[Pairings you like but you feel is underrated?]

1 minute ago, vanguard333 said:

Byleth and Lysithea is touching, but there's a big problem with it that you're overlooking: how did Byleth figure out a way to remove Lysithea's Crests? Linhardt and Hanneman are Crest Scholars/researchers, while Edelgard uses stolen Agarthan tech and Claude... I don't know; someone tell me how he does it, as I haven't seen their paired ending. I have seen Byleth and Lysithea's paired ending, though, and there's just no explanation. Right at the start of their S-Support, it's just, "That's it; you are healed because I am protagonist." 

Spoiler

At least in CF all the crest stop working meaning the burden of having two is removed restoring her lifespan, contrived yes, I haven’t don’t the other ones yet so I don’t know either 

 

[Gameplay mechanics ideas for PoR remake]

1 minute ago, Etheus said:

Being a subpar unit in PoR isn't that big of a deal, because even the worst units are completely viable with how easy the game is, but RD is positively filled with straight up joke units.

Well that and the bexp abuse that game had

[Week Five: Who Is Your Favorite Blue Lions Character?]

5 minutes ago, Sid Starkiller said:

Why the hell should I welcome someone who appears to be trolling?

Yes, just because I said something you disagree with I’m trolling. Solid reasoning.

I do find it odd that 5 weeks and the black eagle thread has 5 pages and this has more already.

[Week Five: Who Is Your Favorite Blue Lions Character?]

32 minutes ago, Sid Starkiller said:

If you don't like any of the characters in the game, then why the fuck are you here? Go to a different thread.

Wow, really welcoming ain’t ya?

12 minutes ago, Fire Emblem Fan said:

And the point of this was...?

All the blue lions eliminated, was that not clear? Should I rephrase it?

I’m one person in the minority, so don’t mind me

[Gameplay mechanics ideas for PoR remake]

1 hour ago, Etheus said:

I think RD needs a greater overall rebalancing. It's a really imbalanced, uneven, and sloppy game in so many regards. Ideally, units as straight up useless as RD Astrid would not exist.

I just think they shouldn’t have nerfed her stats so badly in RD. An marksman with double bow is so OP compared to Astrid that it makes her special boss talk worthless as you are not gonna field her 

[Gameplay mechanics ideas for PoR remake]

On 3/5/2020 at 12:45 PM, Etheus said:

Close Counter for archers/snipers.

Maybe not for mounted archers like Astrid.

I think Astrid should get this, it would give a reason to use her over Shinon and Rolf in RD. She is boardline useless in RD

But on the topic, getting the skill scrolls back after removing a skill(like in RD) would be something I would like to see

[Pairings you like but you feel is underrated?]

2 minutes ago, Gregster101 said:

Would you rather Lysithea die from a shortened life span then?

... or you could just CF Lysithea with Byleth and she would be fine... is that underrated? Byleth and Lysithea I never really see anyone on about that

[Thoughts on the character cast of 3H]

I’m the other way, Bernie, Lysithea, Marianne and Rhea are the only ones I really like. I would take the polarizing characters of Fate over the kinda boring group of 3H. That is why I’m generally disappointed with the 3H roster

[Thoughts on the character cast of 3H]

I don’t mean this in an offensive way but I really feel, now that the paint has dried, that in terms of characters 3H has the lowest amount of characters I flat out dislike but it also has the smallest amount of characters I really like too. What is everyone’s thoughts on the overall cast of 3H?

[Week Five: Who Is Your Favorite Blue Lions Character?]

Votes for none

[Week Five: Who Is Your Favorite Black Eagles Character?]

These sort of poll are always rigged(not in that way). You’ll always be in the lead or you’ll never have a chance. Like this, my least favorite character in the game is the (US) fan favorite just because she like to show off her maidenform(joke). But maybe this vote isn’t for me outside of Ferdinand and Bernie I don’t really like the black eagles

[What are some TH predictions that aged poorly, that you could think of?]

I had guessed that the marriage system would be trash, the game really didn’t have one so... bad guess I suppose. I was at least kinda correct as outside of Byleth, I don’t pair anyone up. None of the pair are that good in my mind

[Characters that need more appreciation from every FE game]

1 hour ago, NinjaMonkey said:

Vika/Lyre/Fiona ones

It often makes me wonder if people actually gave those ladies a try. Having Vika solo the level she returns is a great sight. But I agree they need more love

[Soooooo what'cha playing?]

1 hour ago, Armagon said:

Well i don't know about Caligula Effect but in Atelier Sophie's case, it's more like, the combat is like 99% the same as other Atelier games but this time, you select everyone's actions and then the turn plays out, instead of it being instant like in most turn-based RPGs. It's odd and i'll have to get used to it but it shouldn't take too long for that to happen.

That is Caligula, but different attacks require different things like, Protagonist get a counter off and that will launch enemy. Your teammates are all set up to combo off that juggled enemy but... you whiff so everyone just stands around doing nothing since the enemy remained on the ground.... and then you have to wait for your turn Cooldown before trying again

[Soooooo what'cha playing?]

59 minutes ago, Armagon said:

I can't really say anything about the game yet other than I'm gonna have to get used to the battle system.

This is how I felt starting up Caligula Effect: Overdose, loved that game but the combat was a whole different demon 

[I like Fates more than Three Houses]

5 minutes ago, Quiyonce said:

To be fair, Opera is not easy work and Dorothea did have to survive alone in the streets until she was discovered.

True, but Charlotte doesn't have adoring fans gifting her things either. Dorothea may have had a harder start but Charlotte grows more.

[Any chance of a sequel?]

52 minutes ago, Samurai Navarre said:

I haven't played Three Houses yet. No spoilers but is it any good? Fates was sort of disappointing for me. Most of the characters were just watered down versions of the ones from Awakening.

Some say yes, some say no. I thought it was good, not the best but pretty well off. Everyone has different issue with it so... take each person as you will

[I like Fates more than Three Houses]

1 hour ago, Etrurian emperor said:

For what its worth Charlotte's reasons seem to be a lot more benevolent then that of Dorothea. 

Dorothea is a gold digger who's after the money of the people she dates. She intends to spend this money on herself. 

Charlotte is after the money of the people that she dates. She intends to give the money away. 

That said Dorothea has a more likable conduct. Charlotte has a temper and is quick to treat people like dirt when she can't dig for their cold. Dorothea on the other hand is quite the sweetheart despite being a gold digger.

Sure, but Charlotte worked to get where she was, where Dorothea got the help for the opera company. Charlotte also seems to show a bit more regret when doing that to people, like when she starts rejecting Kaden’s gifts.

[Any chance of a sequel?]

11 hours ago, Samurai Navarre said:

Tharja is actually not a complete clone of Robin. They tweaked her moveset  a little. She uses Goetia in place of Rexaura as one difference. Can't remember the others.

Outside of her specials, that is the only difference. Nameless charge spell-Elfire-Elwind-Thoron-Ruin-Goetia(Rexaura for Robin). I may have gotten C2 and C3 backwards, I don't often play those 2, Linde is a better Foot Mage.

[Atelier series discussion thread]

19 hours ago, Falcom Knight said:

First of all each game of the series features a female protagonist who's an alchemist

Well this doesn't hold entirely true, Iris for example as a Male Lead named Klein, but Iris is the odd one out.

[I like Fates more than Three Houses]

1 minute ago, Hawkwing said:

I see. I agree to some extent, but the whole issue is reliant on more factors than the RNG. For instance, I find it annoying when missing a high hit rate or an enemy hitting with a low hit rate in Shadow Dragon, but less so when compared to Fates due to Shadow Dragon handling ironmanning extremely well, so I have an easier time recovering from the loss. And I'll stop there to avoid another argument from popping up. I was just curious about your original point.

Oh no, I know better now. It's fine, I disliked the debuff and weapon system in Fate so whiffing then to be slapped with a debuff or death just got old. especially since I play with "Any death is a game over" style. But that is my fault for playing that way

[I like Fates more than Three Houses]

1 minute ago, Hawkwing said:

Also, @ciphertul are you trying to say that you prefer Three Houses to Fates due to the latter having more consequences if you miss a 90% to hit when compared to the same thing happening in Three Houses? Or are you saying that you prefer Three Houses due to the reliably having higher hit rate percentages, while in Fates there's a greater variance (as in, the same character could have an 80% to hit against one enemy and a 30% against another on the same map? To some extent I agree that it is more frustrating to miss a 90% to hit in Fates do to having greater consequences and leading to nastier domino effects when compared to missing in other games, but a multitude of aspects lead to that being an issue, not just how the RNG was set up. I'm trying to understand the original point you were trying to make.

Both but I do feel missing on Fate to be far more problematic and harder to recover from it, but I'll stop there... don't to cause an issue again.

[I like Fates more than Three Houses]

4 minutes ago, Eurydice said:

You should at least give Dorothea a chance, not trying to force you to like a character or anything, but she actually has a pretty good reason as to why she dresses like she does. Some spoilers below, if you don't mind them.

  Reveal hidden contents

Dorothea grew up as a orphan that had to sing to survive she grew up dirty and hungry and had to bathe in lakes. Nobles instead of taking pity on her instead laughed at her and bullied her because she was a poor dirty lonely kid. However because of her talent she was picked up by the Opera and quickly became a celebrity and nobles began to adore her and even give her expensive gifts. Dorothea feels the need to dress hrm...with a provoking sense of style because she's "learned" that she feels that she needs to marry a wealthy noble to live and so any possible children can live too. Dorothea hates Nobles, despises them, actually, but she feels like she needs to sacrifice some happiness to live. 

I just, recommend giving her at least a chance.

Some like you may find that understandable, others may not. To me, those are pretty bad reasons. Kinda reminds me of Charlotte and well I find her reason far better then Dorothea's.

But again love her or hate her, each person has their own reasons

[I like Fates more than Three Houses]

6 minutes ago, vanguard333 said:

…Maybe she'll grow on you if you give her a chance? Intentionally killing her is a bit... much?

Everyone has their preference on characters, so if that is how they use them that's fine. I don't care much from Dorothea, but I'll at least keep her alive(if playing SS/CF).

Don't take it to heart.

[I like Fates more than Three Houses]

Just now, Flere210 said:

Imo no unit should have high def and res whitout also having very low damage in the first place.

Or speed for that matter, a tanky unit should have either Low Attack or Low Speed to balance