Rapier

Okay. I voted you because I think you were more focused on my argumentum ad hominem than in scumhunting, and while I don't think you look that scummy, you're my best bet. I can't think of anyone else, mainly because I have to study for exams now and I'm not that good with OC and talking off the topic. By the way, I think both Lucina and SB's are newbies, so I'm not bothered about them.

Man, did you read the rest after his vote? He realized his mistake...

It's ok. Sorry about my overreaction, Bizz. =P SB kinda helped me a lot with reads, so his votes weren't that bad in the end. After all, the crows love meat~

Is saying someone's using an argumentum ad hominem because they answered agressively towards a player an argumentum ad hominem itself? I'm getting this weird feeling...

Also SB voted me for an argumentum ad hominem, his only reason was "because it's stupid". He didn't do it because I attacked Bizz and as such I looked scummy (as Straw stated). For me, Straw's answer was focused on my behavior, and not on my action. So I like his answer. Imo that's enough to vote BBM. We're supposed to scum hunt here, saying someone is being dumb and needs to be voted isn't the point. ##Vote: BBM

1. Who do you find the most scummy currently? For now, I don't find anyone particularly scummy. I don't trust anyone, especially on D1. I'm paying attention to SBs case, I think it's an easy way to pull a lynch at him by saying he looks scummy for being newbish, and pulling the newbie card is an easy way to excuse yourself. In particular, I'm not liking Elieson's actions and Manix's because he seems to be dragged by everyone else's opinions to me. I'm not sure about Bizz because she's always that way... Meh, why do I even worry about it when I just said I wouldn't care about such excuses? 2. Who do you find the most town currently? Shinori and Clipsey seem to be the most Town. I'm not saying they ARE Town, I'm saying they are the less scummy ones. Shinori is doing a good job by Town Leading (although revealing his role PM wasn't such a good thing), and Clipsey was kidnapped. 3. Who do you think is the most likely to die tonight? I'm not sure. 4. As a cop who would you target tonight? Either Elieson or Manix. Actually... What she said: I'll vote him. I don't care about the newbie card, that's a convenient excuse. What I said: Well if that's the case I'm not going to let any "I get bad/good vibes from <player> because I just do" get through me because that's also bullshit. Now don't you dare say I'm using an argumentum ad hominem. I just wanted her to see just how stupid it is to play ignorant, but it failed terribly.

Right. Your reasoning: Your vibes. And now I'm defending Bananas and overeacting to protect him because I'm his scumbuddy. Right? No, because I only attacked -you-, and I only had reasons to question you. See, I didn't attack the rest who voted him.

Fine then, I'll pick on you for any "I get scum vibes from <player>. Idk, I just feel them" because it's a stupid and convenient way to convince people. I'm not letting crap get past through me anymore, if that's so. No more "They always play that way" excuses. You're right. Playing the ignorant card is easy. That's why I want him to justify himself, before I decide to vote or not.

The newbie card is important: You aren't voting people because they aren't pros, you are voting people because they are scummy. Bananas, would you justify your vote on Shinori?

I'd say it's something important to notice, but the chances of her being Mafia or Town is the same, in that case: 1) She could be from the Town, kidnapped by a Mafia Kidnapper or a Townie one who suspected her 2) The scums decided to kidnap her for some reason. I don't really think it's a good thing to kidnap your own scumbuddy on D1 unless he/she's being suspicious enough, so I'm inclining towards Town, with Mafia Kidnapper.

I still find it strange that Shinori managed to get investigated in N0, so he could conveniently become the Town Leader. But I'll go with it.

I'm just that generic. XD

I'm worse, because my role's a NPC that greets you with Welcome to Corneria when you go back to the Main City.

what is this is it edible

Meh. I'm tired of never being Mafia, seriously. It's been eight games since I'm not scum, counting with this one. Now, to wait until N0 is over.

I'm in!

About the last episode, I didn't understand...

If you have the book, then DON'T wait for the season! Seriously, I guarantee you. The book is too awesome. It gets stuff done in a way the last books has never dreamed of doing, much like a Star Wars Episode 3.

I loved the last episode. The last scene with Theon made me laugh, and the rest was well done. Now I just hope they'll make Season 3 even better. =P

Many reasons to dislike Marth: - First appears in a game with bad gameplay and terrible script. FE11 made the gameplay a bit better, but it still sucks. FE12 wasn't released overseas; - Has no personality. His only shred of "personality" is the one given to him to fulfill his role as the Main Hero in the game; ... Ok, they're not many, but they still count a lot to me.

Large games requires more players, and more attention. It's kinda hard to do it when we have two ongoing games, imo. Also, where is that Umineko Mafia thing? That was one of the best ideas I've seen so far. :3 I wanna see how we're going to use the Blue, Red and Golden truths

I went too far. Do you think I was wrong by pressing Paper, or do you think I'm wrong for not admitting it? I'm not sure if a "I'm sorry" post would've made me less scummy.

I thought that was the only one. Also, I'm too stubborn, that's why I still held you. I thought I could find a Phoenix Wright-ish reason that would fix this and lynch you like the difference between flavors, but I was wrong. Sorry. >:

Jon was never a major character in the start of the series (books included), but he just seems retarded to me. As long as they give him attention in the following seasons, I'm fine with it (which they probably will, because they'll have more episodes... 12, if I'm not mistaken). Now I just wonder how the Reed siblings will get to Bran.

It would never have happened, because: - My case agaisnt Paper wouldn't have been that stupid if the Jailer possibility didn't exist. - I didn't know Roleblocks also included stopping Night Kills.