Jump to content

Mapping Voting

Chocolate Kitty

By Chocolate Kitty
in Competition

  

23 members have voted

  1. 1. What map looks the best but still retains the base of the original mape the best?

    • [img]http://i.imgur.com/o3M8U.png[/img] - Aura Wolf
      1
    • [img]http://i132.photobucket.com/albums/q30/Feaw_2007/FeawMapContest07.png[/img] - Feaw
      5
    • [img]http://dl.dropbox.com/u/29863231/week10%20%281%29.png[/img] - Hero
      3
    • [img]http://www.majhost.com/gallery/Neo-SL/Maps/competition_map_10.png[/img] - SuperLuigi
      8
    • [img]http://i165.photobucket.com/albums/u67/anouleth/fffortscrn-1.png[/img] - Anouleth
      1
    • [img]http://i.imgur.com/oGs6G.png[/img] - Primefusion
      5

Recommended Posts

Caliban of Sycorax Newbie

Caliban of Sycorax

Posted
Posted

There's a lot of good ones, but I think feaw's is a nice twist on the original, and I'm a sucker for the snow tilesets.

Primefusion Newbie

Primefusion

Posted
Posted

The most common issue between all of them was how the upper right was handled. Some of the maps make it very difficult to access that area of the map. A lot of them also use broken walls but using just one tile of broken walls creates a height issue. Overall, I think Anouleth handled that part the best but his stairs to nowhere elsewhere really detract from the overall map. Superluigi also handled it well but the room itself doesn't really serve too much of a purpose unless an important person were in that room and the player needed to rescue them.

Gripes aside, this is a pretty tough choice. Going with Feaw though everyone else is literally right behind him.

Celice Newbie

Celice

Posted
Posted

SuperLuigi's is the most playable of them all, and isn't bad looking either.

I should have finished my map--everyone here did the same boring thing D:

Wolf Newbie

Wolf

Posted
Posted

Anouleth's is my favorite because there are many areas to engage in, and there are many breakable walls to open up more paths to attack from. Though, Feaw's snowtile theme looks nice.

Darros Apprentice

Darros

Posted
Posted

Well, since Eric hasn't visited yet I threw in my vote.

Voted for SuperLuigi, that map looks fun! ^^

Anouleth Newbie

Anouleth

Posted
Posted

Overall, I think Anouleth handled that part the best but his stairs to nowhere elsewhere really detract from the overall map.

I wasn't really sure how to handle those stairs, but I though that the stairs leading up and ending in a staircase that goes down looked ridiculous.

Chocolate Kitty Newbie

Chocolate Kitty

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Deadline, Eric.

Ror, stop putting my name out there :p

And like I'm getting up early to end contests either lol

Anyway, the voting was for 3 days anyway you gun jumper you

Darros Apprentice

Darros

Posted
Posted

Ror, stop putting my name out there :p

We all know it by now anyway

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...