Jump to content

RADicate

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    9

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Posts posted by RADicate

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    10 hours ago, Magnificence Incarnate said:

    Well their tone felt like it had strong conviction in what they were trying to do?  Scum want to stay in the background and keep their options open for which wagon to push while town want to solve the game so they are proactive in their approach and are more confident in what they're trying to do. 

     

    @XnadrojX it makes him a good vote because his actions didn't actually do anything new? In rvs you need to push *something* but his interjection like, doesn't develop any new points so its likely to come from scum faking content?  Its worth a push if you ask me.

     

    I feel like people are scapegoating Bart for trying to start something in rvs like what happens every game he plays in and I'm not sold on him being scum. In fact I liked his defense in his last post to Claire and I think the frustration is genuine there. Also if Bart is scum why does he take the trouble to grill Amy and then go after Claire while talking about other people like weiner shows that he's putting in a lot of thought into why a person would act the way they do as either alignment which is p gamesolvey. As scum all Bart has to do is sheep amph's vote, get out of the thread and come back later to watch the shenanigans, the stuff people are talking about from Bart sounds as unnecessary overplay from scum. 

    The last paragraph is just a really long winded way to say tldr scum should low effort there. Which is........eh? I guess i get the POV but from a perenial d1 lynch under heat during d1, regardless of faction he'd want to get out of, and thus put forth the effort to do so? I disagree with the point, the skeptic in me feels like a bit of a white knight , but a d1 townread under heat warrants defense regardless of faction so meh. 

    I've given my thoughts on the Ichigo case already (or at least's marth's variation of it). So i'll refrain from repeating what I said before on that front. (Skipped next post because it was in relation solely to the ichigo case from marth which is a weak case at best, and a stretch of a shade at worst.

    10 hours ago, Magnificence Incarnate said:

    @Refa @Athena_57 You should totally sheep my case on ichigo, his content doesn't push the game state forward as town, easily fakeable as mafia and is exactly what I'd expect mafia to do at this point of the game. 

     

    I'd sheep your amph case after her last post, plus I didn't realize that she hadn't voted Claire, which looks shady in hindsight now.  But more importantly,  the RAD vote feels like a safe vote and just outright dropping the Claire case feels very iffy to me after how she made it out to be a big deal initially. I still think ichigo is the better vote here though. 

     

    Also sully and via are locktown IMO. 

    Agree on the sully townread ig? (I dont have this via metaread the rest of the game has sorry, yall do your thing tho)Mmmm, ngl on reread I dislike this sequence considerably more than just "not a fan of the case". Gut almost says this is.... systematic for the lack of a better term. Going through the motions ig. Find a case on someone that is shaping up to a potential ML---> ask for people to follow----> "eeeeh i like your case but mine's better"----> state a couple of townreads (one of which is universal, and i'd personally be shocked if anyone SR'd sully rn, those two townreads seem almost too easy.)Idk maybe im looking too much into it, either way.... 

    ##Vote: @Magnificence Incarnate

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    1 minute ago, RADicate said:

    I dont think marth's case on him is very well founded, and I have a pretty bad habit of giving headstrong/aggressive tones a pass. Tha being said I need to see more out of the slot. Tennative townlean based on that tone with the modifier that i want dat CONTENT  (has he been ITT today? @Ichigo wya)

    Wbu?

    EBWOP: as in what do you dislike about him beyond the fact i dont think he has done much in the way of analyzing/trying to solve slots (which is something i'll take issue with if he doesnt pick up Soon:tm:)

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    3 minutes ago, Shinori said:

    Hrmm, ok.  It just stood out to me as weird.  What are your thoughts on Ichigo?

    I dont think marth's case on him is very well founded, and I have a pretty bad habit of giving headstrong/aggressive tones a pass. Tha being said I need to see more out of the slot. Tennative townlean based on that tone with the modifier that i want dat CONTENT  (has he been ITT today? @Ichigo wya)

    Wbu?

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    20 minutes ago, Shinori said:

    I like weiners posts.  Dislike Ichigo at the moment, but I don't know if that's just a factor of playstyle as it appears I've scumread him in every game I've played with him now.

    Where are you going with this?

    Nowhere tbh, reading refa's posts feels wierd for w/e reason. I cant really explain it. It might just be a general tonal thing from refa. I dont particularly think he's scummy or anything (he hasnt done much, hard null atm) So i'm asking for thoughts for my own sake. 

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    1 minute ago, Bartozio said:

    Hmm, okay. I feel like he has voiced enough suspision about me and Marth to not make me think of a slow starter that much tbh. Could be me missreading his tone there I guess, since he didn't place a vote yet (which I dislike, but let's not go there).

    How do you feel about Marth then?

    Bunny girl sempai is pretty much my favorite show this season, so good taste there!

    I didn't dislike the ending, apart from it not really feeling as an ending.

    If I said I disliked Kill la Kill and Guren Lagan, would you still recommend it to me?

    Fair enough, my bad about forgetting you asking her for previous games, lol.

    Btw, I'm assuming I don't need to tell you you're free to ask me questions about stuff, right?

    Idk, slight scumlean ig, like i said the push felt nitpicky and it felt like marth immediately came to the negative conclusion before weighing the possiblities (dunn's kneejerk to your comments vs him just trying to throw shade at you). @Magnificence Incarnate you should walk me through why you feel why its the latter of those two possibilities as opposed to the former.

    Mostly mentioned the whole slow start thing that since it was part of marth's case (the whole not providing meaningful content and pushing gamestate forward and the fact the comment came less than halfway through d1)=worth addressing. 

    I touted bunny girl as the best show of the season until the last ep, after which i gave the title to Zombieland Saga (also worth a watch, and im not an idol fan either, so unbiased on that front)

    Ur taste is wild >_>

    Imma say yes wrt jojo, it doesnt mirror the style of either of those shows by a long stretch. (both of those shows i loved though, i need to rewatch Kill la Kill soon) (i'll hyu soon:tm: @Ampharos)

    Im fine just talking to you like this tbh, helps me out more than anything else would d1. But since you mentioned it~~

    Thoughts on refa atm?

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    6 minutes ago, Refa said:

    Not gonna lie, I've been playing video games instead of playing this game. I'm just going to sheep Marth until I reread, which might be a while. 

    What are the votals? How much time is left?

    ##Unvote

    ##Vote: @Ichigo

    like 32 hours till deadline and im way too lazy to figure out votals for you

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    17 minutes ago, Bartozio said:

    Watched any good anime recently?

    For starters, what do you think of Marths case on Dunn? And Dunns play in general?

    Impressions on Amy and Claire might be nice as well, partially because I never really played a town game with them, so you might have more to go on than me there.

    Oh i forgot about the other half of the question OOPS

    i dont have enough mafia experience with either claire or amy to help you out on any meta reads soz i did get claire to link a couple games earlier itt that i need to look through, im being really lazy about it though

    gut says tone is natural for claire but like i said im lazy on homework atm so thats pendingish

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    7 hours ago, Magnificence Incarnate said:

    Hmm at this point since the narrative is a scum!Bart tunnel I'd expect scum to add fuel to the fire while maintaining a low presence/making safe votes. I'm confident in my town read on Bart for now so, 

    ##unvote ##vote: @Ichigo

     

    You fit the bill!  Also you've got your evidence wrong, 

    No he didn't, he voted amph for what he perceived to be a shady vote on Claire and then sheeped amph's vote when he got her explanation.  This sounds like an argument tailored to suit the consensus narrative on Bart, which is p scummy. 

     

     

    7 hours ago, Magnificence Incarnate said:

    @Refa @Athena_57 You should totally sheep my case on ichigo, his content doesn't push the game state forward as town, easily fakeable as mafia and is exactly what I'd expect mafia to do at this point of the game. 

     

    I'd sheep your amph case after her last post, plus I didn't realize that she hadn't voted Claire, which looks shady in hindsight now.  But more importantly,  the RAD vote feels like a safe vote and just outright dropping the Claire case feels very iffy to me after how she made it out to be a big deal initially. I still think ichigo is the better vote here though. 

     

    Also sully and via are locktown IMO. 

    Err the only two posts i could find in reference to that, (if i missed any lmk)

    Honestly, feels weak. Mild bias towards players who take awhile to get rolling (i hate d1 myself) esp during EARLY d1. Not to defend his point but that "not pushing gamestate forward" can probably apply to a solid half the game? Nitpicky imo, willing to call that null on dunn.

    That being said I can see where marth is coming from wrt Dunn stretching out bartz's "read" on claire as coming into thread with an agenda to get a SR going on Claire upon second look. I'm pretty 50/50 on whether dunn just had a kneejerk to bartz's claire comments early or genuinely was trying to shade though. @Bartozio 

    Also i just finished bunny girl senpai, fwiw.(Great show, could ramble about the ending for a bit but i seem to be in the minority on that one) 

    Also i finally started jojo recently, show's great

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    god quoting things between pages is hard so you guys are gonna wind up getting a couple posts, 

    10 hours ago, XnadrojX said:

    I hate names that end with 'S' because it ends up like, do I use Ampharos' posts, or like, Ampharoses posts, or like, posts from Ampharos and it's like dksbfjslfuckingenglishnfkekshdue. Walrein was a much better name :c

     

    Anyways, I think their recent posts are townie. I can get behind their RADicate read.

    ##Vote: @RADicate

     

    He solves himself if he's Town pretty sure.

    Alright xnad, lets get this out of the way just like every other game. If you are scum you should know better than to pick a fight with me :D

    That being said what about amy's read do you agree with? To me amy's comments wrt me weren't much of a read at all and more of a "get your act together and start being productive"?  

    So i'm confused as to what you see here?

    9 hours ago, XnadrojX said:

    BTW a very easy way to see if RAD is scum is to see if he reads me wrong. Guy has 100% accuracy on my alignment as Town.

     

    weinerboy, so is there a problem with people approaching the Bart slot slowly with a long stick rather than just "taking the straightforward approach"?

    The former part makes no sense coming from a town POV, if i were to be scum, and if you were to be town, logically I would know you are town and could very easily fabricate a townread on you, why is my read on you at all AI in this scenario?

    Also if you could, walk me through your overall thoughts on amy and what about them pings you as town? 

     

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    1 minute ago, Shinori said:

    What the fuck is happening?

    I actually like Amph's overall posts, they don't make me instantly remember cuphead mafia.  It's a good feeling.

    Not really feeling a vote on claire mainly just cause I don't really see a reason to.  I also don't see a reason to town read her yet though so.

    Marth's post sounds weird to me. @Magnificence IncarnateCould you by any chance expand on your read on Wiener?  I felt the entire exchange between wiener/amph was nice and added discussion/comments of interest so I'd just like to understand your read here a bit more.  Also if possible, how do you feel about Amph at the moment?

    I don't like Rad's jump. His first post just seems off to me.  @RADicateYou said Claire felt defensive; is this bad in your eyes?

    Chalking it up to a tonal thing for now at least, i'll get back to you on it after i look at those two games she sent me 

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    6 hours ago, Bartozio said:

    Because I can.

    I feel like this post has impatience behind it? The second line is pretty sarcastic and stuff, lol.

    I kind of get your point, but what I don't get is: why are you not voting her?

     

    6 hours ago, Bartozio said:

    Fair enough.

    I'd advice you to make sure your vote is either on who you suspect most or the person you're currently focussing on. That said:

    ##Unvote

    ##Vote: @Mitsuru Kirijo

    Btw, thoughts on Weiner so far?

    quoting the post this was replying to:

     

    6 hours ago, Ampharos said:

    It's easy enough to make sarcastic jokes, but her posts following that don't really follow up on that impatience.

    The answer to your question is: because I'm bad and don't move my vote around nearly as much as I should, as either alignment. I might vote her at some point, still rolling this whole thing around in my head a bit.

    I assume this is the exchange you wanted me to look back at. And ngl i kinda glossed over this upon initial readthrough. That being said even upon reread I read this more as a "sure thats a fair pov" (wrt the fair enough from bartz), even implying some level of mildmeld here that wasnt really hinted at it still feels like a leap to go from there to implying Claire as the de facto d1 lynch? Maybe im overblowing the implication of the quote below but eh. 

    5 hours ago, Bartozio said:

    K, fair enough. I liked Weiner's play so far, and I think the only agenda he could have for not joining the Claire band wagon is that they're both scum, which is a scenario we might as well consider after lynching Claire.

     

    @Athena_57 sorry for terribad formatting, too lazy to fix, if anything about that makes it unclear lmk

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    1 minute ago, Mitsuru Kirijo said:

    Tsk of course I'm not scum you fool. Why would I want to work with other dirty scum and get my hands dirty when I can be on my own as a wonderful town

    Of course, of course. I apologize for doubting you. But so I can prove your superiority to the world you should link me a recent towngame where you put forth considerable effort ~

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    1 minute ago, Mitsuru Kirijo said:

    Ew it's Rad. I guess it can be kinda seen as defensive. I kinda had a 'really?' moment with the whole first part but eh

    Ah Claire, its a wonder to see you as always. Please forgive my meager self for daring to criticize your posts, someone as gallant as you cant be scum right?

    :notlikenico:

     

    Arctic Mafia (Game Thread)

    in Mafia

    Posted

    8 hours ago, Ampharos said:

    Also please go see Into the Spider-Verse.

    is it actually good? I had low expectations for it ngl

    42 minutes ago, Mitsuru Kirijo said:

     

    Also as a blanket response to this: I was very clearly (well I guess not so clearly if I have to answer this) making jokes. I wasn’t impatient or anything of the sort. I’m really confused how you can even get that from my posting. Really I feel from my convo from Sully and overall tone it should be clear I was just making lighthearted posting.

    This is a pretty strange point A to point B mindset that I really really dislike from Bart. He goes on before talking on he’s not so sold on me being scum but I kid you not one post later he goes from ‘ehhh maybe’ to what I just quoted for you. That doesn’t seem real to me. That feels like someone who tried to fake understanding of a read and pretended to buy it right after that as an excuse to vote. His egging on of getting Ampharos to vote doesn’t help either. Just the overall confidence of this post is strange and off.

    ##Vote: @Bartozio

    ngl kneejerk from the first half of the post felt defensive might just be a tonal thing from claire tho

    that aside im down with the read on bartz

    ##Vote: @Bartozio

     

×
×
  • Create New...