Rapier

The problem is, why would he lie about targetting you on N0, and then tell Sho he was going to target you on N1 while choosing to target BBM? He didn't need to go that far. All he needed was to say "sorry, I don't trust you enough to tell you who I'm targetting this Night/who I targetted last Night". Now, why is it illogical that you and Baldrick are scumbuddies? If your item really helps him act twice during the Night, he could've easily targetted two of us three and found out who has the ingredients. Either way, the Item Cop is suspicious of lying when he did not need to.

The screenshot size is nice, at least for me. I'll be following this run.

Rein being killed for some other reason than the stone is a big coincidence. I'd rather work with hypothesis that are not coincidences. Now, Baldrick certainly seems scummy. I've been thinking about the possibility of an item cop verifying Rein's item somehow, and my theory evolved into this: Rein had interactions with Scorri (confirmed by Elie) -> Scorri told Baldrick to check Rein's items and got all the materials as the result (they could've used Scorri's magical clock to act twice and figure out who had the components, since both me and Sho were clearly alchemists) -> They killed him on D2. Either way, should Baldrick turn out to be scum, the possibility of Scorri also being scum is pretty high. Elie -could- have sold Rein to the Mafia, but I think it'd be hard to guess he was the holder of all the components. It's not hard if you have a hutch and an item cop with you, however. Seeing how Baldrick was too opportunistic to place a vote on anyone in D1 as long as he had an excuse for it, I have no objections really. ##Vote: Baldrick

I didn't let anyone in on this secret. I don't know about Rein's hidden agenda, however. Also, you are insulting my intelligence. Do you really think I would kill Rein and narrow the suspect list to me and Sho? No. I'd have him "in my side" and Sho as well, instead of becomming a suspect. Also, if I'm Cult, then that means I was not the one to snitch Rein.

Me.

Elie's claim seems consistent. He claimed Magus before we could even figure out there was one in the game... And Rein's death just proved us there is one. He could've just claimed Uncultable, but his Magus claim does not contradict the info we got now. I admit there are other ways to know if there is a Magus in the game before it even starts, but all we know is only the Cult knew that, and he couldn't be the mastermind. Now now, Baldrick, are you saying I'm possibly a Mafia Vanilla? Sho and I roleclaimed at the same time, we both said we were vanillas, hence why we believed Rein's claim, too much of a coincidence. While I have no evidence to prove myself otherwise, I want to make this clear that we roleclaimed to each other (and other people, such as Xinny and Elie, knew I was one too).

Care to explain why, instead of saying "I believe this guy here did something bad, so *votes*"? Thank you very much. I believe Sho's town because we revealed we were Vanilla Townies at the same time, and I don't belive this is a coincidence. Nothing stops one of us from being in the Cult, however.

Why would Sho tell us the Werewolves have the Philosopher's Stone if, theoretically, he's one of them? He should've just stayed silent about this, and nobody would have learned about it (and by it I mean, Rein had the ingredients for the stone). Unless I'm forgetting something important.

Two people with uncultable roles? That's... Weird, to say the least. Is it common for scum in other games being immune to Cult?

My thoughts exactly. He can brag about having Ike in his family. :3

Unvote ##Vote: Kay Because seriously, even though she's busy (and has been acting like this in many games so far), at least she should've done something about her inactivity instead of saying she was lazy. At least 13th is talking and we can get more info from him.

Why do you agree with the case and vote Mancer if you think it's fishy? I see opportunist scum. Honestly, both Baldrick and 13th look bad to me. The former was opportunistic enough to vote Mancer, and then vote Sho just because he called him for a policy lynch (note: those are dangerous, as scum can vote someone and say it was just a joke). 13th is another opportunistic guy who didn't stand for either cause when BBM voted Mancer, he said the later was scummy from BBM's arguments but the former was also scummy and his case was fishy. Now he picks a completely random post and votes Helios by using Strawman's Fallacy in one of his lines. Hence why 13th receives my vote. I wish we could actually get more info since, well, it's OC and all, but all the info I got are not conclusive enough to prove someone is scum or cult, so I have to do the whole NOC proccess once again in D1 and see if I'm right or wrong. ##Vote: 13th

I like the world of Mega Man Battle Network, even though I hated the gameplay... Oh so very much. I'd like to live in a futuristic setting with a NAVI and participate in awesome battles. Mega Man ZX is also cool... But it sucks if you don't have access to a Biometal, as it means you're screwed by those who have. Gensokyo would be great, but the ammount of random nonsense pisses me off.

The contradiction on Mancer's story makes me willing to vote him, honestly. He says he targetted Shinori, yet got BBM's item. There's no way out of this unless there is another scum Thief. Mancer's excuse is a paradox.

I'll most certainly read a LP of this. I considered playing Rance once, but the weak plot and focus on porn made me go look for something better. Even so, it looks fun and I'd rather be proved wrong.

And no one will suspect you if you do, even if it's a hot, sunny day.

- Ballistas are useless. - Rocks are as strong as pebbles. - You can never count on reinforcements to help you. They're just a bunch of Red Shirts who were supposed to help you, but will need YOUR help after they Leeroy Jenkins around and get owned. They're also jerks who steal all your EXP. - I still don't understand why axes are inaccurate and weak agaisnt swords.

I'm not even sure about what I should be doing in N0 and I have no info, but my skype is Lorddomu, if anyone wants to contact me.

I wonder if the Wolfguard will appear next chapter (in my playthrough I didn't bother with talking to them, I just lolwarped Marth to the boss and seized on turn 2) since you made them retreat. Either way, next chapter's plain annoying.

wrong game I'm so hype, totally going to use that water type first. I still have lots of time to buy a 3DS, gladly.

I'd say you have to watch it first in order to judge it by yourself. There are so many opinions about it that it's hard to say "it sucks" or "it's good". I found the premise very cool, but then it just disappointed me. The fact that Kirito is a God Sue doesn't help.

Sign me in, I'll try to play better than on Life's OC game (because I didn't know where to start from, now I've got an idea).

So the other seasons are worse than the first? ... Screw that, I'll never watch SAO again and waste bandwithd connection with it. I've been watchin SAO recently and it disappointed me in many ways. I imagined some kind of .hack meets Greed Island Arc of HunterxHunter, but the whole setting is completely wasted imo. There is little to no world building, Kirito starts as an OPed Sue and stays like this throughout the anime, the story arc is disappointing... the list goes on. Now I plan to get back to Helsing, which I've put on hiatus for a while because of some VNs. Meanwhile, I'm waiting for more Akame ga Kiru! chapters because I love that manga soooo much (if anyone can recommend me a manga similar to it, please tell me). Do you mean this Magi?

Give me an example of a Cleric that can take a hit and not die, then. I don't like Yumina much just because of her starting stats, level, and only appearing in Chapter 5 (or was it 4?). Malliesia is good, though.

I oftenly download my games in both options. I think I've only brought 3 games so far (without pirating). I think this is justified in my case since everything here is expensive as hell (Skyrim is roughly 180 bucks here), there's no way I'm going to spend that much money in a single game. And don't let me get started with the consoles' prices. When I start working, I'll consider stopping. Until then, I'll join Jack Sparrow on his adventures. Uh, same thing here. At least PC games are purchasable, so I tend to buy through Steam. Sooo much practical.