@Elie- I'm not voting you because of meta. If you notice, I said that you're not playing like your town OR scum self. You're just playing really passive-aggressively, which I normally find scummy in anyone. It's something in the tone of your posts that seems really snippy.
@Psych- read what I just said to ELie. In Nostalgia your play was slightly more aggressive than it normally is, but you were still playing in a townie way. Elie is not, IMO.
@Cam- Please explain what exactly is bad with my idea, especially as most of the town is in fact going to lynch Shinori today- the current discussion is to see who we find scummiest, and therefore who Shinori should shoot as he gets lynched.
And Elie, why exactly is Mancer newbscum and not newbtown? Remember SB in his first game, SFM? He just blundered in and voted for the town leader, Shinori. That's no different from you voting for Prims in SFMM2. What both of you did was you guys being inexperienced, and not any indication of alignment.