Weapon Icon Voting

[CT075]

The goal was to make a B-rank anima tome.

Do not penalize someone because their tome looks like another tome of its kind (IE, a GBA version of Rexcalibur should not be penalized only because it looks like Rexcalibur).

Lord Glenn:

Camtech:

Psych:

Iavasechui:

Acey:

Ghostclown:

Astra:

13th:

Feaw:

BlackShadow:

Spiker:

Hithere:

Do not vote for yourself. I will be checking this.

Edited April 14, 2011 by Camtech075

[Psych]

Gonna have to go with Astra. All the others either look too low, or the ones that don't (Glenn, Cam, Feaw) look either too dark or dull to me.

[AstraLunaSol]

To me, Hithere's tome looks the most B Ranked.

Others look a bit too flashy. :/

Therefore my vote goes to Hithere.

[Nanami Touko]

Votin' for hithere because it looks like a Goomba good B rank tome.

[Feaw]

So many options, and so many epic icons @.@

I decided to vote for Glenn since it looks the flashiest and cleanest.

[13th]

Had ti go with iava-whatever. I can't spell your name, but I can vote for you/

[Amelia]

Uh, voted Astra's. Cause it's shiny.

Although Feaw's, Cammy's, and Glen's are shiny, too, but they're too fancy-looking, more like a A rank than a B rank to me. And it looks like that Fimb-whatever that ice spell is called. I can't remember its name.

The others are non-flashy and dull. :<

[iavasechui]

Had ti go with iava-whatever. I can't spell your name, but I can vote for you/

XD You can just call me iava for short. Thank you by the way for the vote ^_^ That's my first tome ever. XP Pity I suck at animations XD otherwise I would make an earth magic animation to go with it, as its supposed to be an earth tome.

Edited April 12, 2011 by iavasechui

[Lord Glenn]

Well, I guess I picked a great "challenge" for this week, seeing as there were a ton of entries and we don't already have a clear-cut winner in the voting.

I went with hithere's icon as I feel that it fits the regular GBA tome design quite nicely and does seem potentially representative of a B-rank tome.

I do have to give a slight partial mention to Ghostclown's icon, just for the subject matter and noble attempt to make a tome with it. I feel that if you were to tweak the shading and colors used for the phoenix and make the rest of the icon a bit more... noticable, you'd have a pretty damn snazzy tome. Granted, it probably wouldn't fit the criteria of this round, but it'd still be snazzy.

[CT075]

Tiebreaker time, I guess.

[iavasechui]

0_0 I can't believe I'm actually tied with Lord Glenn with my first tome ever (and third ever weapon sprite period)

[CT075]

Closed, next round up as soon as I can get a hold of Josh.