BBM

You can post this in the thread you know. It wasn't that you argued aggressively, it was that your argument was about her playing style.

You're just a poor girl You need no sympathy Because you're easy come, easy go Little high, little low Any way the wind blows Doesn't really matter to you... to you....

It's not like there aren't canon pairings though. Levin x Fury or Sigurd x Diadora. And then FE10 has a bunch Micaiah x Sothe, Jill x Haar, Boyd x Mist, and Geoffrey x Elincia that are almost canon because those are the only ones that result in endings.

Rapier, I never said that you are dumb, I said that your ad hominem was dumb. And yes, I do consider what you did ad hominem. Ad hominem is the fallacy by which you dismiss someone's claims due to their negative characteristics. Arguments against their style of playing falls into that category. Paraphrased, what you said is "I'll pick on you if you use your gut as a reason". Also, you said that you don't mind Strawman's vote on you because it is due to your behaviour instead of your actions. Someone's actions can be just as scummy as their behaviour, and in the case of your action that I find scummy, that bleeds into behaviour too. I'm keeping my vote on you, especially as your vote for me seemed too OMGUS. Also, Eli, we can't all be happily settled like you...

We are bloodthirsty monsters. RAWRRR! People do find it a scumtell, but almost all newbies recommend it in their first game or so.

Sadly, the No Lynch vote will make you more enemies. The thing is, the town doesn't learn anything from not lynching anybody. Even mislynches give us some information, because we can see who the people were who pushed particularly hard for that lynch, the people who bandwagoned on near the end, etc., and use the mislynch to pull off a lynch on a mafioso. Not lynching anybody, however, means that come Day 2, we will be exactly the same as we were today, except one of us will probably be dead, and maybe the Cop will have hit a mafia, but since there are more townies than mafia, probably not.

Okay, I got ninja'd my SB, so I'm going to repost the votals. Votals: Iris [0]: Elieson Hikarusa [1]: Aere Lucina [1]: Iris Aere [0]: StrawSloththeSawSlothStraw, BigBangMeteor, Bluedoom Helios [0]: Bluedoom Scorri[0]: Manix Serious Bananas[4]: Scorri, adiosToreador, Elieson, Manix, adiosToreador Shinori[0]: Serious Bananas San[0]: Manix Eclipse[0]: San Rapier[2]: StrawSloththeSawSlothStraw, BigBangMeteor adiosToreador[0]: Serious Bananas No Lynch[1]: Serious Bananas

Votals: Iris [0]: Elieson Hikarusa [1]: Aere Lucina [1]: Iris Aere [0]: StrawSloththeSawSlothStraw, BigBangMeteor, Bluedoom Helios [0]: Bluedoom Scorri[0]: Manix Serious Bananas[4]: Scorri, adiosToreador, Elieson, Manix, adiosToreador Shinori[0]: Serious Bananas San[0]: Manix Eclipse[0]: San Rapier[2]: StrawSloththeSawSlothStraw, BigBangMeteor adiosToreador[1]: Serious Bananas

1. Rapier. Ad hominem is dumb. I think SB is newbtown, not newbscum. Look at how SB signed up. "Uh, Okay." Not very enthusiastic. And I talked to Eli, and he said that although SB had wanted to learn mafia, he did kind of give him a push to join, because we needed only 2 people at the time. I think he's just not paying very much attention to the game, and while that's annoying and frustrating, I don't think we should lynch him for it. So ## Unvote, ##Vote: Rapier 2. Disregarding Shinori, I have to say Proto and Hikarusa. Neither have made very many posts, but the ones they have made look good. Bizz would be here too, but her claims about being able to know if she got targeted are weird and while I don't think she's mafia, I'm not quite sure what she's up to. 3. Not Shinori. Possibly Eclipse? None of the people who had any suspicion on them today and are actually townie, because from the mafia POV, those could lead to mislynches later on. 4. Objectively speaking, any of the people who have/had suspicion on them this phase. In order, that's: BBM Aere Rapier SB I think those were the only real suspicions, but I might have forgotten someone. Other than that, I dunno.

So Great Lord? I dunno, I think Eli needs his horse.

Was the objective of the chapter to Rout or Kill Boss?

Eclipse? What? She got kidnapped/silenced. I mean, it's possible the mafia are setting her up to look more credible for Day 2 and beyond, but shouldn't we at least wait for her to get here?

Just to clarify, Bizz, but this is what your original basis for thinking Aere was scummy was, right? It's not your current opinion?

But that's not one pairing.

I only checked the completed games, not the queue, ffff- Got to get on making Hunger Games Mafia then.

Selena x Brady new OTP

How about you make a Paper Mario mafia, and I make a Hunger Games mafia (probably not), and we see which one is more popular?

books > video games fact

Gaiz just had the best flavour idea for a game. Hunger Games Mafia

Not just Kay. SB, Proto, Blitz, Lucina, and Kay all have under 5 posts

My mistake. Not worded well, but you know what I meant.

Well, I don't think Marth will mind, so I'm just going to say that yesterday night, Marth and I were discussing whom we thought had shown suspicious signs up to that point. We (or at least I) only had Aere up to that point who had made any noteworthy reactions, so he piled a third vote on you to see if you would react even more and (if you were scum) maybe slip up. I don't actually find you that scummy Aere, just the scummiest of the bunch because damnit more people need to post or I need to talk to more people outside. >_> And I feel that some people are using OC as an excuse to just lurk. As for Rapier, he did react weirdly, but I can kind of see where he's coming from, because you do have a tendency to follow your gut more than logic a lot of the time, Bizz, and it can be a bit annoying for others sometimes.

Well, as one of the votes on you is mine, I'll explain why I've chosen to keep it on. This game is OC, so people are not posting in thread as much as they probably would be otherwise, so there is much less to analyze in-thread than there is in N0C/limited OC games. My role doesn't give me more info to analyze, which means your complaining even about the very first random vote placed on you is the most suspicious thing anyone's done so far.

@Aere- Votes that are made without even an attempt at a logical reasoning are randomvotes. Why are you getting so worked up? I realize that I'm the last person who should berate someone else for over-reacting, but looking so nervous about a paltry 3 votes in a game with 19 people in it is suspicious.

I fought Damian with both Hector and Eliwood on my first run of that chapter just to confirm, and Damian definitely didn't have any convos. Nor were there any convos with Bernard.