Kamina
-
Posts
0 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Kamina's Achievements
Newbie (1/14)
-
##Unvote ##Vote: Nemu Kurotsuchi Went back to look at Nemu's ISO after reading this and there are issues regarding Nemu's progression on her reads. She starts out with voting Estelle and in that post seems pretty confident in Estelle being scum right up until All Might says Estelle's lack of reads is a scumtell and Nemu is suddenly like "Actually I think it reads as genuinely lost town" without much explaining and without moving her vote. She says she needs more time to parse it but instead of parsing it we get a comment on a single post of Estelle that doesn't have to do with her lack of reads, and then Nemu switches to a Sham vote despite very little focus on Sham beforehand. She's really quick to move to Violet (despite going back to Sham right after she then moved back to Violet before Violet posted again) for an "unimpressive catch up" and all 3 of these votes as well as her comments on Ochako feel opportunistic and keeping her options open for where she can put her vote. On a lesser note, I still don't feel like she's giving C. C. the attention she'd be giving C. C. if she was town and her willingness to give C. C. another chance but not Violet is off-putting. Thought I posted this before going rip.
-
The interaction between Estelle/Nemu where they're talking about C. C./Violet is making me start to like Estelle more and I can buy what she was saying earlier about "when I notice something I'll jump at it" based on how focused she's been on those two.
-
I don't see the hedging on Ochako. Sham was pretty consistently pushing her up until the unvote, which was explicitly stated to be "giving her a chance." Do you think that, as far as the second half goes, scum!Sham would "blatantly lie" or that "not paying attention" is a scumtell?
-
Kamina unexpectedly out. Shouldn't be too long.
-
@Nemu Kurotsuchi I'm in no way 100% caught up, but I want to ask you while you're here how your thought process has evolved on C. C. from where you were like "at least C. C. discusses specific things" and voted Violet to now, when you're willing to vote C. C./Ochako over Violet.
-
@Olivier and whoever else was having this thought, how was C. C. engaging people in her first post?
-
9's got some good things. First off @Sham, I saw you offer All Might some reading lessons. If Marisa shoots me down, how about... Estelle's post on C. C. goes into a lot of detail and brings up some pretty good points, namely C. C.'s failure to address Estelle's substance issues and Nemu's lack of a reaction to C. C. despite their reaction to Violet. I also noticed C. C. seems to be giving a disproportionate amount of attention to only a couple of people, looking out for her thoughts on more than just Olivier/Ochako/Aizen/one line on Sham. That's a weird list of people to take note of imo, especially since you did acknowledge, for example, All Might, but only to comment on his postcount. Think Sham's observation of Nemu creating a false dichotomy is a valid one. Going to ask your thoughts on C. C.'s first post though and my initial thoughts on Violet's post. @All Might walk me through the thought process that led up to your Sham vote. Manly as you may be, I''m ultimately the paragon of manliness and I'm set to veto it. @Cú Chulainn wasn't the post you linked by Sham their entrance? I don't place much stock in the "they RVSed when there were other things" argument since I myself will sometimes RVS upon entering regardless of what else is going on. On the topic of Ochako, here's what I'm wondering: if she was being pressured to do more by All Might and she resolved to make an effort, would it be a town reaction to call All Might town and then also only question All Might? What I was saying when I agreed with Sham was that it felt way more like she was just putting it out there to get All Might off her back.
-
Oh, and then All Might take a step back at the top of 9. 'K.
-
Estelle's vote on C. C. isn't especially bad, I can see @All Might entering the tunnel already at the bottom of page 8. You can't very well get upset about someone not solving and then accuse them of just trying to look good once they start making solvy posts.
-
Some good questions for me to ask myself probably, putting this here for self reference.
-
C. C.'s first post has a lot of shadey one-liners thrown about and it finishes with some reconsidering but the work seems half finished. Want to see more here (and yes there may be more past where I've read), especially want to hear what she thinks of my take on Ochako, which is a scumread for a different set of reasons. Speaking of Ochako, probably need to go back and look at her again since I also remember having a thought that she could be new/inexperienced town. Violet's catchup lines up a lot with my thoughts at this point in the thread. Want to see what she thinks of myself and Marisa, I think we both had enough at that point to get some sort of opinion on. Nemu's subsequent vote on Violet feels bad, Violet's post shows some effort to scumhunt in their catchup and I feel like you're just voting there because it's not this long wall with quotes and everything. Put differently, yes there's a summary but it's an analytical summary. The Estelle read's a holdover, I'm on page 8 right now.
-
Also in agreement with this, something felt off to me about Nemu's first post and how they just responded to my post with "This is good", but I wasn't sure if it was just my paranoia acting up.
-
Indeed we haven't! Allow me to introduce myself! The reputation of Team Dai-Gurren echoes far and wide. When they talk about its badass leader, the man of indomitable spirit and masculinity...they're talking about me: The Mighty Kamina! Now that that's been established, let me introduce you to my band of blood brothers: AKA the new Team Gurren: All Might, Sham, and Olivier. Cu's also on his way to recieving an invitation. Estelle and Ochako, meanwhile, are what we'd call Beastmen. Even without being caught up though, I still don't feel great about being on a wagon earlier alongside the top two wagons. I literally just got to Violet's first post, so things are about to get interesting. Marisa and Aizen are quickly becoming these revolving door reads where I'll get to the end of a page and scumread them, then get to the end of the next page and townread them. Overall I feel more confident in Aizen being town than Marisa. Your time to shine, I guess, where are you at?
-
Lol12hours Kamina in. And still pretty far behind but also here to talk while he reads.
-
Kamina out (for less than 12 hours though).
