Jump to content

Refa

Member
  • Posts

    7,055
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Refa

  1. @Orihime Martyr redirects all actions on Jaybee to you, correct?
  2. I took it to mean Athena definitely got roleblocked.
  3. Oh, I mean on N3. Baldrick seemed mad that I called him out on lying about that, felt like scum that got caught for the wrong reasons in retrospect. I don't think it makes sense to use the safeguard on N2.
  4. No, they probably used it on Conqueror. Athena got the results that his actions failed before getting the results that he was redirected. That doesn't make sense if Orihime's slot was safeguarded.
  5. @Orihime How did last night go? Why didn't you martyr Kill, he became confirmed town after last night's flip. ;_;
  6. Ike, Titania, Jill, Marcia, Soren. Having a healer who can use siege tomes probably helps more than having Oscar/Kieran does.
  7. Oh, I forgot Snike. I still think what I said is more likely, though.
  8. If it doesn't work, then Kill is more likely to be town. The only claimed 1x's are mine and Kill's, and while Via might have had one, Kill wouldn't be able to fakeclaim it in the way he did as scum (Via would have just flipped as a Vanilla).
  9. Scum would need to have a role that can redirect and a role that can cause actions to fail on the same night. This is in addition to them having a 1x Janitor. The role that redirects would need to be poorly used as well, and the role that causes actions to fail would need to be a 1x w/the Janitor or something. Also, this means that Kill cannot be scum w/Orihime WRT your theory, because he was rolecopped as Vanilla. Conqueror's interactions with her seem strange as scum/scum, and I already know that I'm town. So even if she wasn't more likely to be town off of actions, the person she makes most sense as scum is w/you anyways. I don't think Scum!Orihime volunteers to be copped though (doubt there's a Godfather in this game specifically to counter a 1x Cop).
  10. Oh right, I fucked up which one she could use tonight...and my terminology.
  11. No, Orihime can't be scum. Considering no one else has claimed a redirecting role, it either means 1) scum intentionally redirected and roleblocked Athena (this is regardless of whether or not you believe she's telling the truth BTW) or 2) Orihime is town. In the words of a wise saint... ##Vote: Baldrick @Killthestory @Orihime Kill needs to cop me/Conq tomorrow and Orihime needs to Martyr the other person.
  12. @athena_57 Do you know how your role interacts with Inventors? Would you be able to restore them as well?
  13. @Jaybee It doesn't matter that you're out of items, I want to confirm that your role works similarly to Baldrick's claimed role.
  14. What do you mean by lightning? Does that redirect all of the target's actions towards yourself?
  15. Who did you target on previous nights and why? Why did you initially claim vanilla?
  16. Ugh, I thought Orihime confirmed she used it on Athena FSR. ##Unvote
  17. TBH, I'm inclined to believe Baldrick here because it feels scum driven to me. If Jaybee confirms that his role works the same way as Baldrick's claimed role, I'm switching my vote here because it seems worse to me. Wait, is that true?
  18. @athena_57 I'm confused, did you get notified about who you targeted on N2? @Shinori When did you scan Kill?
  19. I'm still voting Baldrick because I think he's most likely to flip scum, I just don't think you should get tunnel vision about it.
  20. Athena can't be redirector beca-sniped. I think you're reading to into N3, Shinori. FMPOV, if Baldrick is scum, that means that he knew that Conqueror couldn't be targeted on N3 over him specifically lying about it. What's an alternative light Lightning Rod/Martyr do? Asking because I think you're using different terminology than I'm used too.
  21. Also for some reason my changed role doesn't have a role name, blame Marth for that one (and his not a comod, Iris). I'm not confident in it. I think what you said about him not being willing to NL is telling because it doesn't seem like he ever explained that. My problem is that if you're town, then mafia is probably Kill/Orihime (Conq/Orihime is weird because it means all scum piled up on SB except Bartozio and Orihime's interactions with Conq didn't read as scum/scum to me, and Conq/Kill is possible but it means that Conq has been lining up lynches on Kill/SB but didn't want to lynch Bartozio because ??? Makes no sense) and then what will I actually get out of asking him to scan you instead of voting you? Actually I'm not confident in anything. Why do you think your action failed on N3?
  22. Oh, I already asked if it failed on anyone tonight. It did fail on Athena on N3.
×
×
  • Create New...