Bibbon

My meta read on Fable says he's town. I can read him successfully most of the time. He usually puts in more effort as scum.

Okay here's a question. if not you then who?

Really, because I thought it was manipulative.

Yee, I agree. For voting, I just have to type it out right? ##Vote zeus_112 If the formatting is incorrect, please let me know.

Actually, I want to vote you for this post.

You're saying here, don't lynch me, don't shoot me. Yet you're doing nothing to prevent this. Actually, I'm not too sure. There's too little content to go off of. Like maybe we should lynch him? I'm not too sure. But each post he makes is worse than the last one.

Weapons could very well be scum I think.

Possibly. I understand, but lynching him today would be a waste of a lynch, I think. If there's ever a lack of options we could do it. I think he's given up more or less, so if it comes to it, his teammates will probably buss him.

Okay I tried the Multuquotes and it didn't work. In the quote right before this one, you clearly said that Athena doesn't look bad for backing off and that you could see yourself doing that yourself This is your literal next post, and your progression is awkward I think. How do you go from "I can see myself doing this" to "Yeah, he's scum for doing that" I don't see it. Also, why are you asking a player to self meta? Since when is self meta useful at all? You should know this? Or are you just asking for the sake of asking?

Even if we lynch you, we're likely to get no info from that.

Actually Zeus might even be a bad info lynch.

It means you plan on getting by with little effort. Just do nothing the game, and expect us to be okay with it. We're not going to be.

Well, what I said was in response to BBM saying someone is not at risk of being lynched. I said that's not true. The risk is ever present. Please understand, I'm not critiquing your playstyle.

Not too sure what to make of it. Could be scum. There's no actual content there.

I think it's strange how Zeus thinks the only two options are "defend myself" and "get lynched" This is extremely survival motivated, to the point it's not towny anymore. I understand, you don't want to be lynched as town, but, town has other priorities as well, like scum hunting. There's none of that going on here.

My point is, if you don't think someone is scum, you should defend them. A highly discussed player is at risk of being lynched, regardless of alignment. I'm not saying don't discuss players. I never said that.

It's your casual style that's bothering me. You are just so carefree about this thing, and it's about the only thing you've consistently done. You have a handful of posts, of which 3, and now 4 of them are defending yourself. You don't seem to be doing much and that is my problem. You are not planning to coast, are you? That's bad regardless of alignment.

Do you think votes are the only things that matter? If a player is cased a lot and has a lot of negative attention drawn to them, they eventually end up being lynched at some point. This is why I typically discourage talking about the same person all the time. If you have a bunch of people saying "I didn't like this post, I didn't like that post" eventually it adds up and lynches happen like that.

I wanted to point this out. You've clarified this two times before. That you don't want votes on me. I think it's strange you'd mention this so many times. I think this just comes off as "I'm not scum I swear" There's also a serious lack of content here with a lot of your posts being just casually defending yourself. (Unless I have missed some of your posts because this site is hard to navigate.) I have you on my scum pile but I'm not sure if I should vote you, since I have a few more scum reads.

I'm composing a long post. I'll give a scum read just now. I'm having a hard time navigating this site and I have yet to figure out how to ISO a single player.

@Fable I would expect you to play a bit differently if you're part of a team. You've made it clear that you're a bit awkward because you don't know a lot of people, but if you were Mafia, I'd expect you to be more confident, I think. 3p is not out of the realm of possibility I guess.

All the reasons to push Athena is bad. Athena has proven to be a player with less experience. Things like defensiveness are not NAI. Neither is being opportunistic. I'm a fairly opportunistic player, for example, as either alignment. I'm not giving them a 100% town clear card, but based on experience level and what I've seen so far, I would be very surprised if Athena were scum in this game. There's definitely scum on this wagon.

Holy shit where are you from?

I believe Athena is shaping up to be a mislynch. They just come off as a new-ish sort of player. Does anyone know how much experience they have playing? I mean, Mafia overall, outside of this site actually.

Okay so that's it for catch up. Hopefully I've answered all the questions. I'll give my thoughts now, but I also need to get dinner so it might be a little while before I get to it.