't convinced me.

I was waiting for a specific person to post but since it's taking longer than I expected, I'll just explain my full reasoning behind the wienerboy lynch. First off, he stays parked on the Marth lynch for the longest time, although he was present and posting content and it didn't seem like he'd developed tunnel vision on Marth. Then near EOD, but far enough to not be real EOD, he tries to get Via to shift with him, from Ichiho to me. He's still online at real EOD, but doesn't really do anything there.

##Vote @weinerboy Vote patterns seems sus. Gonna wait until more people talk before saying more.

I'd prefer CFD to Athena because I feel like most of their posts have been asking questions rather than contributing themselves and I don't have any strong scumreads other than Ichigo. What's your thought process behind a supa lynch?

I don't buy it, but I also don't feel comfortable lynching it, because worst case scenario a tracker mislynch D2 is more productive than a tracker mislynch D1 imo.

##Unvote Care to claim flavor too?

ngl figuring out who Amy/Claire/Dunn/Marth/Soup were when I was reading up was a bit of a struggle

You can already see people defending me over the existence of a catchup post (which imo is NAI)? If you're lynching me because of Refa's words/actions or lack thereoff then I guess I have nothing to say really.

I don't know you, but I've heard your name before. I'd be extremely surprised if you knew me. I'm not proud to say it, but I'm from that one chatroom on a Japanese competetive monster fighting simulator website. Yes, I do happen to go by another username. Your content is exactly what I would expect from a town!xbad. Iirc, you were the first person to state a non-scumread on Bart after his early antics, and that's the kind of perspective I'd expect to see. I also find that I tend to agree with you more when you are town, which I think holds true this game. Plus, you haven't done anything crazy yet. As for my identity, well, that's classified, although I wouldn't be surprised if you guessed. I'm not really feeling this Marth lynch. Looking at wagon build up, weinerboy was parked on Marth for a while, RAD came in with a flimsy gut-read that even he seemed unsure about. Via lynching for mostly "low effort" I think? And unless I am missing something, Ichigo straight up OMGUS votes. It doesn't come off as extremely town motivated to me. ##VOTE @Ichigo I'll be on and off (probably lurking) until deadline.

page 9: Bart - "Marth is right that I pushed/grilled Amy" Hold up. Am I reading the right game? ampharos: filler bartozio: rvs ampharos ampharos: non-serious response bartozio: why aren't you voting claire? ampharos: i'm just like that bartozio: unvotes This doesn't seem like much of a push/grill to me. It was pretty weak and now I am starting to think possibly scripted, at least on Bart's end. RAD's vote on Jordan comes off as a little bit of OMGUS. I'm not a fan of his response to Xnad saying "BTW a very easy way to see if RAD is scum is to see if he reads me wrong. Guy has 100% accuracy on my alignment as Town." RAD say's it doesn't make sense coming from a town POV, but Xnad's statement still has it's merits, although I'd take everything "100%" with a grain of salt. Let's say RAD scum reads Xbad and lynches him. If Xnad were to flip town, RAD would be implicated as scum (assuming Xnad's statement that RAD has 100% accurate reads on him as Town is correct). What confuses me is that RAD proceeds to lynch Xbad right after. page 10: It looks like RAD's vote was more pressure than an actual read, but it's still a little odd to me. Lots of input from Mitsuru, but somehow my read on them is still null, possibly because I'm bad at making reads. page 11-12: I feel like Athena has been coasting a little bit, I don't think I've seen anything particularly stand out-ish. It's not sr-worthy, but I'd put him at null/scum as of now. weinerboy has a way of saying things that makes a lot of sense to me, but I'm not confident enough to give him a strong townread. Would anyone be kind enough to link me to a couple of games where Bartozio was mislynched? I'd like to compare some stuff. My attention span has reached its limit. I'll be back tomorrow.

First off, apologies for not posting after my first post because the text box to post disappeared and I had to message Fenrir about it and then it told me I had reached my posting limits and I had to wait 24 hours before posting again when I tried to reply probably because my account is new or something. He got an admin to manually validate me so shoutouts to whoever did that. Here's a summary of my thoughts on what I've read so far. page 1-2: 99% filler no comment page 3: Not a fan of Bartozio and Ampharos interactions. Bart questions Amph about voting but backs off completely after Amph responds, and Amph did not shift votes. I would be more inclined to believe bart!scum at this point. Also worth noting that he starts off with a vote on Amph, which could be assumed to be rvs since there is no additional reasoning, but only later does he question Amph, which leads to her response and Bart's unlynch. My first impressions say that Bartozio is not the kind of player to "lynch first ask questions later." Possibly could be Bart + Amph scum team, but it's way too early to tell. page 4: Mindmeld with RAD, but I don't think Claire coming off as defensive is indicative of her being scum. I'm a fan of the Bart wagon. page 5: weinerboy's vote on Marth rubs me the wrong way, but I can't really explain why, so no further comment. Most of what Refa said I agree with, but personally speaking I would've put my vote on Bart rather than Amph. page 6: I'm starting to get the impression that Vi-astra is high whenever he posts. Gut reaction to Xnad's posts is to say he's likely town, given that he's one of the people here who I've actually played mafia with before. Bart's comment of "'Besides people will realize I don't actually have someone who only made joke comments as lock scum, right?'" seems like he is walking back his vote, but he does not unlynch which I find strange. page 7: I'm going to trust everyone who's saying that Vi-astra's tone is natural and put him as a town slot. Putting Xnad as almost locktown. Marth reasoning about Ichigo would've been solid if Ichigo had voted Bart. Comes from a town perspective imo. I think I'll have to spend some time reading Bart's past games and possibly re-evaluate my read on him, but on the other hand I'm very lazy. page 8: Bart comes back with an immediate jab at Ichigo. Interesting. He keeps saying he grilled Ampharos, but it wasn't really much of a grill imo. I feel like Bart here is trying to build up the Ichigo counterwagon in order to save himself. Not exactly a great look.

testing 1 2 3 (hopefully I can post now)

Hi, first time posting on Serene's Forest. I've got 11 or so pages to read, so I'll get back to you guys hopefully soon.