ninjapokemon

Well I think I was exaggerating when I was saying how logically superior my theory is. I was half serious half not serious on that point. You're right again but I'm not wrong you know? We can only work with what the game's scripts tell us. Because anytime you deviate from that, anything can happen based on anyone's imagination. All I am saying is if based on the scripts and scripts alone, my theory works! :)

^ Actually, Camilla does say in her S-rank support she has loved Avatar since they first met. Avatar is her first love. She then ponders whether this is what a breakup feel like should Avatar reject her love proposal. Look I understand the general feelings expressed but all I am saying is the above is true. There is a VERY strong argument for Camilla's canon love interest, unrequited perhaps, to be the Avatar. However, theory 2 states that if in a subsequent play through, Camilla does not refer to Avatar as her first love, or loved him since they first met, etc, then in that particular play through, Avatar being the first love of Camilla does not hold. It is really quite simple.

unknown at this point.

^ You aren't wrong. But I am not wrong either. Why? Because my theory is about Apple, Orange and Peach. It is not about Camila. My theory is about a way of thinking. And in fact, theory number 1 and 2 is exactly what you are proposing right now. Theory 2 suggests previous knowledge of S-rank supports details iis not canon for subsequent playthroughs. Apple's first love is Orange in play through 1. Though you know Apple loved Orange in play through 1, play through 2 is about Apple loving Peach since forever. Play through 1's knowledge does not hold. My theory is so damn good.

Yes, actually, canon is your pairings for a particular play through: 1) Say if Apple is S-ranked with Orange. Apple says I have been in love with Orange since the first time I met you. This is now canon for first play through. Apple canonically loves Orange and Apple's first love is Orange. 2) Now, Apple is S-ranked with Peach. Apple says I have been in love with Peach since forever. ​This is now canon for the second play through. Even though you know from the first play through that Apple loved Orange before S-rank has occurred, this knowledge is gained from the previous play through, and thus it does not hold in the current second play through. Apple canonically loves Peach and has loved peach since forever. You interpret what forever means. This is my theory and I propose this theory to TC to ease his worries. Look I hear you. But Camilla's affection towards Avatar is romantic in nature. She says so in her S-rank support. Unless Camilla continues to suggest she still holds romantic feelings towards Avatar when she S-ranked other characters and only until such words are uttered, my theory above still holds but shall now be changed slightly: 3) Apple is still S-ranked with Peach. But Apple says to Peach, I still hold romantic feelings for Orange. Apple says I cannot forget Orange as Orange is my first love. On the second play through and on this play through only, Apple still canonically loves Orange despite S-ranking Peach. This is different from 2) because Apple uttered such words. Apple canonically holds romantic feelings for Orange, Apple's first love is Orange, despite being now married to Peach. I hope I have put everyone to ease with my grand but very well thought out and logically superior theory.

^ Interesting, but not entirely convincing. Maribelle says I have loved you since early on to Chrom. Maribelle doesn't say the same thing but it is Ricken who says I have loved you forever to Maribelle. Debunked. Lissa says Frederick is first love. Lissa says I loved you forever to Stahl. First love > forever as forever can just be a hyperbole. DEBUNKED Your theory isn't holding up that well tbh.

Me too, would like to see.

Terrible. But this is coming over to NA and EU. I am just going to ignore this system message and ignore paralogues. There is enough content (3 games worth) for me anyway. I didn't really interact much with the nextgen characters in Awakening anyway. I thought they were silly, shallow, and a waste of time ad my memory.

My memory is fading, may I ask which characters say something akin to I have been in love with you forever during S-Rank for Awakening? And do the same character say the same I have been in love with you forever to other characters too during S-Rank?

Actually, she says she loves the avatar SINCE THE FIRST TIME SHE LAID EYES on the avatar. This is where the TC is getting at. Camilla "canonically" is already in love with the Avatar even before S-Rank is reached.

Actually by OP's logic, Kamui cannot be a bigger one, because Kamui has no personality so theres no point of reference. Camilla has a trait which make her obsesses over Avatar. But because this trait can be overcome, she is a slut because she can forgo her first love to the point of obsession and marry someone like, Harold. Lol. ^ I think this is what OP's logic is trying to express. Here's my advice to you TC: There is no canon for character pairings in FE IF. You are the master of your play through. You decide who romances who. Your decisions are canon for your play through. Only chrom x village girl is canon. Enjoy the game.

Anyone has links to Hinoka x M Avatar S support + Amie?

Why don't you just use my way? Here: 1. Once S-Ranked, do not do any prologues. That is all you have to do to ignore the nextgen characters and it makes no impact on the story. Regarding the system message that shows once S-Rank is achieved, you can feel free to ignore it. I mean FE is all about YOUR OWN experience. What is canon for you, canon for your playthrough, is canon for you only. Nothing more nothing less.

No. Nohrian siblings --> biological father = Garon. Mothers are the Queen and 3 other concubines. Aqua --> mother and father are apparently dragons. Garon is not Aqua's biological father. Mikoto --> not wife of Sumeragi. Hoshido siblings --> all biological children of King Sumeragi and the late Queen Ikona. Avatar --> biological child of Mikoto. Father is Hydra. There you go.