Mapping Voting

[Chocolate Kitty]

Alright, so this time we'll do that "work off a base map" deal from a few rounds ago. This time, however, there's choices:

Folks can choose either indoors or outdoors. The border squares can be deleted obviously.

The base portion can also be moved around as seen fit. However, do not alter its contents.

If you choose the indoor base, you must add an additional chest somewhere on your map.

If you choose the outdoor base, you must add an additional village OR 2 houses (The 1 tile variety).

Dimensions: 15x10 to 30x30

Palette swaps are allowed, but the actual type of tileset needs to remain the same (Overworld/Generic Castle). Custom palettes are a go.

herp'n and a derp'n

[Primefusion]

Sweet turnout this round ^_^

Went with Kenshi for being a relative newcomer to the contest and producing a pretty solid map.

[Aura Wolf]

Voted for Feaw.

[CT075]

Kenshi, for the same reason as Prime

[Klokinator]

Voted prime. Only thing I'd change is adding a destructible wall with 100 HP at the bottom of the right hallway, to give you an alternate route to the chest. Otherwise, I love the layout a lot.

[deranger]

Solid turn out, all the maps did most things right. And they all look dece

nitpicking & reasoning for my vote:

If I didn't list it below, I thought it was good.

Prime's height errors (the whole right wall) turned me off that one.

Kenshi's has too long of straight diagonal cliffs, and the southwest road looks unnatural.

Prime's had an initial wow effect, but didn't seem that interesting to play on after further consideration.

Cam's was kinda bare (could be intentional, but...)

Ended up going with Aura, because it's randomness felt well spaced out, making me think it'd be fun to play.

[Anouleth]

Sweet turnout this round ^_^

Went with Kenshi for being a relative newcomer to the contest and producing a pretty solid map.

It has a couple of mistakes, if you didn't notice.

[Primefusion]

Correctness wasn't why I voted for him =P

[Celice]

It has a couple of mistakes, if you didn't notice.

So did every submission.

[Chocolate Kitty]

was close, literally i had to vote to tie break

so, because of that i'll have a legit tie breaking poll, up for 24 hours