Irony

I'm still going to stick to my No Lynch on Day 1 Policy. In going to use the night hours to reread the thread, prepare myself for Day 2 and hopefully survive through the night. I now have a lot of material to work with, so I can maybe start on definitive reads. :)

And I made a typo... Blitz, I'm sorry.

Wow.... There's been a lot of activity since I last posted. From what I've read, I am going to believe Blit's claim that he has the weird role. Don't know what it's called. I don't feel that it's a role that would be claimed by the Mafia, but I'm not sure. I might be more weary of Elemina's claim, and move him to my suspicion list. I feel like it's a role a member of the Mafia *would* claim in order to mislead people on how many people are in the Mafia. However, no one else has claimed that role. Does that mean that Elemina *is* the person who knows that there are 3 Members of the Mafia? Is this role even in play? I don't know. Apart from that, Ryker, YOLOSWAG and Green Poet are on my suspision list. Ryker for obvious reasons, YOLOSWAG because their opinion changes a lot and Green Poet for the whole "Their reasoning makes sense, but I'm not going to remove my vote". I still trust Spinal and Hober, and I think I might trust Rainbow and Refa too?

Oh, right. Didn't realise that part. My bad.

...I'm female, Elemina. You're not the first to make that mistake, but I felt like I should let you know.

@Blitz, thank you for handling the Night/Preventing people from dying plans. :)

As we're getting closer to Night One, I am going to change the topic of discussion slightly, to ask: Who is at risk of getting killed by the members of the Mafia? If we can make a list, then the Doctor and/or Bodyguard can protect these individuals. :)

Actually, I think I did suspect them, as he was on my "Inactive Six" List.

Ok, I think kirsche is a townie. I dunno if I suspected him previously, but his argument sounds reasonable and stuff.

Thank you! :D

Found it! "With Ryker, it's that he keeps on trying to paint people as being members of the Mafia (I think he's done that to at least three people by now, including myself?) and, when I asked him to prove his alignment he didn't give me any evidence." This was all I had at the time, but yeah, I'm getting more Mafia-vibes from him.

@Refa (I.e the Irony/Ryker section) 1) Um.... I'm actually female. 2) I do remember giving a read last night (probably around 12-2am-ish where I live.) If I didn't, I apologise, but I'll try and find it for you?

Whilst I'm leaning towards the "the role is so ridiculous that it's difficult to make it up" side, if Blitz is not being serious, then it makes him less trustworthy, as he would have stuff to hide?

*Feels the Gun to my head* Me: Gulps Ok, so who do I think is Mafia? There's only 1 person that I'm leaning towards at the moment, and that's Ryker. I stated my reasoning earlier, but I don't trust him at all. I'm sorry if you're Townie, but yeah. I do want to see you defend yourself against the lynching, especially as you have the highest amount of votes. This is something that I am not seeing. Apart from that, I'm suspicious about: 1) The people who haven't commented much yet. I do think that a couple of them might be members of the Mafia, but the problem is that they haven't posted enough to let me know about them. 2) I also want some more information about YOLOSWAG, Refa, Green Poet and Rainbow. People that I'm trusting at the moment: 1) Spinal- Has a similar attitude to myself r.e. Lynching, being consistent in their viewpoints. 2) Elemlina- You're pushing the conversation forward and trying to work out who is Mafia and who is Not. 3) Blitz- Has already stated his role (?) and therefore has little to hide? 4) Hober Mallow- Again, is acting reasonably and is trying to push the conversation forward. So, whilst I think that Ryker is most likely Mafia, my other two picks would probably be in the list of the six that I posted yesterday (I.e. The ones that haven't commented as much as we have). Or Green Poet, who was the one to start the whole lynching process without providing a reason? (Have I done that right?)

1) I actually did a couple of reads on people yesterday (i.e. Ryker, Spinal and you) which you may or may not have seen. Apart from that, I've just been looking at how everyone has been acting towards each other. I will say something new about Ryker and Spinal. I don't think that they are both members of the Mafia. If both of them were members of the Mafia, then I'd highly doubt that they would be trying to make each other look suspicious. Either they are both Townies, Ryker is a Townie or Spinal is a Townie. I could be wrong, but I'm getting that impression. As I've said before, I'm getting used to Mafia. 2) I'd rather sit on the fence than lynch the Doctor. Yes, that is risky, but I don't want to vote unless I'm mostly certain that the person I'm voting for is a member of the Mafia. 3) I'm not sure? It is just that his reasoning sounds sensible and logical, unlike Ryker, who keeps on changing his argument (he said that he was voting for me when he was actually voting for you, which seemed off?) 4) I just want to analyse people , not lynch them. 5) The reason why I was thinking of claiming my role is that Ryker and a couple of other people were reading me as being a Member of the Mafia, and I wanted to show them that I was a trustworthy ensemble member? :)

@YOLOSWAG- Ok. @Hober Mallow- 1) Yeah, that's why I'm interested in the inactive members. For all I know some of them could not be posting in order to not draw suspicion? I don't know. 2) That was actually unintentional. I'm glad that my subconscious likes to act ironically. XD 3) Thank you for the term definitions! :)

Yeah, I should probably do the same tbh. I'm enjoying myself though. :)

On Blitz: Ok! I'll have to reread the comments again (when I'm more awake, so ideally tomorrow(?)) and make notes. On Spinel: Yeah, I was getting that impression of him. :) On Ryker: Ok, so I misinterpreted your comment, and having him explaining himself (instead of trying to get others to do it) would be useful.

I don't know what the vote count is exactly, but next time you are on here, can I ask you a favour? Can you give me a read on EVERY single player that has commented in this thread? (Yes, including myself). I'm interested in your thought processes, especially because you were one of the ones that I'm interested in.

This is my first game of Mafia! :) I've played Werewolf before, but the rules of Mafia seem slightly different to the rules that I'm used to?

1) Can I have your read on Blitz to tell me why? 2) I agree with you on your latter point. As I said my reasoning earlier, can I have your reasoning on why you think Spinal is townie and Ryker is a member of the Mafia? (If I interpreted what you said correctly.)

In all honesty, I don't think we have all of the information we need yet. I want to see how these six people post and stuff, as they haven't commented that much: kirsche, YOLOSWAG, Hober Mallow, SB., Rainbow, yedi. We only really know how half of the people comment. For all we know, the six I listed could all be members of the Mafia. This is another reason I don't want to point fingers yet.

Dumb question: What does "LYLO/MYLO will be announced." actually mean?

Wait, what happened with my comment? Did I accidently delete the last bit of the quote bar or something?