BBM

;/ We're just going to let four claimed info roles slide?

Well then. I like my Lucina vote because I find her worse than Prims.

The way he claimed doesn't seem like something scum would do. He claimed in a 1v1 against Paper. If he was scum then even if he wins the 1v1 he just gets lynched the next day, which doesn't make any sense. I thought of that when you claimed, but eh. I can try to prove the other part of my role if you guys want, but it requires pretty judicious use so I'm kind of wary about it.

The flavour says that I show up as a Plegian dark mage upon inspection (I'm Tharja). I'm guessing that just means mafia.

Well then who do you guys want to lynch? I don't support an Areox lynch and it doesn't seem like you guys support a Lucina lynch, and I guess the odd-night Tracker/even-night Voyeur have a sort of duality to them.

Tracker, Voyeur, and Cop? Ehhhhhh even if both the secondary info roles are on opposite nights, that still seems kind of too much, and I'm inclined to believe the Cop claim because of my role.

I don't think Lucina's claim is that believable, nor do I think that Tracker = Town anyways. And if I'm understanding Paper correctly, the Cop he's in contact with has no restrictions, so it seems odd for a Tracker to have restrictions.

We've got less than three hours left, so IMO Lucina should claim.

Well, my scumread against you is not very strong, but I don't really like your case against SB. The whole thing basically boils down to "SB thought Smilies was town and did nothing to stop it". But why would scum do that? If your scumbuddy is receiving heat and you're going to say he's town, why not actually try to stop it? Saying your scumbuddy is town and not actually going to any lengths to stop their lynch both makes you look bad for defending them and doesn't even stop your buddy from being lynched. It's a lose-lose situation. The other reason you give is that he voted Paperblade for not giving reads even though he hadn't given any of his own reads, but I don't really think that's true. People voted Paperblade because he had no reads despite being fairly active in-thread. IMO, voting someone for that is scumhunting. Your case against SB being IMO not very good doesn't make you scum, yeah, but some of the reasons just seem fabricated. And I don't think your's or anybody's case against Prims is that good either. I have to apologize to everyone. My play's been lackluster this game because of school and because I'm quite honestly paying more attention to FR right now.

What are votals? I don't really want to lynch Prims because I don't think his play has been as bad as people make it out to be. Also this is meta but Prims doesn't like D1 bussing. He goes to some lengths to defend his scumbuddies on D1, actually. See Chilean and ToS. IMO, the scum are between Boron, Shinori, Kay, and Lucina. Out of these I find Lucina and Shinori worst at the moment. I don't see at all how Shinori making those pair of posts makes him town (seems like a solidly null thing to me).

As an engineering student, there must be as few unknowns as possible. Eh, we can see what other people have to say about this I guess.

Isn't dealing with the unknowns sooner rather than later better? Elie can just hook CR and even if CR is scum redirector and that's redirected away, no biggy because nobody really has an active role that matters.

Mods/IOs need to figure this out. Yeah, I can idle. IMO we should still lynch Kay and have her shoot JB if she's town and then lynch CR tomorrow. Settles which one of Kay and JB are scum today, without leaving it to tomorrow when we don't know for sure.

Okay, if it's actually potential MYLO, then I guess 5/1 with both me and Kay being town and killing town along with us would also result in a loss.

If town need a mislynch to lose, that's MYLO. LYLO is where you lose unless you lynch correctly, meaning you can lose even after a no lynch.

eww Sonix

...then how is it LYLO?

Or alternatively we could lynch Kay and have her shoot JB, since one of them pretty much have to be scum.

Lynching Kay is still better though, because if she's town, CR, also dies to make it 3/1, and then I can target JB so that one person at most dies during the night. On the other hand, if she's scum, that stops us from having to guess who the last scum is tomorrow from among Kay/JB. Hooker sort of helps, but if scum is JB he could idle to implicate Kay or something.

To use one of Prims's own terms, kind of seems to me like he's using refuge in audacity right now by being blatantly useless.

I dropped Elie as a target because he proved his Vig shot. Even if it wasn't on who he was supposed to prove it, it makes it unlikely that he's town. I'm also 99% sure CR is scum and I dislike Kay's claim more than Elie's now that he was able to prove it. As for the bussing, yeah well, shrug. There's a counter to like everything that makes someone look townie. You have to decide how likely it is that I'd actually bus in that situation.

WIFOM, obviously. If we go with the theory of Kay/CR fabricating results to get me lynched, you could also say that two vengeful-like roles are unlikely to exist, so it's even more likely to result in my mislynch. Manix, can you restate any non-role reasons you have for finding me scummy? IIRC the last time you did so I countered most of them pretty well.

Well, how likely does me being on a scumteam with Baldrick sound? I would have had to have suggested massclaim, prompting Baldrick to claim, and then have provided one of the key pieces of info that led to his lynch.

Etheeeeeeer. Prims, do you have anything useful to say? Also, gtfo Stahl x Cordelia OTP.

Okay, so even if a few of the PRs would modkill you, CR's clearly doesn't because she would have been modkilled by now otherwise, so.