Jump to content

Guitar Mafia - Game Over


Vhaltz
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 1.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'll also post my thoughts tomorrow, after I have the time to recollect them. I tried ISOing Omega and I found nothing that I can consider scummy, his content is pretty much legit. SB is cleared only because Larsa jailed him, though. His excuse is the most fallible one as I can see because he could as well not have been jailed at all. What are the evidences pointing to his jailing? I need to check if they are reasonable enough to clear him (or make it very likely that he isn't scum). For now, this is all I have.

Under normal circunstances I'd bring out the wisdom of lynching me so to clear the Town from the noise, but since we're in a LYLO I can't give myself this benefit.

Guys, who seems town and why? I believe that checking everyone's "alibies" is a good way to solve this puzzle.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Larsa's crumb tells us he suspected SB. We infer from this that he targetted SB, which seems likely but not much conclusive.

Prims, hold on, you believe you were jailed during N1? This is giving me weird vibes, considering that was the Night on which we didn't have any deaths. Anything to say with regards to this?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Now I have some conclusions, too!

pages 5-9 wit a focus on bbms/rapiers/dewounds posts are by far the most useful information town has to figure out the best play wit page 8 bein the most important. this is ignoring randas posts n larsas would be jail which i need to take a second look at when possible

i really think yu shuld read those parts doe

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Larsa essentially confirmed he jailed me when he responded to Refa "knowing" scum killed Prims.

I forgot how jailing effectively protects someone from being killed. ç.ç

I'll sleep on it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still think SB is legit

why? with both sb n rapier playing like theyre town in yur words why are yu writing him off like this? is it just the presumed larsa jail? i am baffled that your posts thus far imply the last scum between me n rapier as opposed to rapier/sb

reread pages 5-9 plz. i dont actually want yu to post your thoughts about em til after me sb n rapier post some more but yeah thats one of the most important things that should happen today

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i'm pretty sure i claimed the jail instantly and larsa crumbed jailing me heavily, so. also a 1-shot cop alone isn't enough info for a game of this size realistically.

uh, my conclusion from Rapier Meta is that he liked to randomly white knight people which uh, is kind of what he did here. I'm inclined to think that he's just a godfather after all, but i'll reread when i get back today. don't have time atm.

should we just nl today?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 shot cop is way more than enough info specially a day variant

sorry. im jus confused that rapiers gameplan was to leave 2 clears alive n the guy whos been wanting to lynch him for both the last day n night phase

ill hav to look at the jailed shit later

why would you suggest a no lynch if you have a townread alive?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 shot cop is way more than enough info specially a day variant

sorry. im jus confused that rapiers gameplan was to leave 2 clears alive n the guy whos been wanting to lynch him for both the last day n night phase

ill hav to look at the jailed shit later

why would you suggest a no lynch if you have a townread alive?

modmeta but vhaltz hosted a 10p game before where there was a 1-shot daycop and a tracker, i don't think he'd add 3 people and cut out the info tracker when the majority of the roles in this game blow lol. also what's the scum rb meant to be blocking of actual worth if i'm scum?

Wrt the nightkill not making sense for Rapier: I don't think the kill makes sense for anyone tbh, so I'm just gonna assume scum was playing suboptimally there and ignore it.
NL for cop result, although I guess if there's a godfather it means nothing.
Meh. After rereading Omega's interactions with scum again I still don't think they make sense for buddies, even as a busser the way he went about it wouldn't seem to be a way to maximize towncred or anything like that.
Also, today Rapier looks like he's going after reasons for me not to be clear rather than reasons why I'm scummy, so that's kind of questionable? I also feel like the Randa claiming his role thing I brought yesterday was a gambit gone wrong where he was meant to show up and cc Randa in order to get towncred from it but then he never showed up before Refa shot the guy? Need to reread this guy in more depth but I'm kind of tired atm, and I feel like PoE is pointing this way anyway
Need to reread the rest of his content though but meh.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

hey rapier can you please explain this? what is a lovedmaker and what made you think that randa targeted you?

Lovedmaker allows me to choose a player and make them harder to lynch (they'll need 1 more vote to be hammered). I tried to target Prims but I wasn't allowed because we're in LYLO.

I think Randa targeted me because he apparently knew my role.

Also, today Rapier looks like he's going after reasons for me not to be clear rather than reasons why I'm scummy, so that's kind of questionable? I also feel like the Randa claiming his role thing I brought yesterday was a gambit gone wrong where he was meant to show up and cc Randa in order to get towncred from it but then he never showed up before Refa shot the guy? Need to reread this guy in more depth but I'm kind of tired atm, and I feel like PoE is pointing this way anyway

But I was there during the timespawn before Refa shot him and after Randa claimed. If we were scumbuddies and we rehearsed this so I could get towncred, then why didn't I counterclaim? This case scenario doesn't make sense.

Also, as I said, I don't find any of the remaining players scummy. Hence why I want to check the validity of their towness to deduce who is most likely to be scum (I'm obviously not scum in my PoV, so I only read the remaining players). Mancer was the least town of the protowns and arguably the only one without hard evidence pointing to his towness, as I said before. If he were alive, I believe I'd be able to make a case against him, but the same can't be said about the others.

What if we NL if we don't reach a conclusion toDay? I find it likely that Prims will be killed for being the most townie though, so this may be a waste of time. Yet, we could very well find the last scum easier in a 3 players only phase.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...