Refa

You can't just cockblock all of my scumreads and ditch without leaving anything on the table.

FTR I can see Gorf's Elemina read coming from town (it was initially why I townread him until Yolo was like "no this is actually really bad"), but I don't like the pivot to Animal Midlife and anything to do with his read there.

Seems legit. He's still who I feel the worst about who's a large wagon. Your last few responses seem town to me, I'll reevaluate after everyone has posted and you've gotten your head in the game more. Marth/Dyachei are the only other people I'm bothered by. I really need more people to post here, because I don't know how my reads are going to progress from here. ##Vote: Donald Trump

Pepperidge Farm cares.

Linked the post below.

##Unvote Forgot to do this, I'll vote again after Omega responses.

1. It was when Via/Naana were arguing w/each other, you were on the sidelines at the time. No you're right about it not being wolfy since you're townreading both of the slots, I'm being dumb here sorry. My biggest (well, only lol) issue with your slot is that even later in the day when you have clearly defined scumreads, it feels like you're not going out of your way to push them or sell them to other people. I definitely wouldn't vote you for just that alone on D1, but I dunno...that's just where I stand on your slot. I do like that you've questioned more people and are getting reads in the last 24 hours though. 2. What do you think about Gorf's last post regarding Elemina?

Actually maybe Gorf wasn't such a bad vote lol, his reasoning for scumreading Animal Midwife seems kind of shoddy to me. I get that AM's early content was shoddy but it feels like you're spending more time arguing against Orihime's TR than pushing your scumread on the slot. Not sure about Elemina's catch up post. I definitely don't agree with the Naana/Via reads. I can get Elemina's logic behind these reads and I might be wrong on Naana, definitely sure that Via's slot is town though. I can see why Elemina would think Alpha Male is active lurking but don't understand why Scum!AM needs to be voting Elemina in this situation when a fuckton of people have scumread Naana up to this point. Orihime scumread also seems thrown there with little connection to the other reads, which seems weird to me considering Elemina was like "IM SURE IVE CAUGHT ALL FOUR OF THE SCUM". Sidenote @Elemina Why do you think there's only four scum? I'm expecting five. There's a lot of null reads but I remember Elemina doing that in previous games, so not holding that against the slot. Overall I'd say the slot is town (it does read like he felt like he caught something, and is pushing off of the assumption that Naana is scum) but I don't like any of the scumreads. @Omega. You said Elemina is obvious town, do you think this makes sense coming from Town!Him? Also while we're at it, can you explain the Alpha Male read? Why are Alpha Male/Gorf not scum/scum? I feel like you actually explained the last one but I forgot and I'm lazy. @Magnificence Incarnate Your catchup post was weaaaaaaaak. Your Dyachei and Naana reads seem at odd with each other. Why is Orihime scum, I don't get where you're coming from on this one. I can see why Town!Orihime would be frustrated here when she's townreading the two main wagons. It reads differently to me than the last game where she didn't support the main (mislynch) wagons but never tried to argue against them. Your Shinori meta seems hilariously wrong to me. He's frozen as scum? Shinori? Are we talking about the same guy here? @Shinori Back me up here and tell this guy that you're better than that as scum. =) @JohnCarter Hey, can you discuss your Elemina read in more detail because I'm not sure about this slot. @SB. What are your scumreads BTW? Want to compare shit w/you. I'm primarily bothered by Yolo/Dyachei (and Dyachei, paranoid of Gorf/Elemina (overall I'd say they make more sense as town but there are some weird plays that don't sit right w/me), and uh have no other noteworthy scum reads lol.

Lemme catch up before I respond, Yolo. I think your Gorf vote is more reasonable in retrospect even if I'm bothered by you for other reasons.

Who's Red Ryu? @Naana Why was the dude locktown reading AM scummy? I can guess where you're coming from here but I want to hear it from you. @SB. I'd sheep what you said about Omega having a weird stance on Via/Naana, felt like he went out of his way not to get a read on other of them. In general, I'm not seeing the thought process behind his actions, which are at least somewhat obvious in his town games. The Gorf vote is particularly egregious to me. Can you explain your toneread on Animal if possible? I know it's hard but it seems like they flaked so anything to help my read there. What are your issues with Marth (Magnificence Incarnate) again? @Shattiel Can you explain Naana's usual town posting? What are the differences in this game? @Donald Trump Your reads seem legit, what are your thoughts on Omega? @manti I liked how Elemina was asking questions that were influencing her reads. Not that strong of a townread but him doing it early on felt townie to me. Naana's later posts (specifically, his responses to his Top 3 Shinori reads and I'd sheep his Dyachei vote) seem good to me (content and tone wise). I'm going to sheep Orihime's AM read here, it seems more convincing than "meta could point to scum too" to me. Animal Midwife's early content still bothers me but I don't want to lynch off of it unless there's nothing better for me. I'd vote it over Naana but that's about it. tl,dr; I'd be okay with voting Yolo and Dyachei ATM. I don't remember if I mentioned this but I think Wolfy's responses to the case on him were fine, not bothered by that slot. Gut scum read on Manti just for those scum reads TBH, I think they're all halfhearted and on people I'd say are more likely to be town (not including Ichigo, whose posts I don't even remember honestly). Gonna vote Yolo if nothing changes in the next 15 pages.

I'm back, baby. Gonna catch up and change my vote if necessary.

Oh, didn't even pay attention to Dya's thing. Fuck it, I'm going with that. ##Unvote ##Vote: Animal Midwife Fair enough on Mag/Ele. I don't have any strong opinions on Magnificence, but I'd give him a few more posts to explain himself because he's the type of guy who has decent reads but ends up getting scumread anyways as town. I haven't played w/Scum!Him in forever, so all I remember is that he busses and his read progression isn't as natural.

I was scumreading Animal too until several people were like "this slot is locktown, no way Animal plays like this as scum". Honestly still not really okay with anything the slot has done, but that's made me avoid voting it until the slot does something more telling. Can you explain the Magnificence read? He actually is from SF, so I should be somewhat decent at reading the slot (don't ask me to read SB though, I always read him as town regardless of his alignment). Need more to go off of WRT Elemina. I thought his early content was good, assuming he'll check back in sometime tomorrow. Fair enough on the Naana read. For me, it's less that I feel strongly about the scumread and more Naana's responses have been baffling to me and I'm not sure how to interpret them. I can at least get why several people have Naana as their strongest scumread this early on.

Yeah, he doesn't deserve your vote. =)

It can help scumhunting, but it's like in the name lol. It's also a lot easier to do as scum. can you explain why you don't want to lynch naana? who do you want to lynch? i remember you had several scumreads earlier but idk how strongly you feel about them now? why are you voting naana if you don't want to lynch them? vi-astra.

wolfy, don't really have anything else for the other two. i'm not scumreading swag atm though. if everyone shows up and talks and he still has no convincing reads then he's on my hitlist but otherwise we cool.

my b

@SB. My scumreads were Wolfy/Naana/Yolo at the time of my last post. I already explained my early Yolo vote in my reply to Via (just ISO me, I haven't made that many posts IIRC), do you want me to explain more because I don't think I can. Having a hard time getting into the game because a lot of posts read null to me, and I don't feel super strongly about either of my scumreads. I've read all of Naana's recent posts and I don't get his mindset at all. Where is the scumhunting? Where is the thought process? @Naana Please play in a way in a way that I can comprehend, I don't know how my read on you is supposed to progress. I remember being like "this wagon built up really fast" as a gut reaction but then I still don't feel better about the actual slot. @Shattiel Earlier you mentioned you were scumreading Elemina/Wolfy but I don't remember you saying anything about their slots. Did I miss something or could you elaborate on both of these reads? @Omega. Fair enough regarding your play, I'll cut you some slack until everyone has posted and you can form some legit reads. Please be sheepable, though.

i think scum will just go anonymous if they want to lurk Shinori/Animal seemed like they had the most votes to me, need votals though.

@Orihime What's your read on AM?

I don't think it was you? Lemme find the post. This is what I was talking about (PEdit: Ninja'd by John lol). Makes sense. Need to wait for his response then.

Someone (I don't remember who) said Animal was town on meta. Can you explain why you disagree? I'll find the post if you don't remember it either.

@Animal Midwife Willing to lay off him if his scum meta is freezing up, but I want more out of him. Really would appreciate elaboration on your reads later this day (as in, this day phase) because I'm at a dead end reading your slot. @Donald Trump Honestly, I thought your initial reason for voting Elimina was bad. Your initial reasoning was based on NAI content. The tone read makes more sense to me though, but it's going to take more from Elemina for me to determine if that's accurate. Can you dig it? @EvanManManMan Can you explain your Shinori read more? @Naana Can you explain your Shinori read more? Also would sheep reads on you because you've been posting intermittently but haven't been contributing reads. @Omega. WRT my current read on you, it feels like you're not really pushing anything which is bothering me. Does anyone bother you ATM? Why? Getting the same vibe as Nanna except you're a lot less obvious about it. @Shinori I don't get your EvanManMan scumread. Also your posts made it seem like you were scumreading Orihime, why is that? @Vi-astra You mentioned my early Yolo read and it's less jokeposting and more that tonewise, it reminded me of his scum EM games. I know EM doesn't directly translate here (or translate at all lmao), it's just what bothered me the most on my initial read. What are your thoughts on Shinori?

@Animal Midwife It seems like you're questioning people but not getting anything off of them, which bothers me. What's your read on John (asking because he's the person you interacted the most with)? How about anyone else?

hot