Best/Worst in the Series: Round 92

[NinjaMonkey]

Please vote for what YOU think is the best AND worst in the series for this round. Failure to vote for both will result in your vote not being counted. The round will last for about a week or so, after which I will tally the votes, and will add the top three to a list in the opening post of the next topic.

It would be nice if you nominate ideas for when I'm out of them. I'll keep track of the nominations. Please nominate only once a round. You may nominate for idea that have already been nominated.

Please remember to nominate. Also, if your vote is not for one person/thing/etc, it will be thrown out. Your vote will also be thrown out if the FE game it is from is not stated if it is needed. This is mainly to avoid confusion.

If you excessively complain about the results of previous rounds, you will not be allowed to vote in these topics for a period of time that will be determined later. A list will be kept of those who will not be allowed to vote, and how many rounds until they can vote again.

Previous winners (Best)

Best NPC: 1st- 3-13 Archer ; 2nd- FE10 Daein Army ; 3rd- Eltshan

Best Swordmaster: 1st- Rutger ; 2nd- Lakche ; 3rd- Shanan

Best Hair: 1st- Titania ; 2nd- Heath and Stefan (tie)

Best Non-Final Boss: 1st- Black Knight ; 2nd- Alvis and Trabant (tie)

Best Thief: 1st- Pahn ; 2nd- Matthew ; 3rd- Lifis, Volke, and Sothe (tie, FE10 Sothe can only be assumed)

Best Personal Weapon: 1st- Graphcalibur and Pugi (tie) ; 3rd - Wolf Beil

Best Chapter: 1st- FE10 2-E and FE5 chapter 14 (tie) ; 3rd- FE6 Chapter 21, FE5 chapter 24x, FE5 chapter 13, FE4 chapter 5, FE5 chapter 22, FE9 chapter 13, FE9 chapter 26, FE8 Ephraim's Route chapter 11, FE10 4-5, FE9 chapter 17, and FE10 3-E (tie)

Best Final Chapter- 1st- FE9 ; 2nd- FE4 ; 3rd- FE5

Best Final Boss Weapon- 1st- Judge ; 2nd- Flametongue and Loputousu (tie)

Best Personality: 1st- Levin and Kieran (tie) ; 3rd- Wallace

Best Rapist or Attempted Rapist: 1st- Narshen ; 2nd- Oliver ; 3rd- FE10 opening movie soldiers

Best Tactician: 1st- Mark ; 2nd- Soren ; 3rd- Jeigan Book 2

Best Est Archetype: 1st- Nino ; 2nd- Sara ; 3rd- Zeiss and Pelleas (tie)

Best GBA Critical animation- 1st- Lyn (Sol Katti) ; 2nd- Warrior (Axe) ; 3rd- Hector (Armads)

Best Console Critical animation- 1st- Celice 1st attack ; 2nd- FE4 Swordmaster/FE10 Black Knight (tie)

Best Epilogue- 1st- FE4 ; 2nd- FE10 ; 3rd- FE9

Best Gato Archetype- 1st- Athos/FE5 Sety (tie) ; 3rd- Galzus

Best DS critical animation- 1st- Hero (2nd attack), Swordmaster (2nd attack), Mage, Lord, Berserker (1st attack) (tie)

Best Form of Abuse- 1st-Favoritism; 2nd-FE9 BEXP Abuse; 3rd-Arena Abuse

Best FE- 1st- FE4 ; 2nd- FE5 ; 3rd- FE7 and 10 (tie)

Best Ruler: 1st- Alvis ; 2nd- Ashnard, Naesala, Caineghis, Dheginsea, Sanaki (tie)

Best Gaiden chapter: 1st- FE7 19x(HM) and FE5 21x (tie); 3rd- FE7 19xx(HM)

Best Unit: 1st- Levin!Arthur; 2nd- Ike (O_O); 3rd- Seth

Best Merc/Hero: 1st- Dieck ; 2nd- FE3 Oguma ; 3rd- Skasaher

Best Paladin (Anything that promotes into it as well): 1st- Seth and Aless (tie) ; 3rd- Titania

Best Peg Knight: 1st- FE10 Elincia ; 2nd- FE4 Fee and FE3 Book 2 Paola (tie)

Best Defense Chapter: 1st- FE10 3-13 ; 2nd- FE9 C8, FE10 2-E (tie)

Best Archer/Sniper/Marksmen: 1st- FE10 Shinon ; 2nd- FE4 Jamka, FE7 Rebecca (O_O) (tie)

Best Desert Chapter: 1st FE8 Scorched Sand ; 2nd FE10 4-3 ; 3rd FE7 Living Legend

Most Hyped: 1st Lilina ; 2nd FE10 Haar ; 3rd Nino

Best Addition to the Game Series: 1st Capture ; 2nd Weapon Triangle ; 3rd Rescue and Skills (tie)

Best Lord Unit: 1st Sigurd ; 2nd FE10 Ike ; 3rd Arum and FE9 Ike (tie)

Most Generic Playable Character: 1st Ralph ; 2nd Aran ; 3rd Vika (she got exactly 1 vote)

Best Castle: 1st Crimea Castle and Grado Keep (tie) ; 2nd Daein Keep

Best Dragonkid: 1st Fa ; 2nd Chiki ; 3rd Al

Best Staff: 1st Again ; 2nd Physic and Warp (tie)

Best Knight/General: 1st FE10 Gatrie ; 2nd Oswin ; 3rd Wallace and Amelia (tie)

Best Priest/Cleric/Bishop: 1st Sapy ; 2nd Moulder, Natasha and Serra (tie)

Best Glass Cannon: 1st Sara ; 2nd Micaiah ; 3rd Lucius

Best Wyvernrider: 1st FE10!Haar ; 2nd Miledy ; 3rd FE3Book2!Paola and Altenna (tie)

Best Chapter Goal: 1st Rout ; 2nd Escape and Defend (tie)

Best First Boss: 1st Lawrence ; 2nd O'Neill ; 3rd Greil

Most Important Stat: 1st Speed ; 2nd Defence ; 3rd Strength

Best Red/Green Knight: 1st Sain ; 2nd Abel ; 3rd FE9!Kieran and Lance (tie)

Best Healer (primary use is healing): 1st Priscilla and Saphy (tie) ; 3rd Laura

Best Prologue Chapter: 1st FE4 Prologue ; 2nd FEDS Prologue ; 3rd FE10 2-P

Best Weapon Type: 1st Swords ; 2nd Axes and Wind Magic (tie)

Best Generic Weapon: 1st Javelin ; 2nd Killing Edge ; 3rd FE10!Hand Axe and Steel Sword (tie)

Best Female Physical Fighting Unit: 1st Paola (FE3 Book 2) ; FE9!Titania ; 3rd Lakche

Best Jeigen (Seth and FE9!Titania excluded): 1st FE7!Marcus ; 2nd Sothe ; 3rd FE6!Marcus

Best Player Phase Battle Music: 1st The Devoted ; 2nd FE5!Attack, On Glory's Wings (tie)

Best Support Unit: 1st Saphy and FE10!Reyson (tie) ; 3rd FEDS!Lena

Best Terrain Type: 1st Forest ; 2nd FE4!Road ; 3rd Wardwood tile, FE10!Heal Hedge and FE5!Mountain (tie)

Best Facial Hair: 1st Nolan ; 2nd Tauroneo ; 3rd Oifaye

Best Skill: 1st Pursuit ; 2nd Galdrar ; 3rd FE5!Wrath

Best Unlockable Character: 1st Ashnard ; 2nd Lyon ; 3rd Farina

Best Non-recruitable Female Boss (Excluding Ashera): 1st Ishtar ; 2nd Selena ; 3rd Brenya

Best Green-haired Archer: 1st Rebecca ; 2nd FE12!Ryan ; FE10!Rolf

Best Offense: 1st Levin!Sety ; 2nd FE10!Ike ; 3rd Othin

Best Recruitment Theme: 1st FE10 ; 2nd FE4 and FE8 (tie)

Best Character Name: 1st Sirius ; 2nd Skasasher; 3rd L'Arachel

Best Support Coversation: Volke/Bastian C (FE9); 2nd Kieran/Rhys A (FE9) and Bartre/Renault A (tie)

Best Enemy Recruit: 1st FE9!Jill and Ayra (tie) ; 3rd Rutger

Best Weapon Name: 1st Tyrfing ; 2nd Alondite and Florete (tie)

Best Artwork: 1st FE11!Minerva ; 2nd FE10!Boyd and FE12!Sirius (tie)

Best Canon Couple: 1st HectorXLyn; 2nd SigurdXDiadora ; 3rd SethXEirika

Best Crack Pairing: 1st SigurdXAyra ; 2nd SainXFlorina ; 3rd JillXMist

Best Japanese Name: 1st Soanvalcke ; 2nd Tiamat ; 3rd Zaggaro

Best Princess: 1st Ayra ; 2nd Minerva ; 3rd FE9!Elincia

Best Prince: 1st Joshua ; 2nd Marth ; 3rd Jamka

Best FE Soundtrack: 1st FE4 ; 2nd FE10 ; 3rd FE8

Best Fighter or Warrior: 1st FE9!Boyd and Othin (tie) ; 3rd Nolan

Best Country Name: 1st Crimea and Thracia (tie) ; 3rd Agustria

Best Twins: 1st Lakche/Shasaher ; 2nd Jorge/Daniel, Briggid/Aideen and Ephraim/Eirika (tie)

Best Story: 1st FE4 ; 2nd FE10 ; 3rd FE7

Best Legendary Hero: 1st Sety ; 2nd Iote and Anri (tie)

Best Quote: 1st Sylvia: "Good little gi-- You ever see a little girl with THESE before?" ; 2nd Micaiah: "Right. Lord Ike, hero of the Crimean Liberation, leader of the Greil Mercenaries, and father of Sothe's children... " ; 3rd Schaeffer: Gwaar... Haaaarr... Haaaaaa... Shoulda brought... more priests... Or some...babies... Dang...", Haar: "The world could flip upside down and you'd be trying to boss around gravity.", Wil: "Huh? W-Why? Nonsense. I'm normal! I might as well be Normal Archer number three!" (tie)

Best Generic Boss: 1st Gomez ; 2nd Schaeffer ; 3rd Denning and Carlyle (tie)

Most Depressing Ending: 1st FE4 Gen 1 ; 2nd FE8 ; 3rd FE7, FE9, FE11 and FE12 (tie)

Best reference to plant life: 1st Shinon: "You'd hit on a tree if I dressed it in a skirt. Tell me I'm wrong!" ; 2nd Soren: "What do you say, rose of Tellius? O goddess of desire?" ; 3rd Dandelion Gang

Best Red-haired Unit: 1st FE9!Titania; 2nd Seth ; 3rd FE11!Cain

Best Map Theme: 1st Light and Dark ; 2nd Eternal Bond ; 3rd Bearer of Hope

Best Non-Jeigan Prepromote: 1st Pent ; 2nd FE12!Sirius and Levin!Sety (tie)

Best Brother: 1st Sigurd ; 2nd Oscar ; 3rd Ike, Uther, marth and Eltoshan (tie)

Best In-game Nickname: 1st Fireman ; 2nd Pookums ; 3rd The Shield of Thracia and Hurricane (tie)

Best Bro: 1st Nolan ; 2nd Hector, Seth, Cuan, Gerik and Levail (tie)

Best Fog of War map: 1st FE10 Chapter 3-6 ; 2nd FE7 Chapter 26E/28H and FE6 Chapter 14 (tie)

Best Feminine-looking Male except Lucius: 1st Midir ; 2nd Xane ; 3rd Soren

Easiest Boss: 1st Batta ; 2nd Lorenz ; 3rd Greil

Best Written Character: 1st Sigurd ; 2nd Trabant ; 3rd Jill

Besr Version of the FE Theme: 1st FE3, FE4, FE7 and FE11 (tie)

Previous winners (Worst)

Worst NPC: 1st- The three generic Caelin soldiers in FE7 ; 2nd- Lachesis' 3 Pallies and FE8 Chapter 19 Armor Knights (tie)

Worst Swordmaster: 1st- Karla ; 2nd- Shanam ; 3rd- Lucia

Worst Hair: 1st- Vaida ; 2nd- Gheb, Lowen, and Makalov (tie)

Worst Non-Final Boss: 1st- Aion ; 2nd- Toras ; 3rd Batta the Beast

Worst Thief: 1st- Cath ; 2nd- Daisy ; 3rd- Ricardo

Worst Personal Weapon: 1st- FE9 Rolf's Bow ; 2nd- Sol Katti ; 3rd- Daim Thunder, Ettard, Amiti of FE9, and Caldabolg (tied)

Worst Chapter: 1st- Lyn's prologue normal mode ; 2nd- FE6 chapter 14 ; 3rd- FE7 Chapter 11 (Eliwood's tale), FE10 4-1, FE10 1-5, FE4 chapter 7, and FE7 16x/17x (tie)

Worst Final chapter: 1st- FE6 ; 2nd- FE10 ; 3rd- FE8

Worst Final Boss Weapon: 1st- Dark breath ; 2nd- Nightmare ; 3rd- Ravager

Worst Personality: 1st- Aran and Vika (tie) ; 3rd- Soren, Florina, Horace and Clarine (tie)

Worst Rapist or Attempted Rapist: 1st- Gheb ; 2nd- Oliver ; 3rd- General Lang, Eliot, Garnef, and Narshen (tie)

Worst Tactician: 1st- Malledus ; 2nd- Mark ; 3rd- Soren

Worst Est archetype: 1st- Sophia ; 2nd- Est and Fiona (Tie)

Worst GBA critical animation: 1st- Great Knight ; 2nd- Thief ; 3rd- Mage, Bishop, Pirate, Soldier, and Ewan (tie)

Worst Console critical animation; 1st- FE10 Sword Armor ; 2nd- FE4 Mage Knight ; 3rd- FE4 Bow Users

Worst Epilogue: 1st- FE9 ; 2nd- FE11 ; 3rd- FE8 and FE4 (tie)

Worst Gato Archetype: 1st- Karel ; 2nd- Gato/Gotoh ; 3rd- Lehran

Worst DS critical animation: 1st- Sorceror, General (Bow), Mage (tie)

Worst Form of Abuse: 1st-Battle Save Abuse; 2nd-Arena Abuse; 3rd-RNG Stat Abuse

Worst FE: 1st- FE1 ; 2nd- FE7 and 8 (tie)

Worst Ruler: 1st- Desmond; 2nd- Dheginsea; 3rd- Mordred, Alvis, Darin, Talis, Nailah, Micaiah, Victor (7 way tie )

Worst Gaiden chapter: 1st- FE5 24x; 2nd- FE7 19xx(HM); 3rd- FE5 14x, FE6 22x, FE7 31x(HM), FE11 16x (tie)

Worst Unit: 1st- Bantu; 2nd- Yuno and Lyre (tie)

Worst Merc/Hero: 1st- FEDS Samson ; 2nd- Oujay ; 3rd- FE3 Samson

Worst Paladin (Anything that promotes into it as well): 1st- Arran ; 2nd- Zealot ; 3rd- Vyland

Worst Peg Knight: 1st- FEDS Est ; 2nd- FE6 Yuno ; 3rd- Sigrun, FE9 Elincia, Florina and Syrene (tie)

Worst Defense Chapter: 1st- FE7 C15 ; 2nd- FE9 C13 ; 3rd- FE7 C18 (HM), FE7 C28 (HM), FE9 C8, FE10 1-5, FE10 3-5 (tie)

Worst Archer/Sniper/Marksmen: FE6 Wolt ; 2nd- FE5 Ronan, FE9 Rolf (tie)

Worst Desert Chapter: 1st FE6 Arcadia ; 2nd FE9 Chapter 15 ; 3rd FE10 4-3

Least Hyped: 1st Thomas ; 2nd FE10 Aran ; 3rd Eliwood ; Arum and Syrene (Tied)

Worst Addition to the Game Series: 1st Reclass ; 2nd GBA support system ; 3rd Fatigue

Worst Lord Unit: 1st Lyn ; 2nd Roy ; 3rd Micaiah

Least Generic Playable Character: 1st Levin ; 2nd Oliver ; 3rd Ardan

Worst Castle: 1st Nados Castle ; 2nd Laus (yes, a territory was voted as the second worst castle) ; 3rd Araphen Castle, Jehanna Hall, Castle Nox and Castle Goldoa

Worst Dragonkid: 1st Al ; 2nd Myrrh ; 3rd Chiki

Worst Staff: 1st Silence ; 2nd Berserk ; 3rd Again

Worst Knight/General: 1st Wendy ; 2nd Meg ; 3rd Ardan

Worst Priest/Cleric/Bishop: 1st Corple ; 2nd Wrys ; 3rd Renault

Worst Glass Cannon: 1st Lilina ; 2nd Diadora, Micaiah, Sophia (3 way tie)

Worst Wyvernrider: 1st Eda ; 2nd FEDS!Est ; 3rd Zeiss

Worst Chapter Goal: 1st Seize ; 2nd Rout ; 3rd Survive and Escape (tie)

Worst First Boss: 1st O'Neill ; 2nd Greil ; 3rd Lawrence

Least Important Stat: 1st Resistance ; 2nd Luck ; 3rd Skill

Worst Red/Green Knight: 1st Alec ; 2nd Noish ; 3rd Alva

Worst Healer (primary use is healing): 1st Renault ; 2nd FE10!Oliver and Wrys (tie)

Worst Prologue Chapter: 1st FE7 (Lyn's Mode) ; 2nd FE8 Prologue ; 3rd FE9 Prologue and FE10 3-P (tie)

Worst Weapon Type: 1st Knives ; 2nd Dark Magic ; 3rd Axes

Worst Generic Weapon: 1st FE10!Longbows ; 2nd Slim Sword ; 3rd Hammer

Worst Female Physical Fighting Unit: 1st Wendy ; 2nd Lyre ; 3rd Yunno

Worst Jeigen (Seth and FE9!Titania excluded): 1st Arran; 2nd Eyevel ; FEDS!Jeigan

Worst Player Phase Battle Music: 1st FE8 Attack ; 2nd Clash, March, FE6!Attack and FE7!Strike (four way tie)

Worst Support Unit: 1st FEDS!Rickard ; 2nd Cath ; 3rd FE9!Sothe

Worst Terrain Type: 1st Desert, 2nd Peak ; 3rd FE5!Throne

Worst Facial Hair: 1st FE9!Lekain ; 2nd FE6!Bartre ; 3rd Dozla

Worst Skill: 1st Shriek ; 2nd Sure Strike ; 3rd Mercy

Worst Unlockable Character: 1st FE9!Oliver ; 2nd Valter and Lyon (tie)

Worst Non-recruitable Female Boss (Excluding Ashera): 1st Hilda ; 2nd Sonia ; 3rd Petrine

Worst Green-haired Archer: 1st FE11!Tomas ; 2nd Wolt ; 3rd FE9!Rolf

Worst Offense: 1st FE9!Sothe ; 2nd Sylvia ; 3rd Lara

Worst Recruitment Theme: 1st FE2 ; 2nd FE6 ; 3rd FE8

Worst Character Name: 1st Dorcas ; 2nd Erk ; 3rd Carrion

Worst Support Conversation: 1st Hector/Florina C ; 2nd Lance/Alan C ; 3rd Vaida/Dorcas C

Worst Enemy Recruit: 1st Oliver; 2nd Cath ; 3rd FE11!Rickard

Worst Weapon Name: 1st Double Bow ; 2nd Lughnasdh ; 3rd Laundry Pole

Worst Artwork: FE1!Dolph ; 2nd Lance ; 3rd FE9!Tormod

Worst Canon Couple: 1st MicaiahXSothe and AstridXMakalov (tie) ; 3rd AbelXEst

Worst Crack pairing: 1st IkeXMia ; 2nd MarcusXMerlinus and IkeXSoren (tie)

Worst Japanese Name: 1st Tomth, Asseray and Xyst (tie)

Worst Princess: 1st Almedha ; 2nd Eirika ; 3rd Clarine

Worst Prince: 1st Zephiel ; 2nd Marth ; 3rd Levin

Worst Soundtrack: 1st FE6 ; 2nd FE7 ; 3rd FE8

Worst Fighter or Warrior: 1st FE7!Bartre ; 2nd FE11!Cord ; 3rd Wade

Worst Country Name: 1st Gra ; 2nd Carcino ; 3rd Dolhr

Worst Twins: 1st Lethe/Lyre ; 2nd Yumina/Yubello ; 3rd Ephraim/Eirika

Worst Story: 1st FE6 ; 2nd FE11 ; 3rd FE8

Worst Legendary Hero: 1st Dheginsea ; 2nd Bramimond and St. Elimine (tie)

Worst Quote: 1st Ranulf: "It's General Zelgius. Next time you see him, Ike, use caution. He's your enemy. He's the one. He's the Black Knight.", Soldier: "Altea and Aurelis and Akaneia...The League of A's, you might say!" (tie) ; 3rd Greil: "Ike? Stay back!", Pelleas: You're going to pay! You're going to BLARGHHHH! (tie)

Worst Generic Boss: 1st Gheb ; 2nd Norris ; 3rd Batta

Least Depressing Ending: 1st FE10 ; 2nd FE6 ; 3rd FE9 and FE11 (tie)

Worst reference to Plant life: 1st Lyn's "Ocean of grass" ; 2nd Dandelion Gang ; 3rd Sue's "Sound of the wind, smell of the grass"

Worst Red-haired Unit: 1st Ewan ; 2nd FE11!Vyland ; 3rd Roy

Worst Map Theme: 1st Wind Across the Plains ; 2nd Change of Scenery ; 3rd A Gathering of Storms

Worst Non-Jeigan Prepromote: 1st Wallace and Shanam (tie) ; 3rd Hannibal

Worst Brother: 1st Makalov ; 2nd Matthis ; 3rd Michalis and Karel (tie)

Worst In-game Nickname: 1st Rave ; 2nd Pookums and Raven (tie)

Worst Bro: 1st Lekain ; 2nd Eltshan, Karel, Leonardo and Izuka (tie)

Worst Fog of War map: 1st FE7 Chapter 26E/28H ; 2nd FE6 Chapter 14 ; 3rd FE10 Chapter 1-9

Worst Feminine-looking Male except Lucius: 1st Valtome ; 2nd Soren ; 3rd Arthur

Most Difficult Boss: 1st FE12!Medeus ; 2nd FE9!Black Knight ; 3rd Gomez

Worst Written Character: 1st Micaiah ; 2nd Roy ; 3rd Lyn and Eirika (tie)

Worst Version of the FE theme: 1st FE6 ; 2nd FE7 ; 3rd FE8

Nominations

Best/Worst Boss Quote (2)

Best/Worst Pet

Most/Least Badass Unit

Best/Worst Healing Items (inc. staves)

Most/Least Attractive Character (2)

Best/Worst Dodge Animation (2)

Best Worst Mount Name

Best/Worst Hardcore Character

Best/Worst Deceased Character

Most/Least Masculine Male

Most/Least Interesting Character

Best/Worst Protective Item

Best/Worst Recruit Convo

Most/Least Conclusive Ending

Best/Worst Final Boss Battle Music

Most Easy/Difficult Chapter

Best/Worst Mount

Best/Worst Chapter Map

Bets/Worst End Credits Theme

Best/Worst Verbal Tic (3)

Least/Most Ugliest Generic Boss (2)

Best/Worst Death Theme

Best/Worst Enemy Phase Battle Theme

Best/Worst Special Battle Theme (4)

Best/Worst Character Theme (3)

Best/Worst World Map Theme (2)

Best/Worst Rout Map

Best/Worst Headgear

Best/Worst Unit with realistic hair colour

Best/Worst Sister

Best/Worst Ogma Archetype

Best/Worst Plot Twist (2)

Most Underrated/Overrated FE (8)

Best/Worst Sound Effect

Best/Worst Masculine-looking Female (5)

Best/Worst Masculine Male

Best/Worst Holy/Legendary Weapon (2)

Best/Worst Version of Wrath

Best/Worst Flying Unit

Best/Worst Member Badge

Best/Worst Late Non-Final Boss (2)

Best/Worst Base Preparation Music

Best/Worst Preparation Screen Music (3)

Best/Worst Skills Combo (2)

Best/Worst Bald Unit

Best/Worst Boss theme (2)

Best/Worst Manakete/Laguz

Best/Worst Defence (2)

Best/Worst Character Design (3)

Best/Worst Text Sound

Best/Worst Triangle Attack

Best/Worst Looking Male Unit (2)

Most Underrated/Overrated FE

Underrated: FE11

Overrated: FE4 (from what I've heard)

*Gets some popcorn ready*

Edited May 29, 2011 by NinjaMonkey

[eclipse]

Underrated: Shadow Dragon. Reclassing rocks.

Overrated: Sacred Stones. Sorry guys.

Nominate: Best/Worst Masculine Female (or something like that)

[I.M. Gei]

Underrated: Shadow Dragon. I don't think it deserves all that crap it gets from the fans =/

Overrated: FE7

Edited May 22, 2011 by Tiki's Pet Pikachu

[Second Pronoun]

Underated: Fire emblem Gaiden

Overrated: Fire Emblem 7

[Non-Existent Member]

o_O

Underrated: TearRing Saga Fire Emblem Gaiden

Over-rated: Radiant Dawn

[Dr. Tarrasque]

Underrated: Gaiden.

Overrated: FE7. Honorable mention to Radiant Dawn and FE4.

Try to ignore some of the "overrated and underrated" nominations. Discussion of what is and isn't overrated is overrated.

Edited May 22, 2011 by Sirius

[dondon151]

Underrated: Radiant Dawn

Overrated: Genealogy of the Holy War

[Junkhead]

Most underrated is FE5, easily. Too much whining about "oh no it's too hard". Bullshit, you know you love it.

Most overrated is FE4, easily as well. A mention goes for FE10, which is basically a bait for newcomer n00bs that are most likely graphic whores.

[Maji]

Underrated: FE5, all I hear is "OMG FE7 IS HARD, SO I LOVE IT!", FE5 is harder and better if you ask me. Honourable mentions to 2 and 11.

Overrated: FE7- not only is the soundtrack overhyped (it's rather hideous much like most GBA music if you ask me), which FE4 can at least hold its own in the sound department and then some, but compared to the Jugdral series, FE7 just doesn't match up to par with them.

[Silvercrow]

Overrated: FE4. I like the game and all, but it's simply not THAT good.

Underrated: FE5, simply because a lot of people shy from it because of its "difficulty" while ignoring the fantastic design of the game itself.

Edited May 22, 2011 by Silvercrow

[Mousefire]

Underrated: Shadow Dragon

Not my favorite, but I would never call it bad as some do.

Overrated: Genealogy of the Holy War

I love FE4, but it isn't deserving of all the praise it gets. The story is good, but its characters feel a bit dull, and the gigantic maps are a hassle at times. The only reason it's still my favorite game over FE5 is due to the pairing system.

Also, since when is FE10 overrated? I always thought people disliked it due to the plot and lack of supports.

Edited May 22, 2011 by Mousefire

[Icon of Sin]

Overrated : FE7

Underrated : TearRing Saga FE5.

[Ϲharlie]

Overrated: Gaiden

Underrated: Mystery of the Emblem

[Darros]

Overrated: FE7.

Underrated: FE11.

[Radiant Dragon]

Underrated: FE10. The gameplay's great and the story isn't as bad as people say.

Overrated: FE4. It's fine the first time, but you spend more time moving place to place rather than actually doing anything. The story's nothing special after the first generation, either.

[Anouleth]

Underrated: Sacred Stones

Overrated: Genealogy of the Holy War

[Bearissoslow]

lol @ people listing FE7 as overrated. Most fans hate the fuck out of it.

Overrated: FE6

Underrated: FE7 /troll

Edited May 22, 2011 by Bearissoslow

[Salad Utensil]

Overrated: FE4 it was fun once or twice, but overkill gets boring after awhile.

Underrated: FE5 excellent map design, great new mechanics introduced to the series (rescuing, capture, move-stars, pcc, con), decent story, mages actually NOT being mediocre.

[Charpig]

Overrated: Seisen no Keifu

Underrated: Shadow Dragon

[Junkhead]

Overrated: Gaiden

You troll, people barely even talk about Gaiden.

Underrated: FE5 excellent map design, great new mechanics introduced to the series (rescuing, capture, move-stars, pcc, con), decent story, mages actually NOT being mediocre.

Mages weren't mediocre prior to that, though. There are just more decent Mages in FE5.

Also, since when is FE10 overrated? I always thought people disliked it due to the plot and lack of supports.

I've seen people make a big deal out of the gameplay IIRC. Or maybe just because it had the best graphics.

Edited May 22, 2011 by Soul

[Randoman]

Most Overrated: FE4

Most Underrated: FE11

And I nominate Most/Least Attractive Character (this is based off looks right?).

Also, NinjaMonkey, you might need this for reference:

FE1 = Ankoku Ryu to Hikari no Tsurugi/Dark Dragon and Sword of Light

FE2 = Gaiden

FE3 = Monshou no Nazo/Mystery of the Emblem

FE4 = Seisen no Keifu/Genealogy of the Holy War

FE5 = Thracia 776 (I'm as clueless about the 776 part as you are. I know that Thracia is a territory in Jugdral though)

FE6 = Sword of Seals

FE7 = Blazing Sword

FE8 = Sacred Stones

FE9 = ...wait, you probably don't need 9 and 10's

FE11 = Shadow Dragon

FE12 = Shin Monshou no Nazo Hikari to Kage no Eiyuu/New Mystery of the Emblem

Edited May 22, 2011 by Randoman

[pat726]

Did someone really put sacred stones as overrated? All I've ever heard about that game was negative. Anyways, here mine:

Overrated: path of radiance

Underrated: thracia 776

[Junkhead]

I nominated Most Least Attractive character as well. Again. For the third time.

[Maji]

And I nominate Most/Least Attractive Character (this is based off looks right?).

FE5 = Thracia 776 (I'm as clueless about the 776 part as you are. I know that Thracia is a territory in Jugdral though)

It's set in the year 776 to set up a subtle (or at least as I interpreted it) joke at the end.

Also, for Attractive: I think if we end up doing this, this should be based on two votes for most attractive (male and female), as we all have our sexual preferences.

[Jaybee]

Underrated: FE5

Overrated: FE7