Randa

I think we may have a difference in philosophy on this. Why take the risk of getting scum and having them twist your words in OC and get you lynched when you could just have OC with somebody who is likely to be town and have greater insight into their opinions. Also most neighborizers are more than one use so you can go off of a combination of your opinions and search using that. I find there's less risk for the same reward. But apparently my philosophy. And remember suspicion of Poly were raised at the end of day 1. Also why would SK kill town. The way I see I would go after scum right away. It's safer and makes it easier near endgame.

And wrt the way I handled GP I very simply thought we at L-2 so I didn't want to put it at L-1 and risk a hammer before she could claim. The claim didn't sway my opinion so I very simply voted for her.

So that happened. @Eury: I don't think I explained this very well. But when Poly and you both are suspected scum then its kinda hard to cleae either of you. As it stands you could both be scum and trying to clear each other. Though I doubt you both are. However it is the one thing that jumped out to me the most when I was Re-Reading.

Actually I don't think Eury has mentioned having OC with Poly at all. Now why would she do that?

And the point still stands that he chose to prove that other claim(neighborizer) on Eury, who had a decent sized wagon at the end of day one. So if they're both scum He clears himself by claiming and can then work on clearing Eury. Which is,what's happened. But I'm probably over thinking this. Either way I'd like to hear Poly's reasons for neigborizing Eury.

Whoops. I don't bother looking at gender. Maybe I should.

Oh god Eury. That's an awful restriction. Hysterical but awful. And that's weird. I used a Hand theme card against Scorri night 1. And had the same thing happen. Either somebody is extremely protective or he has some power/ability.

What on earth makes you think that. Also wrt Poly, I looked back through the ISO and he originally mentioned Eury back in day one when trying get her to claim. He also pretty much clears her Early day 2 and doesn't explain why. Then he explains the choice and the explanation is weird. Wy would you neighborize someone who is still under scrutiny. Why not go with somebody who was widely accepted as town and clear yourself? And looking back I can't say for sure you are the Vig. I think you are, but it could've been Garland/Baldrick and you claim the role after he was Vig. However this can easily be answered by Prims telling us if he redirected Poly night 1. Which would make no sense, because Prims wanted poly to shoot Kay. So there's no way he would redirect him to BBM. ##Vote Mango Sentinel To many things aren't adding up right now.

Am I just missing something or is this just the first you've mentioned Shinori as scum?

Lets try it without a host. This can't end well. It'll be just like chess. oh wait I suck at chess

Okay so same as usual but I think we should go with averages this time.

Okay. So is anyone willing to host.

Thanks.

I lost my save files for this game. Can anybody give me a copy with Hector Hard Mode unlocked.

I kinda wanna try this. Anybody else up for it.

Why do people still think there was a cult in Hard Nocs. It was a move by scum that turned into a giant joke.

If there are no objections I'll put this to L-1. Remember we need a hammer. ##Vote: Green Pot

I'm not 100% sold on GP being scum. More like a 78% right now. As has been stated by everyone else seems to have her opinion swayed especially when it comes to making a vote. Her defense isn't great but I've seen worse, or have written worse. Not a horrible vote on Bear but again was to quick to move off of Bear in a non critical situation. I'm sorta just repeating myself so I'm gonna surmarize what this post is about. I'm not sure GP is scum but I'm willing to vote to secure a lynch.

I'm gonna be able to post actual thoughts in about thirty minutes so I won't vote till then.

Wow SF. I set up a nice and easy post to comment on or get reads from and actually have some activity, and we get two post, one of which has nothing to do with the post. And Scorri previous post wasnt meant to actually push a wagon on you. I simply copy pasted my mental notes, which had recnetly been updated, and hoped to get some conversation going. I didn't not want to try put together a case on GP right before I went to bed, because then it would be horrible and accomplish nothing. I should be able to put the case together before deadline though. So maybe I won't be completely useless.

Lets give a semi detailed read on Scorri because I don't feel like spending the next 45 minutes writing about GP and there the only two people who I have any relevant information to work with. So Scorri has for the most part been playing in way that is similar to Shinori. Both of them have had relatively few scumreads(I blame this on nobody actually posting) and voice their own opinion every so often. Rather Scorri works on finding holes in other people's post and hopes to find a scum slip. But I feel as if she's flown completely under the radar and has played a very clean and precise game. I don't think that means she's scum but I wonder how you can go a whole game without people finding something to pick apart. Unless you're being extremely cautious and making sure to avoid making slips. But this isn't reall anything more than my paranoid rambling. That being said I don't think Scorri is scum. But I don't know if she's town. I would prefer to have a bit more information on her but I doubt it will come out anytime soon.

All of these are very valid points. But I have one question for you. Of the points you brought how many of them can't be explained by the evolution of the thread and the interaction between posters. I do believ ISOs are useful but sometimes things make more sense in the context they were posted. And I already addressed why I didn't like Neko.

Yeah. And then everybody left me with all the work. I should be able to actually contribute tomorrow. And I might be around at the deadline. Depends on when how close we cut it.

Gotta love that SB bio.

Yeah we have 12 still alive. Not voting is Shinori, Myself, Eury and Bear.