Jump to content

SullyMcGully

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    486

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Posts posted by SullyMcGully

    SFMM5 Game Thread- Town wins!

    in Mafia

    Posted

    OKAY so I'm trying to be a good town leader and I have your TL-recommended wagons right here! 

    I would prefer it if we lynched one of the following 3 players, in the following order:

    EvanManManManManManMan: Evan was Brook's only solid scumread. After reevaluating things a bit, I still find Evan to be highly suspicious mainly because: 1) his case on Refa isn't that good, 2) heis reluctant to answer certain questions that I fail to see the town intent in not answering, and 3) he claims to trust me and the rest of the towncore, yet he has told us nothing about himself. Even if he just dislikes the concept of a town leader, that's still no good reason to not share that information with someone who he trusts. @EvanManManMan I'm not going to share your information with anyone else (even though the only people I would trust with said info are people you yourself read as town) or try to control your NA if you don't want me to, so why can't you tell me that information? Why are you hiding info from me if you trust me? I just don't see the town intent in any of that. 

    Refa: As I said before, none of the cases I've heard Evan/KTS/the rest of their cadre come up with this player are that good. The only reason I suspect Refa is because of how weird his playstyle feels to me this game. We're used to Refa being the sociable question-asker who never stops scumhunting. Or at least I am. This game, he's seemed significantly less chatty and less inquisitive. Yesterday morning Refa left me a list of reads. It was actually kinda good, which made me wonder, why isn't he pushing any of these? Maybe he is and I just can't see it. But he really should be defending himself now. None of the defenses I've seen him put up so far have been very comforting.

    TBH I like the Evan lynch more than Refa, but I get that a lot of you would disagree with that and I still think Refa is acting scummy, so lynching Refa might give town some good info to go off of. I really am getting more scumvibes from Evan's slot though, while Refa is just making me scratch my head and realize I shouldn't be scratching my head about Refa when he's on top of his game. There is one more slightly viable lynch though:

    Weapons: I've given my logic on this one, but basically his whole game so far feels sheepy and lurky. If he's been actively scumhunting, I certainly haven't noticed it. However, due to his lack of presence this lynch has few associative reads with it and I'm remembering Weapons acted in a similar way back in IDNSFMM5. I'd only lynch here if my other two reads had good defenses. 

    Who else am I suspicious of? Phoenix has been lurking. He told me he'd put more effort into this game on D3 so I'm letting him off the hook for a little bit but if I'm not impressed with what I see then... he'll be in trouble. Also Euk seems town so far but he could be in a similar boat if I don't notice him putting some real effort in once we need it. There are a few others I won't share about, but I think you get the idea with who I want lynched tonight. Also remember I probably won't be around at deadline. Since the Refa wagon seems to have enough momentum to take off without my vote, I'm leaving my vote here:

    ##Vote: EvanManManMan

    SFMM5 Game Thread- Town wins!

    in Mafia

    Posted

    So, uh, does anybody have any... y'know...

     

    READS???

    I'm not the happiest with Refa's playstyle this game either, but I'm not going to let people just jump on this without explaining their reasoning. If there was a really good case against him D1 that I'm missing or something, then please just show me to it. But this kind of wagon is exactly what my predecessor saved us from D1. We're not going to accept a mislynch, and some of these votes here come across to me as rather baseless. Particularly @WeaponsofMassConstruction give me your reasoning via posting here or over Discord, please.

     

     

×
×
  • Create New...