Bibbon

From this perspective, does Weapons not look scummy?

This is why I disagree with the scum read on Athena, especially the Snike (?) slot is looking the worse for it. I'm not calling them scum as of yet, but you should know that poor logic is more likely to come from town than it is from scum. Anybody who has played a few games should know this. It's so easy for scum to pull apart the reads and the logic and push for mislynches.

I'm good at seeing contexts and narratives, which is how I scum hunt. I don't harp on players for flaws in logic, that is, if their actions make sense. Because I know that both village and wolf do that, since most people aren't logical all the time. This is why a more effective method of catching scum is by seeing how their narrative shifts. You have done that several times this game. You dropped your vote on Athena and now focused on two different players. Your "joke" vote earlier, the parked vote on Fable, it does not follow one consistent narrative. This is why I think you're scum.

Well, Shinori hasn't done anything concretely scummy. That being said, my gut has proved to be correct on more than one occasion. Anyway, I'll keep it in mind and be thorough with his posts.

I don't really understand the relevance of characters this game, but from what Vi Astra said, they are probably town, I think.

I can't point to anything concrete but I have my eyes open to anything from him. And yes, that was an admittance of scummyness. He knows it himself.

It is an unnatural progression, but you seem to know that already, which is why you emphasize that it's "a correct read." As for your question, no, a shift in narrative wouldn't come from town.

In my role PM it says that I'm kirsche

Are you asking me to claim my tarot card?

Weapons probably my top scum read. I still haven't forgotten that logical shift in pushing Athena. To me he comes off as pushing whatever he can (?)

It's disturbing that I caught on to this fact without having any prior experience to playing with them.

I'm thinking BBM has to be town here for pushing me first and then backing off when he read the long post. I assume as scum, he would continue to push me(?). This reasoning maybe weak, but this combined with everything else, makes me think town for him.

I jailkept eclipse last night.

@Vi-astra I'm also paranoid of Shinori, but I have nothing concrete to go off, which is why I didn't name my suspicions of them on D1. Is there any reason to be paranoid of them?

Nvm my previous post. I guess I hadn't caught up yet