I obtained Dragon Claws as a map drop and it’s still not giving me the achievement, and I know you don’t have to repair them to get it because I got Gradivus as an S rank reward and still earned the lance collector 2 achievement, so I don’t know what’s going on. I have iron, steel, wolf fangs, killer, aura, jarngreiper, vajra-mushti, and dragon claws. I even held onto a rusted and went through the trouble of getting training gauntlets.