Jump to content

Why do video game characters wear the same clothes?


IceBrand
 Share

Recommended Posts

Same logic as a video game character being stabbed multiple times in area of vital organs and living because..."Tis' just a flesh wound." Really though it is to make them stay in their iconic clothes,it's better than having to do in game laundry,or recreating the Sims.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lazy developers

not lazy, lets take fe as an example

if we assume that each chapter the unit has a different outfit for every chapter they are in and if we assume that there will be 35 characters in the game, and 30 chapters, starting party size of 5 with 1 new unit per chapter then

c1 for the 5 initial units you need 150 portraits

c2 179 portraits

c3 207 portraits

c4 234 portraits

c5 260 portraits

it keeps getting higher, its to much work,

if we were to assume each unit had outfits then thats 210 portraits

basically if there are lots of characters like in fire emblem its impractical,

and if its in a game with animated cut-scenes then they either have a nightmare hand drawing all the outfits or the programmers have to make a excessively complex code to render all the different outfits

its not that producers are lazy its that its impractical

Edited by Wintersmith
Link to comment
Share on other sites

In the first Paper Mario game, Princess Peach mentions that she has twenty versions of the same dress.

Also, she changes her clothes during the sports spin-off games.

and if its in a game with animated cut-scenes then they either have a nightmare hand drawing all the outfits or the programmers have to make a excessively complex code to render all the different outfits

its not that producers are lazy its that its impractical

And yet they can do different models when it comes to battle animations (for example, Edward's outfit differs depending if he's a Myrmidon, Swordsmaster or a Trueblade).

Edited by NinjaMonkey
Link to comment
Share on other sites

And yet they can do different models when it comes to battle animations (for example, Edward's outfit differs depending if he's a Myrmidon, Swordsmaster or a Trueblade).

1-3 sprites for a unit isn't that bad compared to like 40 for every unit.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

In the first Paper Mario game, Princess Peach mentions that she has twenty versions of the same dress.

Also, she changes her clothes during the sports spin-off games.

And yet they can do different models when it comes to battle animations (for example, Edward's outfit differs depending if he's a Myrmidon, Swordsmaster or a Trueblade).

as captain america said, thats less, also thats a very limited set of actions, i was talking about cut scenes like the ike vs black knight ones

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Same reason a lot of anime and animated characters in general wear the same clothes all the time. Its just animated physics. If you are animated, forget changing clothes! (unless your name is Sakura Kinomoto!)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In hand drawn animation, every time you design a new outfit, that's something new that you have to learn to draw consistently. In anime a lot of the difficulties of costume changes are lessened by keeping frames fairly static so they can draw less. With feature films with lots of movement (ie Disney, Don Bluth), you'll see characters keep costume change to a minimum. Feature-quality 3D films generally also don't like to change costumes either because they have to develop a new set of physics for the new outfit. In games with prerendered FMVs like most of the Final Fantasy games, they can't afford to remake that scene with different outfits that have different physics, which is why there is no customization whatsoever.

Setting up costumes for 2D games is every bit as difficult as animating for TV/movies, and often with even larger casts. Even for static portraits, an additional costume for the entirety of the cast would be another 40+ portraits. 3D is a little easier for generic outfit changes like in FE:Awakening because you can model a single body to be reused for every member of that rig size (in FE:A it's 3 per gender it seems), but individual outfits with lots of customizations are really time consuming, which is why you rarely see more than 3 unique alternate outfits even for a small cast. Games like World of Warcraft basically model from a base rig for every new piece of armor, which is why there can be so many different types of armor. Many parts are only retextured and require no new models at all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...