But even if she's wounded, there's no ending for her, which makes the endings confusing. She didn't die during my play through, but I can see the confusion if she did.
I'd have to go with number 1, by the way.
On my first play through of RD(I played RD before getting PoR from a friend), I MISSED getting Meg... And everyone I knew was always asking "Did you get that fat girl yet? She is SO ugly!" And I'd always be going, what are you talking about...?
=D I was spared on my first ever play through.. Is what I'll believe.