Ampharos

i hm i think i changed my mind "Actually I'll claim because people will waste their investigative roles on me." is not a thought a villager has. People who are already being scumread aren't good investigative role targets. if we think of him as mafia afraid of copchecks, on the other hand, the thought makes sense i think it was the "I'd rather not claim because it makes me functionally vanilla."

anyways i'm gonna reread marth claiming the role itself is still a high ev scum role but i remember thinking the actual process of the claim felt genuine and i need to see if that holds

er a pretty good NA target words are hard

on the contrary to what's been stated earlier i think fable is a pretty damn good pick for neighborizer -not a scumread -v unlikely to die -terse on d1 (meaning that talking more can only be a good thing as far as determining his alignment goes) if approached from the perspective of "trying to figure out fable's alignment" i think it becomes a pretty dang good claim

somebody's gotta

are you accounting for the fact that I'm in central time tho also never change via

anyways i'm going to work and yes i do realize it's an absolutely stupid time to have to go to work there's a reason i've been sleeping a ridiculous amount during the day lately

i'll probably just refer to it as "nate's role" tbh or "mack's role" if i happen to remember that nate subbed out

nope you're gonna have to deal with me sorry

like, if i'm scum last night and refa's my buddy i'm p much 0% worried that he's getting targeted maybe nate was trying to steal a town role from him? but, like... what role? believing this role is scum requires me to jump through too many hoops so i'm just gonna roll w/ occam's razor

mafia decoy would be a pretty bad role to begin with p much good for absorbing info roles/MAYBE a vig shot if it has built in protection and either way i feel like there are better targets for that than refa think that slot's probably just town fml also i think refa's still in my confident town pile tbh

ok so nate's actually a decoy good to know this changes things tho fuck gotta rethink

am i misunderstanding the meaning of the term "martyr" on this site where i come from it's "target x person, all of x's actions are redirected to you"

yes and refa is definitely the other one based on what nightmare claimed happened last night i thought this was common knowledge

oh i guess put satsuma in the confident townpile thank you snike and thank you hydras

oh yeah and my wolfpile sucks marth's roleclaim itself isn't alignment indicative but the manner in which it was made gives me pause. everything about his play is wolfy but this is a pretty big asterisk mack is based off of nightmare's d1 vote. the issue with this is that while the vote was poorly handled regardless, it's not really worth anything unless athena flips scum as well zeus i would prefer be vigged if we have one. no sense wasting a lynch here if we can help it.

ok let's start with some piles --confident town-- eclipse Refa Snike Via --less confident town-- BBM Bibbon Fable Shinori SullyMcGully --null-- everyone not listed --wolfy-- Marth Mackc2 zeus_12 my first and biggest problem with this list is that my nullpile is too big. i'll probably need to reread d1 to get anything resembling a read on the people in that pile (cause people like kirsche junko jb etc haven't made more than like 2 posts d2) my thoughts on the co-neighborizer thing is that while there's no guarantee that both are town, i think it's incredibly unlikely that neither is town; hence, i'm pretty damn sure Refa's town (and i probably would be even if he hadn't have claimed)

snike's probably town for jumping on nate's perceived scumslip the way he did that said i don't think it was actually a slip

i'm catching up v slowly kind of writing off what i missed on d1 for now and starting with the beginning of d2 nate's d1 vote was scummy tho

hi i'm back sorry been taking care of rl shit (didn't help that i was working+sleeping for literally the last 17 hours of d1) will reread

wait is rein really not playing oops

so are we just not gonna talk about the reinfleche drive-by or