Aere
-
Posts
267 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Posts posted by Aere
-
-
Aere: It's not that you dying makes him scum. I think he's scum. I'm just saying that if you're still alive, I'll probably be voting you. And gj echoing both my point on Sage and my call to Anouleth to talk more about his reads.
that was directed at you, not him. Way to misunderstandWhile I also agree with her read on Sage, I feel that was an incredibly easy observation. Do you have more reads on other, active players?
And I missed your part about Anouleth, haha. Point still stands, though.
-
I'm feeling town vibes from Manix and eclipse, mainly because they haven't only focused on me post-lynch. They had valid points against Marth page 29. Manix, I didn't pick Oracle because I am not the greatest at predicting power roles, and I just don't like killing myself. Eclipse has also been responding to a lot of posts, with respectable logic, for a little while now.
I'm not feeling alright wrt scorri. She decided to focus on kirsche after my lynch, for no other reason than she thinks calling for an investigation is scummy. How is calling for an investigation worse than calling for a vig or a roleblock? She's being a bit passive-agressive against him as of her last post, too, as I don't see how me dying makes him scum. I don't like how she just believed elie's claim, either. While I also agree with her read on Sage, I feel that was an incredibly easy observation. Do you have more reads on other, active players?
Anouleth has had all of 1 content post and 0 votes. Who are your top 3 scum reads?
-
I was planning on fullclaiming VERY SOON AFTER my softclaim. I ended up doing something else, though. Pretty sure I already said this.
-
needs more don't stop me now
-
To be honest, I was intending to come back after that post. Real life got in the way. I got home a couple hours ago, after my lynch.
-
Well, my logic process has clearly not been that great this game. My restriction was a non-killing role. I just picked a role to keep myself alive longest, so I could hopefully benefit town, rather than pick a gambling role.
-
I said WHY PICK DEATHPROOF when scum usually doesn't target you anyway? If you're town that's the only thing you'll worry about, and not lynches.
Um, why would I think scum usually doesn't target me? Me being deathproof allows one cleared town/one less doctor protect/one less cop target. Well, that's what I had thought. I was a better lynch target than Elie, which could imply a bunch of things.
-
What? You think there weren't any scum in the wagon on me? Now they have no reason to kill me: You guys are all probably power roles, I'm a vanilla. Why would they kill me.
-
Most important thing in a game of mafia is your word and your vote. Me getting multiple lives fits with that standpoint.
I obviously didn't think of having it turn out this way, but...
Why do I always lose motivation in the games I actually want to play
-
Thanks for listening guys! I need to be around more when it matters.
My restriction was to pick a town role without killing abilities. I can't be mafia, or have a mafia alliance. I picked Iris from touhou.
I literally can't be scum. But now I'm vanilla, which is sick :/
-
Yeah elie. I'm claiming scum /sarcasm
-
Scorri for wagoning? I posted one or two short posts between those times, because I wanted to see how elie reacted. He posted numerous times, I though it over (and referenced it), then placed a vote. Plus it was Yom Kippur, I was on my phone, I think.
Lynching me would gain literally no information. Scum literally can't kill me.
-
In school can't post -.-
-
So, according to you, I'm scummy because I am me, combined with the fact that I find Manix scummy (thus voted him), and also that I didn't feel the need to out every scumread that I had all in one post. I've since then, outed my scumreads (now I have to split my focus and create and manage 5 cases at once, something I had hoped to do just a few at a time).
Your reasoning for voting Manix was that he didn't want to end RVS, and then you provided no other reasoning. What? It's incredibly hypocritical for you to call Manix scummy because your RVS views differ from his.
I'm not gonna post much more tonight. I'm really tired.
-
I feel like Elie is voting me to get the vote off him...
And you're completely misinterpreting my tone. I've been nothing but calm this entire game.
-
I was more concerned with the part where he just said "grasping" or "meta" to my posts. How exactly was I grasping? The second half of his post is also defense, not elaborating against me.
-
Snike, I called it defensive because he used the exact same words to counter me, in a snide tone. Straw Grasping and Metagaming? I accused him of both earlier. That whole half screamed "No, you!".
-
My posts regarding Psych were for clarification. Psych placed a vote on me for a terrible reason (I stood out), and while I hadn't thought it was scummy, I wanted to see what the rest of you thought. I was trying to understand him (and Elie) myself, and I was posting my thoughts so others could correct me/whatever.
Shinori, why do you feel Kay is town?
-
Meta and grasping
Meta
Grasping.
Meta (merely mentioned, right?)
This is probably the most defensive half of a post I've ever read.
-
I said you're playing like you normally do, but that does not excuse you being scummy. I merely mentioned your meta, you are still scummy regardless.
-
-
I would not call my feelings towards Elie based on gut.
With aere, I feel like grasping at straws is a filler excuse to jump on the wagon. I don't really see how 319 is grasping at straws, if only because it's bad logic for the vote, but nothing grabbed out of thin air. As for 306, it came out of the blue, yes, but how can you dismiss it as straw-grasping? It doesn't feel good to me, to sum things up.I called both of those posts straw grabbing because 319 felt like an attempt to get the attention off of himself and push it onto his vote, rather than actually voting for a scumread. 306 felt like an excuse to say "hey I've posted reads let's not focus on me".
-
Why did the post above sound so defensive in regards to psych if you see his reasoning as bad reasoning to vote you? No one else was on you at all. No one was even talking about you, where did this come from? Were you stating this because you think Psych is scum? I'd like to hear that case because I don't see it at all.
Well, it wasn't defensive... so yeah. Everything I've said in regards to Psych has just been me being confused because he doesn't make sense.
Elie tends to get votes on him D1 because he sounds scummy. This does not excuse him from sounding scummy, however. I was merely making note of his playstyle (which seems to be the same no matter his alignment anyway).
-
Can't tell what his beef with Aere actually is though.
Good, because I can't either and I'm still confused. Everything Psych does is confusing me.
I agree with Rapier that BBM looks fine for his defense on Shinori. Kirsche is metagaming, and while it may seem valid here, I myself would jump to Shinori's drunken defense. Typos are NOT scummy, and it's happened to me before (claiming iris/eclipse in Paper's last game) so I understand.
Manix is being typical gut-lead Manix, Elie is grasping for straws (#319 and that vague list #306) , I'd rather not lynch Prims today, we'll have time to think about PGO later... Elie is my strongest feel so ##Vote: Elieson though I am thinking he's playing like he plays D1 a lot
Nostalgia Mafia Game Over
in Mafia
Posted
For further clarification, I'm saying your (scorri's) read on Sage was a pseudo-contribution.