BBM
-
Posts
2,723 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by BBM
-
Talrega Division Final: Jill/Sigurd/Tiki/Elincia
BBM replied to shadykid's topic in General Fire Emblem
okay then I pick HAWK -
No Sully either...
-
Talrega Division Final: Jill/Sigurd/Tiki/Elincia
BBM replied to shadykid's topic in General Fire Emblem
Skasaha and Ulster are still on the polls twice. -
Sure does make defending weak characters more difficult. Chapter 3 all my hate.
-
yeah OC whatever
-
Talrega Division Final: Jill/Sigurd/Tiki/Elincia
BBM replied to shadykid's topic in General Fire Emblem
Anybody wasting their vote on Finn when they could be RALLYING SHANAM with me and Cam is the very hogan. -
Isn't it confirmed now that Elie's BPV got hit N1? I don't think Objection's flip completely clears anyone. Objection's Scorri stance is really really waffly. Shinori was inactive, making Scorri worse, except she posted some opinions, so that's good, but not completely good.
-
Talrega Division Final: Jill/Sigurd/Tiki/Elincia
BBM replied to shadykid's topic in General Fire Emblem
Haha Fin is killing his pool. Magvel nominations: Lyon, Ephraim, Caellach, Cormag, Ewan -
tbf I'm pretty sure Shinori's Elie vote was just to consolidate. As for why I think Objection's vote against me is partially associative, he brings up me being defensive of Strege.
-
The bolded is what makes me think it's partially associative.
-
I really don't like the view of "I'll leave Strege alone to more expert people". Why are you specifically leaving him in the hands of "more expert people" and not me? It's even worse when you consider that the scumread he states here is partially based on an associative read with Strege. It makes zero sense to leave someone who's tied to your main scumread alone. As for the bit about the gutread on Kay, Elie's gutread was based solely on Kay being inactive, with no attempt to look at the one or two posts that she did make on D1. I see a difference between that gutread and mine on Strege, which is based on a tone comparison to his scum games, as well as knowing him for five years. And why would your vote be considered an OMGUS? The reasons you outline aren't even related to my vote against you. Looks self-conscious. Won't argue the me killing Kay thing as maybe being WIFOM because I suppose I am the most likely person to do something like that.
-
I'm in I guess.
-
Almost all of your reads have some sort of qualifier there. Like "somewhat scummy". It makes everything you say feel weak.
-
It's not bastard, but I'm not sure if you're a valid checker?
-
Looking at some of Objection's posts last phase, I don't really like how weak his push against me was. Not in the reasons he outlined, but in how little he pushed the lynch. He had one post about it, and then in his next post he pretty much gave it up as unlikely to happen. In that post, he also said the Shinori wagon was pointless, yet in his first and only post of today, he said it was highly possible that Shinori was scum. What's changed since then? Elie and Kay's flips. But he didn't really find Elie all that scummy at the end of D3 either, and he said nothing directly about Kay other than that she was inactive and should post more reads. ##Vote: Objection for now
-
Scorri brings up some good points about Shin and I think if any of my townreads are wrong (which they are at this point, unless the team is Scorri/Objection), that's probably the one. I can see what Scorri is saying about Strege, and Strege's posts have a lot of modifiers in them wrt people's scumminess, but idk just getting a gut townread there. Scorri, what is your read on Objection?
-
17:16 <BBM>: people apparently want me to run PiG mafia 17:16 <BBM>: and by people i mean SB 17:16 <BBM>: who wants to check it 17:16 <BBM>: bc the balance is probably terrible 17:16 <BBM>: it's 12p OC
-
fwiw even though you misvigged three times in CMV, I don't think our lynch record there would be as good if you hadn't killed some of the scummier-looking town players first.
-
TBF I think Shin is the only one voting Shinori or finding him suspicious solely because of the Kay kill information that NNR apparently gave. SB was talking about lynching Shinori even yesterday, and what we're saying about him isn't about that either.
-
Well this sure has been a day! I would vote Shinori for selectively responding to SB's (admittedly bad) vote on him and not addressing the other questions that people have asked him, but I have a feeling that if he were scum, he would self-hammer, and I don't particularly want to cut this low-on-content phase short.
-
I don't have any scumreads atm. I'd like Shinori to produce content and answer questions like you, and I think there's a decent chance he's scum, but that's about it. I have to reread Objection, but his vote on me last phase sort of felt like a wagon hop that recited points I'd already replied to several times.
-
##Kill: Shinori I'm doing you a favour really. Now you don't have to figure out what the game is about!
-
Ugh, didn't realize that.nobody claimed having N2 BPV. SB, I assume you're hinting at something like a randomized or mod-selected kill that happened because nobody sent one in? idk either way, only one person's been inactive enough for that to work, and there are still two people left in the scumteam. There's probably some other reason. Also, I was Vanilla yesterday as well.
-
My reads this game sure have been trash. I have absolutely no idea why the mafia would kill Kay. Maybe they just wanted to get rid of inactives? SB, there are two mafia left, not one. Even if Shinori was inactive, the other member of the mafia would send in an action. I don't think that's a good reason. That being said, I want to see reasons from Shinori for those reads he gave at the end of D3.
-
Serenes Forest Mafia Mafia 3 - NOW IT'S REIN TIME (Game over)
BBM replied to Paperblade's topic in Mafia
yeah but it's been two years so now he's 12 and you're 14
