[Characters you wish were playable?]

On 8/23/2019 at 3:47 PM, Vince777 said:

Yes. Proposed the same elsewhere and thought it an opportunity wasted.

Randolph and Ladislava, Judith and Nader, and whoever fills that role in the Blue Lions route I have yet to play (Rodrigue?).

 

I'd love to see Judith as a playable character in There Houses, if she is not added via dlc is a very wasted opportunity

[Do you think FE's playable characters should lean more 'high concept' or 'low concept'?]

As mentioned, the low key characterizations and simple stories was overdone in Fire Emblem and was getting stale so I think they should try to subvert some tropes. Should every game be like this though? I don't think so, repeating formulas get stale at some point and it goes in both ways 

[Would you have liked shapeshifters? How would they work?]

I believe shapeshifter would be like the professor units, being route neutral  but recruitable in  random paralogue.

They would work similar to Corrin, having a stone to transform but also being able to use other weapons 

Not really fan of them being able to transform into anything.

 

 

[Prologues in Potential Remakes]

13 hours ago, Dandy Druid said:

Edain was also a bow wielder at that time too IIRC. She didn't become a cleric until after she graduated. Edain is the person I'm most interested in during their time at Belhalla. I wonder how different she was.

If they add reclassing feature in Genealogy's remake,  Edain secondary class tree being an Arch Knight would be awesome

[“Unconventional” Builds you’ve had fun with]

Gremory Shamir, she was quite good

[Recruited Characters: Which make most sense story wise?]

All characters would join the other house if they fall in love with Byleth or a student of other class 

Other than that, the obvious options are Petra, Ferdinand, Lorenz and Dorothea 

[Prologues in Potential Remakes]

Sacred Stones prologue should give more background to Lyon, Eirika and Ephraim relationship because Lyon comes out of blue as well 

 

On 9/14/2019 at 7:49 PM, Dandy Druid said:

Sigurd, Eldigan, Quan, Ethlyn, Edain, Arvis, Azel, Tailtiu, and Lex's lives at the Academy of Belhalla would be a nice intro to the game. (They all studied there IIRC, but Azel, Tailtiu, Lex, and Ethlyn were probably in a different grade since they're younger.)  

Yeah, most people forgot that Edain was Sigurd's classmate as well. I'd love to see a prologue or dlc following their past in the school. 

 

[Wave 3 and 4 DLC Info Leaked (Famitsu) (SPOILERS)]

I'm interested in four the new characters and the Death Knight dlcs 

[What Should the Next Fire Emblem Game Be?]

FE4 and Fe5 remakes or a whole new game. Not exactly in this order but those should the next games 

["Which 3 House Character are you " Quiz!]

Nice quiz, is there something similar featuring ghe cast of previous games?

[What fe game do you think will release after 3h finishes its dlc]

2 hours ago, Rose482 said:

 

Um, maybe the fact it would be a mess to make a remake of? Like even if you ignored how incest plays a bit too much of a big role in the story for games these days, having a game with only 12 big maps might be something which IS isn't interested in doing again? Or at least they surely never went that route in any other mainline game. I think just taking one look at how the format of the newer games work when it comes to chapters would make you see the problem here. I just don't see how you would be able to go on side missions and stuff like that with how FE4 works.

And also a game taking cues from another game doesn't mean anything becasue it happens all the time. 

Agree that the maps are bad and outdated but remakes are to fix this kind of stuff. Adding paralogues/side chapters with interesting maps are the easiest way to go but lots of other things could be done to fix this problem. Incest was always in Fire Emblem to the point of being a meme, so this is not an issue at all. 

[What fe game do you think will release after 3h finishes its dlc]

8 hours ago, Rose482 said:

Either a new original game or a FE6 remake. 

I know a lot of people want it, but I can see IS just never remaking FE4. 

Not sure what kind of logic is that, Gaiden was way more obscure and outdated but was remade

[Thoughts on 3H's Music (Possible Spoilers)]

Overall it's okay, not the best. The soundtrack is too much repetitive and most don't stand out. It's like the same track is remixed and used over and over again.

Some tracks are great,  like in every  FE game. Shambala and all versions, Spirit Dais, Blue Skies, Heaven and Earrh come to mind. There may be more, Fire Emblem always had good quality music, but compared to the other tittles, I wouldn't say Three Houses is the best in this aspect. Far from the worst though - the GBA games were quite poor in music.  Compared to video games in general I think the soundtrack good though. 

 

I don't mind the electronic music, it is a nice detail. I wouldn't like this style in the whole game - but this is not the case. 

[What fe game do you think will release after 3h finishes its dlc]

I like to think there's restrictions in turnwheel, it's not like the protagonists can mess with time whenever they want, pretty much like Butterfly effect. 

 

That said, I don't think it fits Genealogy of Holy War and Thracia, they will need to find another mechanic that fits the lore 

[Did Byleth REALLY have to be a Professor?]

NEED? No... Nobody need to be a professor but they are for a lot of different reasons.... Opportunity, love or talent for teaching or researching, available job, etc ...

--

In Byleth's case she/he has relations with  Rhea, Jeralt and Alois that were influential patrons. Those connections provided the job of teaching a subject in which Byleth was a prodigy. It was the first time as a professor but there was room for improving like every first job. 

 

It's a fantasy medieval time, in historic times people didn't need PHD to teach and even today most careers are build through connections. 

[What fe game do you think will release after 3h finishes its dlc]

Three Houses remakes, obviously. Kidding, who voted in this option? Lol 

 

Next game I believe  will be another original tittle, and so Fire Emblem 18 and 19 will be Genealogy and Thracia remakes respectively. 

[If The Routes Were Played Simultaneously, What Characters Would You Invent?]

On 1/9/2019 at 8:20 PM, Gregster101 said:

I think I would do what most of you guys are saying as well, but I'd also do something similar to RD where once you reach the route split with the three armies, you can choose who can go into which army, with some exceptions (I.e. Soren, Titania, and Mist are forced to be in Ike's army, Sanaki is forced to be in Micaiah's army, Lucia is forced to be in Elincia's army, etc.) I think the forced units for Eirika and Ephraim's armies should be:

-Seth and maybe Joshua for Eirika's army (I say Joshua just cuz of his importance in Eirika's route)

-Kyle and Forde for Ephraim's army (and while we're at it, make them plot important for Ephraim's route)

Everyone else can be put in either army. Does that sound like it could work?

 

Yeah,  the best solution is picking which character will join each side, but there's some units that join later, when the armies are already split.

 

I'm all down for both armies/stories playing simultaneously. It makes the game longer and more interactive. 

 

A new refresher, probably a bard, to join the army that doesn't get Tethys is the only character that would NEED to be created. 

[I hope to see a Middle-Eastern aesthetic at some point in the series]

I can see a middle eastern or arabic Fire Emblem game happening in a story following two different nations like Fates, possibly with a Crusader theme.  At some point, the avatar and their small army change mind and side with the kingdom being invaded so the story start to develop in the Arabic or Muslim inspired nation. Look at Kingdom of Heaven movie, I can see a plot similar to that. 

 

Plegia also has an Egyptian theme and a prequel having Chrom father as the villain would be interesting. I can't see them returning to Awakening/Arachnea universe so early though. 

[A bit shocked by the Lewyn arc in FE4]

On 9/11/2019 at 12:49 AM, Acacia Sgt said:

Just to point out; but Forseti was described to be quite passionate when it came to humanity. I'd think regardless if it's Lewyn or Forseti... hearing about Tailtiu's fate will have triggered an emotional response.

Well, not taking the gameplay aspects into account... likely Lewyn was tired to really try to dodge? I'd think having to escape, running most likely, from a literal meteor shower... yeah.

Maybe Forseti had a crush on Tailtiu? 

Now seriously, I still wonder how much of the time skip personality was Lewyn or if his soul was completely rewritten by Forseti. Maybe it was like Byleth's case in which both personalities existed in the same body and Lewyn listened to Forseti voice in his head 

[Canon Byleth (or, which gender do you prefer?)]

4 minutes ago, CyberNinja said:

I mean, as others said, they were never meant to be a reincarnation it was just a moment of opportunity that a child born of sothis' clone and a seiros blooded knight needed a crest stone to live.

Yes, that's why I said "basically" 😉. Byleth is a vessel but they share the same body  btw. I think the story of being vessel of Rhea's mother and plus being able to S rank all the lords fits more the female avatar.  

Regarding  their design female Byleth reminds me too much of Lucina. Male Byleth in their exclusive class looks a bit like Marth with that tiara. Considering that the feature of customizing avatar   was scrapped, I was expecting something more original. So  I'm quite indifferent towards their appareance. 

[Canon Byleth (or, which gender do you prefer?)]

Female Byleth makes more sense in story considering Sothis is basically her reincarnation and Rhea call Byleth mother and all this stuff. As for design, I'm quite indiferent to both Byleth's, they look good but in a very generic way. 

 

Anyway it's balanced this time right? It's tied. 

[How Can Roy Be Made Better?]

Skill system and earlier promotion are the most realistic options. 

[Revelation worth it at this point?]

On 7/9/2019 at 9:51 PM, Ottservia said:

RobinxCordelia is the best pairing and I will fight anyone who says otherwise. No seriously that family just works in all sorts of ways. 

I disliking pairing avatar with someone who worships another guy. Severa brings Chrom into their family showing that Cordelia never moved on from him completely. Nothing against though, anyone shod ship whatever pleases them 

[FE4 Best Father For *Each* Child.]

On 8/8/2019 at 10:37 PM, Tetragrammaton said:

If you're trying to make a canon story, then Fin Nanna + Beowolf Delmudd + Lex Lester should be considered.

 

Lester being Lex son was never considered canon  ....

And it was never confirmed if Beowulf or Finn are Nanna and Delmud fathers, the developers said it's who the player choses even if more likely it's one of them ...

[The worst parent]

On 9/1/2019 at 11:41 AM, starburst said:

Arthur and Kaze, for enabling Predator Cornflakes to date their literally kid children.

Wow i forgot that Corrin can date Percy 🤣🤣🤣 She is really screwed in the head...  I like to think Arthur and Kaze had no idea what was going on... 

19 minutes ago, Alastor15243 said:

I thought Lewyn only started becoming a shit parent and husband after 

  Reveal hidden contents

he died and his body was possessed by the wind dragon.

 

True, but as far I remember it's never revealed if Lewyn retained his personality and followed Forsethy's will or the dragon took his body completely, Kaga in his interview  let it open to interpretation. Considering Fire Emblem lore, the second option is more likely though...