Thank you. I will definitely give it a read.
Why thanks. Was it so much to ask? By the way, I'm switching up the order of characters in your response...which will make sense as you read this post.
Canas
This seems like a pretty weak argument. First of all, as this is not a ranked list, the price of Dark tomes is pretty much irrelevant. There's ample gold available to give him as much as he needs. Ditto how "rare" dark tomes are. Why wouldn't you just stock up on them? As for him being not particularly good, I suppose the best way for me to respond to that is to ask...
- Is balance of physical characters and magic uses so unimportant in this game? If not, which mage would you use over Canas?
- Is coverage of the magic triangle so unimportant?
Also, his DEF seems a bit high for a mage, which is nice.
Nino
Why bother? Umm...because she's good, and because at join time, your promoted units exp growth is quite low? I'm not saying that she's a top-tier character of anything, but she seems worthy of consideration at the very least.
Marcus and Matthew
Ah, this certainly clears a lot up...apparently the criteria for this list are not what I imagined them to be (and yes, I did read the Ranking FAQ). To me, it seems a matter of course that one will be leaning on Marcus and Matthew early on, and, in the case of Matthew, until quite late (sadly). I had assumed that characters higher on the list are more worthy of investing experience in so to use for the last few chapters of the game, your 'final team', if you will. I understand and agree with what you're saying about Marcus and Matthew, but it seems like something of a non sequitor for them to be be ranked highly because of it - because they are characters you want to MINIMIZE the amount of experience they gain, right?
Mist: I had no idea people were so concerned with "efficiency". Your remarks made good sense in light of that.
I'd also love to hear how many levels people are gaining for their promoted characters after 28 which Nino is stealing. Oh wait, efficiency..hmm, doesn't sound very fun, does it?